Pick Your Power - Game. Set. Match.

[chamber]

Official Vote Count

Players needed to lynch: 10

BloodCovenent

- 2 - Faraday, budja - (L-8)

devotress

- 2 - SerialClergyman, DeathNote - (L-8)

elvis_knits

- 2 - Xylthixlm, Benmage - (L-8)

SerialClergyman

- 1 - Cobalt - (L-9)

Xylthixlm

- 1 - drippinggoofball - (L-9)

Players not voting: BloodCovenent, chamber, Cruciare, devotress, Dramonic, elvis_knits, Farside22, FishytheFish, Seacore, TonyMontana, Vaya

Cobalt claiming vig is a surprise to me and rather disappointing so... I suppose I will vote the next scummiest person on my list.

You've blown my mind with this comment. What exactly did you expect him to take? If you found him scummy before why are you letting him off now that hes claimed vig instead of freaking the fuck out because one mafia has 2x killing power.

[DrippingGoofball]

devotress has some very bad votes

How bad?

serial wanted the bulletproof to claim with poor reasoning

Now, that's worth a vote.

[DrippingGoofball]

No really. I've looked at devotress' voting record and what is so bad about it? So far we've lynched a serial killer. How would we know her voting record is bad?

[DrippingGoofball]

Now I read Devotress' posts in isolation. Maybe vote-hopping and the occasional lack of conviction. Is that normal?

[Cobalt]

specifically her unvote of benmage in iso 20 and the reasoning in the two preceeding posts. Bad. Especially coupled with the vote hopping.

[Benmage]

i'd still rather lynch EK.....where is she...

[elvis_knits]

The relatives will NOT leave my house and more are coming tomorrow So I haven't read anything from this day yet...

However, I can report that Tony Montana is innocent.

[Seacore]

Yay, thanks Elvis.

Vote Elvis

[TonyMontana]

LIES! nowait...

[BloodCovenent]

Vote BC

Cool... anything else?

I am reluctant to admit that elvis still being alive is not good.

I love you elvis but that sure ain't looking good combined with your complete and absolute lack of scumhunting.

Not really. I wasn't too surprised. i know it's all wifom, but what if scum specifically didn't want to kill him. Either that, or ya, he's a scum cop.

tried to vig devotress. I was either blocked or devo was bussed.

Don't forget bulletproof.

Devotress, being 22nd in the draft order, Bulletproof.

Hahahahahhahahahh hahahhah aha hahahhah

DIE SCUM DIE

Plum/haylen, being 21st in the draft order, Empowerer.

<insert laugh here>

^ this. Didn't randomization tests suggest that low draft picks could indeed receive power roles? Was it you Xyl that suggested that in the sign up thread?

Yeah.. maybe dev did. At 20

Wow, that really made me laugh. hard.

Yeah.. maybe dev did. At 20

No. Dev didn't.

Why do you suggest that?
*Facepalm* I see it now, DGB is scum.

Vaya has only posted once all game, is that the norm for him to lurk this much?

In one game I'm aware of Vaya posted only once or twice and needed to be replaced. Vaya was scum.

p.s. That's a horrible way to meta people.

fos

Really.

Someone asked about Vaya lurking. I stated a fact.

That's a horrible way to meta people? I didn't even try to generalize.

Oh wait - you're probably scum.

Just because someone replaced out as scum in game 1, doesn't make them scum in game 2 when they do the same thing. It actually means nothing, and is a null if anything.

Considering the above, you had time to pay me special attention? It's weird, very weird.

Oh wait - you're scum.

you were right above my post, when scrolling up i was reading superficially, then i looked deeper into your post and knew I had to post right away.

Scum motivation to draw the bulletproof claim: they know who not to target for an NK
Town motivation to draw the bulletproof claim: ???

we know who not to lynch.

Bulletproof should certainly not claim but I'm not feeling SC-scum either.

vote BC

you just hate me, don't you?
-why am I scum? is it what DGB said?

Vote: DrippingGoofball

[Cobalt]

um why would we not lynch someone who claims bulletproof?

[Fishythefish]

So, this isn't a catchup post, and I still intend to do a proper catchup some time.

However, to get my priorities right:

What's actually worth reading in the last 11 pages?
Other than Cobalt-vig, have there been any other claims, hints, claims of interesting role-related information?


