Pick Your Power - Game. Set. Match.

[Cobalt]

Official Vote Count

Players needed to lynch: 10

BloodCovenent

- 1 - budja - (L-9)

budja

- 1 - BloodCovenent - (L-9)

devotress

- 7 - SerialClergyman, DeathNote, Farside22, Cobalt, TonyMontana, Vaya - (L-3)

drippinggoofball

- 1 - Faraday - (L-9)

elvis_knits

- 3 - Xylthixlm, Benmage, Seacore - (L-7)

SerialClergyman

- 1 - devotress - (L-9)

Vaya

- 2 - elvis_knits, drippinggoofball - (L-8)

Players not voting: Benmage, chamber, Cruciare, Dramonic, FishytheFish

dgb is town.
hey dgb, let's lynch devotress FIRST and then our little vaya problem might go away, if you catch my drift.

[Faraday]

why is she town? I genuinely don't see it, what am I missing?

also i'm pretty fucking sick atm so activity might be less than usual idk, depends on what the doctor suggests.

[Cobalt]

why is she town? I genuinely don't see it, what am I missing?

also i'm pretty fucking sick atm so activity might be less than usual idk, depends on what the doctor suggests.

cuz xyl is scum.

[Devotress]

Vaya's last post reeks of someone who hasn't even tried to pay attention to the thread. She came back (after ages) and responded to one post that was recent, and then repeated her post from like what, 10 days ago now or something?

Vote Vaya

Go read all 20 odd pages you didn't read and post something again please.

[chamber]

unvote vote devotress

[BloodCovenent]

[quote="chamber"]

unvote vote devotress

[/quote

Why? I agree that Vaya has been scummy.

[Cobalt]

unvote vote devotress

more posts like this

[chamber]

unvote vote devotress

[/quote

Why? I agree that Vaya has been scummy.

Shut up scum.

[BloodCovenent]

unvote vote devotress

Why? I agree that Vaya has been scummy.

Shut up scum.

......wow......

[farside22]

unvote vote devotress

more posts like this

Cheers in delight!

[Xylthixlm]

unvote vote devotress

[farside22]

Reading vaya in alone I have no sense of her or her reasoning thus far in the game.

Just so you see:

Vaya:

I still think devotress and BC are scum, BTW, and would be happy lynching either.

Vote: devotress

vaya:

I disagree with about half of Vi's list there(Budja, Vaya, SC, maybe Coug), though I really agree with the other few. And of those, and all the players here, Devotress is the scummiest in my eyes. I'd also support a Blood, Xyl, or Cobalt wagon if they start to grow.

Vote: Devotress

I don't ask about meta on others but to me this just reads either lazy or scummy. Voting without reason. Calling a person scum with no reason and following others logic without cause.
Does make me consider more on lynching vaya with all this right about now
but damn I get nothing but scum vibes from devotress. Choices, choices.

[Devotress]

I'm at L-1, since Xyl didn't bother to call it out.


Also what's the matter BC, wasn't chambers case against me so clear it convinced you?

@farside regarding choices. Look at the entirety of my wagon and decide who looks scummier myself or Vaya. As scummy as you might think I am, what's your opinion on the people hopping on my wagon?

[Cobalt]

claim or die
edit: claim and then die

[Devotress]

Vanilla.
I tried to become a doctor, incase too many people went for investigation roles without taking the protection role.

[Cobalt]

[]=======

[BloodCovenent]

Also what's the matter BC, wasn't chambers case against me so clear it convinced you?

nope... don't see any case by chamber.

[farside22]

I'm at L-1, since Xyl didn't bother to call it out.


Also what's the matter BC, wasn't chambers case against me so clear it convinced you?

@farside regarding choices. Look at the entirety of my wagon and decide who looks scummier myself or Vaya. As scummy as you might think I am, what's your opinion on the people hopping on my wagon?

*mutters*
*mutters*
*mutters*
*mutters*
*mutters*
*mutters*
*mutters*
*mutters*

I have too many things I have in my head now. I can almost see what dgb is saying about XYL with vaya now.
*feels head starting to hurt*
But then there is budja, you, fishy and BC on the other end.
Damn there is 2 scum teams.
*points to vaya*
please say something that gives me a sign to your thought process

[Cobalt]

[]=======

[BloodCovenent]

Damn there is 2 scum teams.

Yep, there are two teams of three.

[Xylthixlm]

why is she town? I genuinely don't see it, what am I missing?

also i'm pretty fucking sick atm so activity might be less than usual idk, depends on what the doctor suggests.

cuz xyl is scum.

Wrong

and

that wouldn't make DGB town even if it was true. Two scumteams, remember?

[Fishythefish]

Oooo L-1. Doctor is a pretty null pick.

Time for a catch up. Wish me luck – 17 pages to go.

Post 549 from DeathNote really, really tickles my scumdar. It feels like he is constantly distancing from his own opinions by using a lighthearted tone.

Simul hammer fail seems likely to be genuine mistake. It would be a terrible play as scum.

663 from Vi seems a bit odd. She posts the rather nice “top wagoner” statistic, and chamber criticises it as misleading. Vi then says that chamber’s stat isn’t worrying – but that’s not the point, and this assumption that people are thinking primarily about their own scumminess is a bit off for me. (edit: Vi has flipped town. I’ll let her off this time)

Again with using rolefishing as a tell, this time on SC. Can someone point me to some examples in their experience of scum fishing by saying “I think that {insert role here} should claim now”? It doesn’t happen.

Bloodcovenant’s 784 says that Vaya lurking when he’s lurked as scum before is null. Why? I see no reason to suppose activity (and particularly activity in comparison to other games) isn’t correlated with alignment. And odd thing to defend someone about.

I thought that DGB was claiming information that Devotress was not BP. So that he picked BP in the draft. @DGB: what did you mean when you said that Dev was not BP?

DGB’s 858 is an awesome tour de force of scumhunting. I doubt it’s actually right, but it’s produced good results. Faraday’s reply seems to be more picking at words than addressing the case itself: he makes an irrelevant point about the second scumgroup, and attacks old opinions of DGB’s. Neither of these is relevant here. He also claims that other things in Plum’s post did register – this is a non-argument, as the point being made is that they didn’t register originally – you can’t correct a scummy action after you’ve been called on it. Faraday’s response, rather than the initial case, makes me think him scum. If he’d said “that’s a pretty terrible, reaching, overelaborate scumtell”, I’d have some sympathy, but trying to pick at the factual accuracy of DGB’s idea stinks.

Looks at profile during the time. See's post when EK was brought up and 2 other post in other games before coming here. I welcome anyone else to look at your profile during that time period.

Yeah. I gave the timestamps of the posts concerned. Are you seriously saying it’s a scumtell that, when looking at my mafia games, I looked at this one third?

I’ve got surprisingly little to say. Faraday is scum, and BC probably is too. Votes for EK are still wasted votes – assuming she’s scum, her motivation is still to get rid of the other scum team. If she gives us a false guilty, she knows she’s dead. And even if we think the chances of her being town are 5% (which is ludicrously small), that is potentially a 5% where we just win the game.

vote: Faraday

, for what little it’s worth. Looks like devotress is dead; I’ve got no idea what her alignment is.

I need to have a look at the Vaya thing some time.

[Cobalt]

She isn't dead yet. Still L-1.

[Benmage]

unvote vote devotress

[Fishythefish]

You see Cobalt, I just live two minutes in the future.