Netopalis wrote:I seriously doubt that you would be the NK, MO. I'm still not sure what you're getting at. Judging my reactions through who I want to vig? That seems rather contrived. Can't you just look at it after I act?
That isn't what I said, now is it?
What I said was "if you were a serial killer". Who you would vig has nothing to do with it.
Also, it isn't so much the "who" as the "why".
Also I say I'd be nked because I think I'm right about who the scum are, and I think that scum also wouldn't want me throwing such questions around.
Both of those questions share one thing. Now assuming we kill the most town sided role (Since mafia has nothing to gain fom killing a NK immune townie and my role+chacos aren't really good targets)
If whoever we say we'd choose is town sided, it tells scum who's townish and gives them good choces on who to kill.
If whoever we chose is scum then it gives them some WIFOM to hide behind if someone askes them why the most helpful, town like player is still alive.
This question helps scum WAY more than scum and I refuse ro answer it. How does the question help determine alignment anyway?
.......
So, you're proceeding under the assumption that scum can't tell who is pro-town? Why would you make such an assumption? On what grounds can you make it?
I'm confused how this question helps scum. Also, telling you how this helps to determine alignment would defeat the purpose of doing it, now wouldn't it. If the results don't turn up anything, you can lynch me, right?
I mean, let's look at this objectively.
Let's say this is some ploy to get information on who to night kill. Then, this line of questioning should turn out to be completely pointless. If this line of questioning turns out to be completely pointless, you can lynch me. You have nothing to lose by seeing my questions through to the end. In fact, if your suspicions are justified, you'll have found scum, correct?
Note: It also prevents us from picking the same person or from them using some sort of scum power role. In fact, due to the extension....
It does what now?
Explain.
Something doesn't feel right. Something doesn't feel right at all. I'll try to put a finger on it later today.
I suggest proceeding to try to put your finger on why its unusual before jumping to the conclusion that the reason must be scummy. Also, I find it interesting how little faith you had in your previous suspect to change it upon the first sign of something blatantly unusual.
*sigh* This isn't exactly what I had in mind. I'd prefer it if people actually answered my questions. Obviously revealing my agenda before hand defeats the entire purpose. But the question has to be answered before I reveal why I asked it.
