Mini 870: Melee mafia. (Mod Abandoned)

[Kirbyoshi]

Yos, if you look at my 429, you'll see that under most of my points (and I know you think I use that word loosely, but I don't), I put something to the effect of "you should know this." I would have put it with all the points, but didn't, for the sake of not being redundant. The fact that she should know it tells me she's intentionally trying to lead town down the wrong path.

[Yosarian2]

Yos, if you look at my 429, you'll see that under most of my points (and I know you think I use that word loosely, but I don't), I put something to the effect of "you should know this." I would have put it with all the points, but didn't, for the sake of not being redundant. The fact that she should know it tells me she's intentionally trying to lead town down the wrong path.

Except you're just obviously wrong about all of it, and as you would say, you should know this. Him wanting to discuss mechanics is not a scum tell; everyone in the game did that. Him pointing out that us not attacking for the first phase can work because if only the scum attack it'll be obvious who they are is not a scum tell; you can call it WIFOM if you want, but it's still a reasonable point. Him thinking that the Tony case is be pushed by scum isn't a scum tell, that's a normal thing for a townie to try to figure out (although I'm still curious why he thinks that), while your response to him saying that seems like one to me. On the other hand, the way you attacked nuwen without having a case is a scum tell on your part.

And not only was nothing you said in 429 any kind of case against drow, I already explained why none of it was any kind of case. And I think you already know I'm right, or you wouldn't just be making vauge references towards "Oh, I already explained that."

[Kirbyoshi]

the way you attacked nuwen without having a case is a scum tell on your part.

Do I have to create a new thread in Mafia Discussion and title it "NUWEN IS NOT SCUM IN MELEE MAFIA"? I have never attacked her. Everyone, please stop saying that I have.

[Yosarian2]

the way you attacked nuwen without having a case is a scum tell on your part.

Do I have to create a new thread in Mafia Discussion and title it "NUWEN IS NOT SCUM IN MELEE MAFIA"? I have never attacked her. Everyone, please stop saying that I have.

Ok, fine. That wasn't really relevant to anything anyway.

I'm really not happy with the way you are acting. You made a claim, that Hohum was "delibratly misleading the town". I asked you to explain, and all you keep doing is referencing an old post that dosn't actually prove that at all. You're basically cornering me into defending Drow here, which I don't really want to do because I'm not happy with him at the moment, just in order to try to get an answer out of you.

[chamber]

unvote vote nuwen

In light of grover replacing and me liking kirbys recent posts.

[drowmage]

@Mod: taking an emergency V/LA until monday

I'll get a post up when I get back.

[chamber]

Someone needs to attack someone.

[Kirbyoshi]

Someone needs to get back to the thread and get this game moving again *cough*TSQ*cough*

[Nuwen]

unvote vote nuwen

In light of grover replacing and me liking kirbys recent posts.

What do Kirby's posts and Grover replacing out have to do with my alignment?

~~~

Okay. This game stalled hard. We need two replacements, and I'd prefer to interact with them outside of massive catchup posts - two blind spots on Day 1 ain't cool.

There's no real time deadline for the day. I'm all for holding off and posting as little content as possible until replacements step in. I usually don't like putting games on hold, but since we're not pressed with a time deadline there's no reason to continue spitting out content. There's a nice start-stop mechanic built into this game. As long as everyone else is willing to pick up on the dime, I think this'll work. Don't start attacking or throwing around suspicion all willy nilly just to pump life into the game - that'll restart the RVS phase and make reads even more difficult.

In the meantime, reread and I want to hear who everyone thinks is scum

independently

and who's

dependent

scum. Simple and succinct posts, please.

[Nuwen]

^ The above is practical because I know TSQ is in finals season and will probably be driving cross country soon. I don't expect to see much activity on his end.

[Yosarian2]

I don't think stalling a game while hoping to get two replacements is ever a good idea. That just results in more lurkers, and probably in the game just crashing and burning, or else ending badly.

I'm quite close to just attacking the person with the most votes and trying to get this game moving; at the moment, that would be Kirby.

[chamber]

unvote vote nuwen

In light of grover replacing and me liking kirbys recent posts.

What do Kirby's posts and Grover replacing out have to do with my alignment?

Directly? absolutely nothing. Relatively, with them removed, you are next on my list though.

[Nuwen]

Why?

[Kirbyoshi]

@Yos's 478 (sorry, didn't see it before): ??? Just because a post is old, does that mean it isn't there? And btw, ask me any straight question, related to something

that actually happened

, and I'll be happy to answer it for you.

[Kast]

@Nuwen/Y2-
It does feel like this is stalling out. I don't mind as it would be better to get replacements instead of having players melee turns be auto-skipped.

Since TSQ is apparently busy or V/LA, there's not much to be done and I think the non-replacing players have pretty much made their thoughts clear (except Stark).

@KY-
-Can you name your feats?
-What experience do you have with d20 game systems?

[Snow_Bunny]

Someone needs to attack someone.

Vote for Kirby, then.

Meh, this game is stalling badly. That's why we need deadlines. Mod! Where are you???

[Snow_Bunny]

~The Real Unofficial Vote Count~

Kirby (5) - Yos, Tajo, Bunny, drow, TM
Tony (2) - Kast, Nuwen,
Yos (1) - Grover
drowmage (1) - Kirby
Nuwen (1) - chamber

Not voting: Kirby, farside*, stark

I think I have it right.

[Kirbyoshi]

@KY-

1.

Can you name your feats?

2.

What experience do you have with d20 game systems?

1.

I also have a +2 bonus to any saving throw I make.
My feat is that I can redirect any missed attack intended for me, but the redirection has a -4.

2. None. Trying to not use that too much as an excuse though.

[Kirbyoshi]

Oh yeah, and Snow, you have me on the votecount twice. Not complaining, but you might wanna fix it for the next one

[Kast]

@KY-
1. I know you can list what your feats do. I want to know if you can provide a name for your feats. Specifically, can you provide a name for your second feat?

[Kirbyoshi]

Oh, ok. Not sure it'll help determine my alignment, but it's "Fade Into Violence".

[Yosarian2]

@Yos's 478 (sorry, didn't see it before): ??? Just because a post is old, does that mean it isn't there? And btw, ask me any straight question, related to something

that actually happened

, and I'll be happy to answer it for you.

I've been asking you to quote me where it was that drow "intentionally mislead the town" for days now, and you've just ignored the question or pretended you already answered it.

[Snow_Bunny]

More Kirby votes, please.

[TonyMontana]

Oh, ok. Not sure it'll help determine my alignment, but it's "Fade Into Violence".

Thought that name sounded weird, compared to my own feats, but a quick google revealed it to be an actual feat from dnd with more or less the same attributes as what kirb's claimed.

And no, it won't help determine alignment.

[Kast]

Oh, ok. Not sure it'll help determine my alignment, but it's "Fade Into Violence".

Your claimed feat is something that would naturally disincline players from attacking you.
-If you were false claiming, it was possible you might not have thought it through (this is not the case).
-With 13AC, most attacks are liable to miss and trigger your feat (effectively giving you bonus attacks). I'm a bit surprised that you have not emphasized this.