Open 184: Friends and Enemies Mafia (Over)

[DarkLightA]

Wow SC; you really don't want a Neto lynch, do you?

[SerialClergyman]

DLA - I'd hammer right now.

[SerialClergyman]

What I think you don't understand is the position I was in when I replaced in. I had Albert pushing my wagon, a self-voting player who was terrible and everyone wanted to lynch. I took a big breath and decided that my goals for today would be to get the people I thought were most likely to be scum out in the open so that when I died the town could have a look at them and my contribution would be valid. My second goal, and one I didn't think I would achieve, would be to live.

As it stands, it looks like I'll achieve both goals. And to boot, we have a wagon on one of the scummier members of the town. I am totally happy with today.

[Netopalis]

Honestly, guys? Really?


Albert, I have to say that the one that I'm most shocked at is you. This is really disgusting. You call this scumhunting? Just calling somebody scum then voting? I can understand it from the others, but you're better than that.

Ojanen, if I were to go and attack everybody that played horribly in this game, I'd need a lot more votes than I had.

If you guys were so bonzer to vote for a vanilla townie, why did everyone jump off of Hewitt like they did?

[Ojanen]

Ugh. It looks like I'll take a little longer to get access again, mightr5 be more like 48 hours, first noight won't have internet.
I'd like Kitty to chime in but won't ask you to wait for days for me, do as you will on the wagon.
Kiku and Shotty are scummy. That's the nutshell essentially.

/walks out to the big world

[Netopalis]

Oh, and for the record....

To quote my earlier statement, an argument is 2-3 sentences explaining

why

somebody is scummy. Without arguments, Mafia becomes an illogical game in which people just vote for people that they don't like or based on some sort of system of divination. Yes, I want arguments. I demand arguments. I do this because the game makes no sense without arguments.

A lynch without arguments breaks the spirit of the game.

[SerialClergyman]

Neto - you have claimed vanilla townie. There is no reason to keep you alive. You're scummy, your cases have been bad (Albert remains town) and Ojanen has stitched you up completely.

Plus your wagon will give us plenty of info. Speaking of which, if you're town I would have expected that you'd have accepted your lynch and given us your scumreads and things to go by for when you were confirmed. What's happened there?

[SerialClergyman]

Oh spare me.

It looks like you're complaining about how you were caught, not that you were wrongly caught. Fact is Ojanen made a case against you, I made a case against you, Elli made a case against you and we all did that without anybody holding our hands. You are a good day one lynch full stop.

You have 5 minutes for last words then I'm hammering. Last chance to be productive if you're town, or continue whining if scum.

[Netopalis]

...And Hewitt also claimed vanilla townie, but the whole town jumped ship. Further, I never accept my lynch if I know that it's a mislynch, especially considering the bloody awful reasons for it. Finally, I don't think that my cases have been that bad - it seems that the town is calling every non-me case bad today.

[SerialClergyman]

STOP.......................



Hammertime.

unvote, vote Neto

So are you scum?

[DarkLightA]

DIE SCUM DIE!

[SerialClergyman]

Taking all bets.

I'll give 2:1 odds on town, if anyone is game.

Neto disappearing and not bah posting is pretty much a conviction imo.

[DarkLightA]

Can I give -$5?

---- OT ----

So suddenly you just turned around and hammered when you realized all else failed? Interesting.

[SerialClergyman]

What about it do you think was sudden given I've said from D1 that Neto was among the scummy?

[DarkLightA]

That you were protecting him up until the last second.

[SerialClergyman]

That would be awesome if true, except that I was the first to post a substansive case on him and have always said he was amongst my top suspects.

From the tl:dr after my summary:

Top picks for scum, Shotty, Konowa, Neto.
Top picks for town, ABR, farside.

[Shotty to the Body]

Looks like I missed all the fun while I was writing my final paper.

[kikuchiyo]

Looks like I missed all the fun while I was lurking.

If Neto flips scum then SC is scum?

If Neto flips town then ABR is scum?

Yes, no, from everyone please.

[saberwolf]

I dunno about SC, it could go either way, but I'd like to assume it would clear ABR if he flips scum.

[Netopalis]

...and most of you now go on my "I refuse to play with you" list...

Especially you, Albert. Love ya, but our playstyles are like oil and water.

[farside22]

Since this isn't closed yet just a few things I want to say

Farside and Shotty both took their time to look at you, and they said they saw where I was coming from. Ojanen evidently thought you were scummy on her own as well.

this is false. I never said anything about neto. Whatever he flips I said I would look into it but didn't see a case.

@saber: your win condition and according to the convo I read between you and morph means your supposed to try and play not do have ass stuff to win a bet.

What was this referencing to exactly?

Morph and saber have a bet going on. It's a long story but in short saber had to sign up for a lot of games and some of his self votes are so he can get out of games faster.

Actually, KittyMo replaced that guy who hasn't said a single thing all game and hasn't caught up, apparently. That surely has to be one of the scummiest slots in the game.

Just saying.

Why to line up a lynch. Did you note that KittyMo mentioned computer problems and if you look she said it in all her games.

*Ugh I didn't even get a chance to read up on Neto in this case.

[DarkLightA]

Looks like I missed all the fun while I was lurking.

If Neto flips scum then SC is scum?

If Neto flips town then ABR is scum?

Yes, no, from everyone please.

1. Probably
2. No, I don't think Albert would do something that obvious.

[saberwolf]

oops, i misread kik's post. I have no idea if it would clear ABR if he flipped town, but the fact that neto has yet to say anything along the lines of "you idiots, you lynched town", makes me think we actually caught scum.

[DarkLightA]

@kik's ISO.. Ugh..

FoS: kikuchiyo

[hewitt]

Looks like I missed all the fun while I was lurking.

If Neto flips scum then SC is scum?

If Neto flips town then ABR is scum?

Yes, no, from everyone please.

This is bullcrap.