Mini 870: Melee mafia. (Mod Abandoned)

[drowmage]

And what if all your assumptions are wrong? You've already proven to us that you've apparently changed your mind on one of them, so what's to keep the others from being false?

If you're town there's no reason for you not to have a little bit of flexibility with your opinions. This is a very dynamic game and things change at a rapid pace. I'd be more inclined to lynch someone who holds on to their assumptions to the bitter end.

[Kirbyoshi]

Hm. So in other words, you're more willing to lynch a persistent scumhunter than a flipflopper?

[drowmage]

Nope. Not what I said at all. You can twist my word to mean what ever you want them to mean but you're still going to get lynched.

[drowmage]

you don't have a nuwen case and you've been throwing suspicion aronud from person-to-person hoping to start a wagon. That's not what I call persistent scum hunting.

[Kirbyoshi]

I don't have a Nuwen case because I'm not suspicious of him (in other words, what the fish are you talking about?).

And I'm not just randomly throwing suspicion around from person to person. I've made my vote, and it's going to take something pretty big to make me change it--however, I will draw attention to things I think are scummy. That's what good town does.

[farside22]

I will get back to this on Monday.
Weekends are pretty hard on me lately.

[hohum]

I don't have a Nuwen case because I'm not suspicious of him (in other words, what the fish are you talking about?).

You're right. I double checked my quotes. I was attributing a Snow_Bunny MFOS to you. My bad.

And I'm not just randomly throwing suspicion around from person to person. I've made my vote, and it's going to take something pretty big to make me change it--however, I will draw attention to things I think are scummy. That's what good town does.

Oh but you are. The reason I said anything at all was because of your out-of-place comment about Nuwen's adjustment of her assumptions. You ding her but you don't find her suspicious for any reason? That certainly supports the notion that you're just here to make noise in thread and you're not actually interested in doing any scum hunting.

Your vote is on who again? TM, Correct? I don't intend on allowing him to go through the gauntlet when you and Kast are both much better choices.

[drowmage]

I guess I need to do a better job of watching who I'm logged in as. I guess that also means I'm now completely outed. hohum == drowmage.

[Kirbyoshi]

Oh, lol. You prob don't remember me, but you modded my first ever game at MS.

Anyway, it seems you're trying really hard to keep from tunneling on Nuwen, because he keeps coming up in your posts, and you're not actually talking about him. My assumptions post was @Snow, not Nuwen. And just because my vote's not on her, doesn't mean I don't find her suspicious. Just not the MOST suspicious SO FAR. There's a very real difference there.

[drowmage]

I remember who you are. That game didn't finish that long ago.

I don't have a Nuwen case because I'm not suspicious of him (in other words, what the fish are you talking about?).

And just because my vote's not on her, doesn't mean I don't find her suspicious. Just not the MOST suspicious SO FAR. There's a very real difference there.

There's also a lot of contradictory statements in your posts.

Anyway, it seems you're trying really hard to keep from tunneling on Nuwen

Please show me where she "keeps coming up" in my posts. A large part of my focus as been on you.

[Kirbyoshi]

Your first quote of me was talking about Nuwen. In the second quote, I had assumed you meant Snow, so I started acting like you did. Two different people being talked about, so no contradiction.

You have been attacking me, yes, but twice now you have mentioned Nuwen to me when you meant someone else; why?

[hohum]

Twice hardly qualifies as "keeps coming up" as when you posted that complaint I had only done it once. It's rather shameful and obvious that you're trying to deflect by getting me to talk about Nuwen instead.

[drowmage]

sorry peeps, last time I do that. promise.

[drowmage]

Your first quote of me was talking about Nuwen. In the second quote, I had assumed you meant Snow, so I started acting like you did. Two different people being talked about, so no contradiction.

What you're referring to as the "second quote" here is this:

Oh but you are. The reason I said anything at all was because of your out-of-place comment about

Nuwen's

adjustment of her assumptions. You ding her but you don't find her suspicious for any reason? That certainly supports the notion that you're just here to make noise in thread and you're not actually interested in doing any scum hunting.

It's quite obvious that I was talking about Nuwen here and not Snow_Bunny. That proves you're not even really reading the game.