Reasons for a night kill not to go through (obviously, Cobalt is vig, and almost as obviously he did what he claimed to do):
1) Bulletproof
2) Doctored
3) Roleblocked
4) Jailkept
5) Driven
Of these, I'd say Driver is scummy (not definitively so, but it is likely to do more harm than good as a townie), bulletproof is marginally scummy, and the others are very nearly alignment neutral. I'd like Devotress to claim whether or not she is a driver.

I believe a lynch on elvis would be insanity itself. If she's town, leave her two days and we have two more answers. If she's scum, very likely any guilties she feeds us are true, so she's very helpful catching the other mafia. If I was 100% certain elvis was scum, it would be a tough decision. As it is, lynching her is crazy.

At the end of the day, if elvis is a caught scum cop, she is still far, far more dangerous to the other mafia than us. They need to kill her off. We don't, at least until dangerous numbers start to loom.

[Devotress]

At the end of the day, if elvis is a caught scum cop, she is still far, far more dangerous to the other mafia than us. They need to kill her off. We don't, at least until dangerous numbers start to loom.

I believe she's likely scum simply because no one tried to stop her investigation, there was no roleblock, jailer, or anything on her.
But you're right I guess, she can still catch the enemy scum team. We just have to take her "townie" claims with a grain of salt untill we eventually lynch her. (if we lynch her and she flips town we've got a bunch of cleared townies, if we lynch her and she flips scum, some of her clears might be scum).


Since you wanted it to be said: I am not a Driver. I'm thinking someone either Jailed myself or Cobalt, or roleblocked Cobalt.

[Devotress]

Can someone outline the case on SerialClergyman for me, or point to a good post that highlights the case?

[Cobalt]

Can someone outline the case on SerialClergyman for me, or point to a good post that highlights the case?

read page 31

[Devotress]

Oh you're right. Wanting the bulletproof to claim is pretty bad. I guess it's worth a

Vote SerialClergyman

atleast for now.


Later on I might have to re-read through his day one.

[Faraday]

At the end of the day, if elvis is a caught scum cop, she is still far, far more dangerous to the other mafia than us. They need to kill her off. We don't, at least until dangerous numbers start to loom.

I believe she's likely scum simply because no one tried to stop her investigation, there was no roleblock, jailer, or anything on her.

um explain how this makes her more likely to be scum, please. sure no pro-town blocker would block a claimed cop, so yeah.

Don't think SC is scum atm, don't find the case on him compelling at all.

Plum mentioned BC a few times, calling him 'weird' but rarely saying anything beyond that, never going as far to call him scummy/townie.

[Devotress]

At the end of the day, if elvis is a caught scum cop, she is still far, far more dangerous to the other mafia than us. They need to kill her off. We don't, at least until dangerous numbers start to loom.

I believe she's likely scum simply because no one tried to stop her investigation, there was no roleblock, jailer, or anything on her.

um explain how this makes her more likely to be scum, please. sure no pro-town blocker would block a claimed cop, so yeah.

Don't think SC is scum atm, don't find the case on him compelling at all.

Plum mentioned BC a few times, calling him 'weird' but rarely saying anything beyond that, never going as far to call him scummy/townie.

She's likely scum because it's likely to me that of 6 scum players it's likely one of them would have had something that could be done to stop her.
Remember Haylen was an empowerer, why didn't the scum empower their killer and kill EK to avoid a doctor protection.

[Devotress]

I'd actually go out on a limb and say that Haylen was

deffinatly

in the same scum group as EK if that scum group didn't killer her, now that I think about it.

[Cobalt]

I'd actually go out on a limb and say that Haylen was

deffinatly

in the same scum group as EK if that scum group didn't killer her, now that I think about it.

not if the empowerer was roleblocked.

[Devotress]

Actually, question

@Mod.

If the empowerer got killed, would his empower not go off that night, or would the person haylen targeted still have been empowered?

[Devotress]

That's hypothetical anyway because they didn't even try to kill EK, Haylen's group killed Vi.

[BloodCovenent]

That's hypothetical anyway because they didn't even try to kill EK, Haylen's group killed Vi.

Lol, I was gonna say, how the fuck did you know that.

[Devotress]

Because Haylen's group didn't Kill Haylen, and The vigalante didn't try to kill haylen, so of the 3 night kills the one targetting Vi had to come from haylens group.

[Cobalt]

Or haylen was bussed.