Ectomancer wrote:There really was nothing wrong with Badger not posting
Ectomancer wrote:The question is not whether anyone ever reads a game without posting. The question was, did you vote me for lurking and then begin to lurk yourself?
Ectomancer wrote:He then admitted that he visited the game, didnt see anything to post about and left. That is the definition of lurking, which is what I voted him over.
Perhaps you should provide your definition of lurking, because you're contradicting yourself a lot, and you seem to be upset that I would read the game without posting...which a profile check on you shows you do yourself often, posting in one game while not posting in others within several hours or days. It's also a ridiculous notion, as posting every time I read the thread would lead to my putting up 50+ new posts on a slow work day.
Ectomancer wrote:Do you see no inconsistency in complaining about only 8 posts in one post, and then saying you didn't want to spam in another? Aren't those opposite concerns?
This is a ridiculous misinterpretation. You voted me for not posting; I explained that finding nothing needing my response over the course of 8 posts wasn't lurking. I'd love more conversation - it probably would have given me something to respond to - but putting up posts of rambling spam isn't going to help the game, and is in fact likely to stifle investigation and let lurkers pass unnoticed.
Quality vote on kunkstar for seeking clarification of your argument, btw, bullying and refusing to explain is very pro-town.
Ectomancer wrote:Hey Badger, in your post where you vote Parts you seem to want us to believe you are being sarcastic. Can you give your current take on Parts?
My last sentence was sarcastic, I would call my vote on Parts more tongue in cheek.
Parts wrote:I don't care whether this is consistent over his game history or not. His reasoning followed fine for this game and that's all I'm judging on.
Parts doesn't care about careful consideration of truth or logic, just a narrow window of observation. He's either a very bad scumbuddy (your comment about FOS followed by a lack of pressure looks like coaching) or he's very bad town. I wouldn't mind seeing him swing, but you'd be better.
Unvote Parts, Vote Ecto
CSL wrote:Interesting. Badger is contradicting himself, and lurking.
You should tell us what you're attempting to hide from us.
Nearly a quote from Ecto's accusations and post 61...I shall interpret this as '
too lazy to read the game and investigate, but someone mentioned lurking so must post something
'. The hypocrisy is even more astounding than Ecto.
CSL, how do you define lurking and in what way does my behavior match that and yours not? Since you're voting me for contradicting myself and lurking, it would be ironic if you were doing either, let alone both.
And
tell what I'm attempting to hide
? What does that even mean?