Jahudo is right that I suppose I was relying a bit too much on my power role to scumhunt initially, which is why I don't have a full out list like most people do, however in most games as it is I normally don't have many reads too early on.
For the first few days I more just like to see the overall play of everyone getting a feel for their styles, habits, tendencies and what not, and I generally don't act on a scumtell unless it really jumps out at me.
With that said, not too much has really jumped out at me per se. The two main things that have sort of tripped my radar (or however the saying goes) were:
1. My entire case on Nacho at the start of Day 3 laid out in Post 701. Here is the post for everyone to reference again:
"I really don't think any of us saw that coming...
What surprised me even further was that Zazier also flipped town, as soon as we started to suspect him towards the end of Day 2. I honestly don't understand the mafia mentality for that with taking out someone that isn't scum that the town potentially thinks is...
And Nachomamma, you're quite quick to act with that vote tbh. How do you vote then demand an explaination... You act like I'm the only one to have voted Shanba. Sure I somewhat lead the case on him, but he was topping the scum list for multiple people. You saw the slip ups we all thought were scum tells. Almost everyone agreed that Shanba was the top play with the deadline closing in.
Also now, knowing that he flipped town, you quickly trying to cast suspicion on me at the end of Day 2 really does no sit well with me. At all.
Think about it, it's simple scum logic.
If you were scum you would know that both myself and Shanba were town. You already saw that Shanba was the play and didn't have to worry about anyone else being lynched, so you quickly started to target me which could carry over into this day (as you have already started). Targeting me in theory should net a really easy lynch since I was the main person pushing for the Shanba lynch, and naturally suspicion would be placed on me if he flipped town. However, you started the suspicion on me yesterday, which makes no sense. The only way you would know that Shanba was town yesterday was if you were scum. The only other way being that if you were a cop and got a report on him Night 1, though I would think you would use the report to protect him from being lynched if you were town, so no, there's no way you're a cop."
Here is a link to the post so you can go back and refer to the few posts leading up to it by Nacho:
http://mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.ph ... 58#1926858
2. My recent case on Pomegranate. It was described somewhat just a few posts ago, though again... I feel that he is somewhat just trying to divert attention off of himself especially after just getting a couple of posts. I had recently claimed which is a big happening in any game when someone claims, and I feel that Pomegranate used the situation to his advantage to think of a way he could possibly twist it around to make it seem like I'm still scum, and use my verdict on Nacho against me like I had it planned despite clearly not wanting to say it to everyone in the first place. His reasoning for me being scum through my claim and verdict really doesn't make sense to me, and it seems all too likely that he brought it up on this page when suspicion was starting to land on him, and not earlier on when I first said the verdict I received on Nacho.
I don't have any real scum reads on anyone else at the moment, though for the feeling I've gotten from other players I tend to have a feeling that KirbYoshi and Jahudo are town. I'm feeling more better than not about Elvis. Socio could go either way for me. As for Yankee I honestly have no idea at all what to think about him (which in turn could be a bad thing I suppose...)
