Newbie 871 - Game Over Town Win

[Ether]

Yeah, uh. It's not lost on me that you only dropped me when I threatened to lynch you.

Having said that, I'll probably be on Yankee's case tomorrow anyway.

[Annachie]

lol, #375...

[Ether]

Seven posts after this, yes. (Which was eight posts after I had actually cursed.)

[Annachie]

Took me a for me to realise I had what I needed, and then to read through all those games.

[Ether]

Elaborate?

[Annachie]

Well, I thought the swearing ment something, but I assumed what it meant. When I got some time a bit later, I decided to go hunting through your past games, and, after a while, I realised what I had, and that my assumptions weren't that right.

I wont guarentee that I'm right of course since you know how I feel about definates.

It was after that that I found the Wickedest quote that I placed in my sig.

[Annachie]

and worked out the corolley(sp?). "Your reasoning shouldn't make someone look town ..."

[Yankee]

oh wow. I apologize Annachie, for some reason I thought that post was done by you because I didnt go back and check for sure. I guess it was one of those things I just had in the back of my mind and got misplaced... Again, apologies. Not sure where my suspicions lie then...

And I will be ready for ya Ether! Bring it on

[Annachie]

Deepening shadows gather splendor
As day is done
Fingers of night will soon surrender
The setting sun
I count the moments darling
Till you're here with me
Together at last at twilight time

[starkmoon]

Official Vote Count
Players needed to lynch: 5

Annachie - 1 - Yankee - (L-4)
RayFrost - 5 - Incognito, ksen, , Annachie,Patrick, Tyrope

LYNCH

Players not voting: RayFrost, , Ether, boberz


Rayfrost (Townie) lynched Day one

Night choices by... Sunday 13th December.

All deadlines are for midday GMT.

[starkmoon]

Day 2!

Incognito (townie) was killed during the night!

With 7 alive, you now need 4 votes to lynch.

Alive....

herd456
boberz
Tyrope
Annachie
ksen
Ether
Patrick

[Incognito]

Ha. Now I can study for my finals in peace.

Bring it home for me, town!

[starkmoon]

Concerned replaces herd456.

[ksen]

I am still suspicious of herd.

Incog and Annachie seemed to be tangling by the end of day 1 but I'm not sure if that's something that needs reading into.

So right now I have as who I think is scum:

1) herd/concerned (welcome to the game btw)
2) annachie

I'm neutral on:

3) tyrope

I'm pretty confident as town:

4) boberz
5) Ether
6) patrick

[boberz]

An incog lynch would be something that one of the experienced players would want to do. But maybe a lesser experienced player may do to take away suspicion and remove a good scum hunter. The only person (other than myself) feeding this paranoia as it has been called is anachie, he did this well after me. he was also high on my hit list before day 1 ended. So I am interested in anachie.

I am interested in ksen for the opposite reasons, incog was more safe on ksen so it would be a strange decision to lynch him. ksen may now be safer in my eyes. Obviously there is an element of circular logic in all nk evaluations but that does not make them useless.

[Concerned]

Hey guys, good to be here.
Let me just read up and I'll post my thoughts tomorrow.
Quick note: my timezone is +2 for I'm not typically available when most people are active (the evening in the USA).

[boberz]

a cross post there with us both suspicious of annachie and safer on each other, it is rare we agree this much ksen.

I have no internet access from tommorow morning (london time) till monday (afternoon probs) because of the frisbee tournament i warned of.

[Ether]

Should have reread overnight. Didn't.

Most important thing to note is that I don't think Annache and Herd are scum together. That forces me to look over my current backup list, Tyrope and Ksen. I, too, find it unlikely that Ksen would nightkill Incognito, which reflects badly on Tyrope.

Concerned replaces herd456.

Er, don't we already have one of those?

[boberz]

why not annachie and herd?

[Ether]

They kept feuding yesterday.

[ksen]

@Ether: I can see open feuding between scum happening as a way to disguise being scum-buddies. I mean they'll vote to lynch each other if it furthers scum causes I don't see why open feuding necessarily clears one or both of them.

[Ether]

That's not the most likely explanation. Having said that, whether Herd was actually under proper pressure or not at the time is something I should probably check for.

Tyrope voted Herd upon replacing in, too. Um.

[Yankee]

@Mod - I already replaced Herd last week (Yesterday game clock wise) .......

[Patrick]

I'm tempted to just get back on herd/Yankee/whoever it is, as he's my clearest scummy read atm, but I haven't really reread anything yet. From memory, the herd/Annachie interaction didn't strike me as a "they're definitely not scum together" type of thing. Yankee/ksen seems reasonable to me until I start wondering why Incognito was nightkilled. He's an experienced player who most people read as town, but if that's the pairing it seems like killing either me or Ether or boberz would be more logical. Dunno. I think atm we need more info from Tryope, he hasn't done anything to rub me the wrong way, but that may be just because he hasn't done much at all. At this point I still feel Ether and boberz are town, and therefore the scum can be found in the other four. Will read up for some more detail tonight or over the weekend.

Based on what Yankee just posted, I guess Concerned shouldn't waste his time reading.

[Annachie]

Vote Boberz

I'm not sure I understand #410, nor the post that it is trying to explain.

Care to elaborate/try again?