I know votes don't count but I'm adding this for emphasis:

Vote: kirbyoshi

[Kirbyoshi]

Who's not reading the game? I have

never

expressed suspicion of Nuwen. I think he's one of the most pro-town players in this game. Quote for me one post of mine that shows I'm suspicious of Nuwen.

[drowmage]

Who's not reading the game? I have

never

expressed suspicion of Nuwen. I think he's one of the most pro-town players in this game. Quote for me one post of mine that shows I'm suspicious of Nuwen.

I already quoted it for you. If I misattributed your expression of suspicion for Snow_Bunny over Nuwen it's your own damned fault, not mine. Like I said, you're either not paying attention to the thread (purposefully and because scum have no vested interest in fine details, they just want someone lynched) or you can't (because you honestly don't understand what's going on here).

If the issue is the latter of the two then you need to ask for a replacement immediately.

[Nuwen]

Kirby has been referring to me as "him." I'm reading any ambiguous "her" in his sentences as referring to Snow Bunny, not me. His posts make zero sense if they're directed at me.

That proves you're not even really reading the game.

Even if this were true, why are scum less likely to read the game than town players?

~~~

Tony and Kirby aren't scum together. Unprovoked two directional bussing on day one is outrageous, especially in a damage-based game. Anyone suggesting that the two are partners is either scum or needs to have his/her head examined. There's no incentive to pull a bus right out of the driveway.

Kast and Kirby aren't scum together (same reason as above).
TonyMontana and Kast

probably

aren't scum together. (" ")

Of Tony and Kirby, I think Tony is more likely to be scum, although his self-lynch thing is throwing me off.

His possible partners are those veering the wagon away from Tony and onto Kirby instead,

I'm down for a kirby lynch. The case on tony is being pushed by scum.

Snow Bunny is independently scummy for trying to wheedle away from damage postponement and for being the first to play the confirmation bias game in this post, but also for calling Tony and Kirby partners. She opts for the Kirby wagon over Tony's.

I can see a Kirby-Tony-???? scum team with Kirby trying to early bus Tony.

Vote: Kirby

I'm cool with nixing any of them. Mass feedback would be loved.

[Nuwen]

Tajo, where are you? You're never this quiet.

[drowmage]

Even if this were true, why are scum less likely to read the game than town players?

I already answered that question:

because scum have no vested interest in fine details, they just want someone lynched

Kirby has been referring to me as "him." I'm reading any ambiguous "her" in his sentences as referring to Snow Bunny, not me. His posts make zero sense if they're directed at me.

Even with the pronoun confusion I think it's quite obvious that I was referring to you and not snow_bunny. I used your name specifically. The pronoun confusion is the saving grace that makes his claim somewhat believable but he needs to start paying attention to the thread, would you not agree?

He has a tendency to want to dominate the thread with arguments. He was arguing with Tajo earlier and now he's arguing with me. His reactions are emotional and OMGUSy. I've said this once before and I'll say it again: "NO U!" is not a valid defense. Post 314 is a shining example of this.

[Nuwen]

Even if this were true, why are scum less likely to read the game than town players?

I already answered that question:

because scum have no vested interest in fine details, they just want someone lynched

I think this is a false assumption. (Competent) scum need to be able to build cases that appear pro-town. If they "just get someone lynched," they're not playing to their win conditions in full: being scum means not easily dying.

Disinterest is only a scum tell only in very specific, personal cases (shout out to Ether!).

Uh, I'm still not sure where Kirby isn't paying attention. Either you're misreading something or hive mind has set in.

[drowmage]

Disinterest is only a scum tell only in very specific, personal cases (shout out to Ether!).

Quoting gospel by Ether? Okay, I lend some credence to her arguments, Please link. You might just change my mind.

[drowmage]

er

quote above is Nuwen's

[Nuwen]

I meant that Ether is almost

always

scum if she's chronically lurking or uninterested in a game. Yos can verify.

[Nuwen]

er

quote above is Nuwen's

OR IS IT!?!

Sorry, couldn't resist.

[Kirbyoshi]

My assumptions post was @Snow, not Nuwen.

And just because my vote's not on her, doesn't mean I don't find her suspicious.

drow, please read the bolded before you make any more assumptions about either Nuwen or myself. Thank you.