The Dark Goma Mafia: Massacre of the Cloth (Game Over)

[tubby216]

^^^ likely Dram partner.

Heh, I was thinking tubby partner.

hey i was thinkin you guy be the scum imagine that i guess we're all retarded huh


lama,

i die if i hide behind a converter, thats all it says

[dramonic]

I'll repeat what I said earlier: My jk targets are untargettable. Tubby likely failed night 1.

[Sajin]

Dramonic had very little reason to claim if he was scum. Scum roleblocker would be a powerful role in a setup like this.

[SpyreX]

Ok. Its time to shake past the power-role dance and look at this from a holistic approach.

I'm throwing this out there with one thing in mind:

I'm really starting to think there isn't a crazy scum masterplot causing havoc. It is simply us chasing our tails.

With that in mind, lets look at our cast of characters. (bold mean claims thus far)

1.) tubby216 (50)

2.) Vaya (36)
3.) Battle Mage (70)
5.) Papa Zito (93) (6)
6.) VP Baltar (152)

7.) SpyreX (162)

8.) SerialClergyman (88) (7)

9.) milkshake (125)

10.) Snow_Bunny (70)

11.) dramonic (172)

12.) Benmage (236)

13.) SocioPath (76)

16.) Sajin (50)
17.) LlamaFluff (65) (1)

18.) chamber (22) (2)

20.) Plum (98)
21.) Kise (48)
23.) Elmo (14) (16)
24.) stark (92)

Again, our Mod: 62

Now, the first problem with this game is pretty simple. If you asked me how many freaking players were alive no way in hell would I say 24. We are not having the kind of activity and, well, scumhunting that one would expect from that many.

This is simple enough. Three suspects. Everyone. Next post.

So, I've been twisting about the whole claims and AHA bits. Lets parse this out again.

SpyreX - claimed due to zombification / reflexive theory on this being SB's fault.

SC - claimed to attempt to call SpyreX out (good) and then further claimed the second target of VP (good)

Milkshake - claimed in their second post (bad). Claimed that if someone is "totally insane" (what) they make them sane. (overall, with no mention of SK at this point and the assumation relooking at it that this FIXES SK's not cops I give this a tentative good OR SK)

Snow Bunny - Early miller claim (good). PR safe test (bad). This one has been beat to hell so it can sit for now.

Dramonic - claimed due to thinking milk was the SK due to jailing activity (good idea, too many variables for it to be awesome but I'm not so quick to dismiss it). Claimed, again, to try and lynch whom they thought was scum (good).

Plum - claimed to test tubby's givenly bizarre nameclaim (good idea, a little hard for tubs-scum not to see what she was up to but).

Sociopath - claimed to theoretically bust plum (good!). Of course, dancing events say that's up in the air.

Tubby - claimed to save ones own hide (bad) had a breadcrumb (good) that was fairly weak (bad) for a role that damn well could be scum (bad).

chamber - claimed for moonbeams (bad) with a role that thus far has, from appearances, done nothing (bad).

So, if I was to have a bullet, or three, based on this exchange I'd be shooting: chamber, milkshake, tubby.

Now, this should cause a ruckus but:

Plum, m'dear, I'm officially saying I want you to "oust" your neighbor. That variable needs to be pinned down for things to move on from here real good.

Assuming my guesses on that are right, I'll be that guy:

Plum, sociopath, sc, dramonic are all town, or at the very least better at appearing so than most of the game.

Even though I'm not convinced one bit I do not think ANY of the roles that have claimed thus far are a good call (I could bend on SB, but you know).

---

I've preached this song but seriously again:

Benmage has over 200 posts and if I had to give his stance on anything not relating to him I'd be hard pressed.

Sajin truly has the cruise control for cool on and I don't like it.

Vaya and Elmo flat out need to post more. The only reason I'm not all over Elmo is the fact that I haven't seen any OTHER voting mechanics in play at this point so Elmo-scum points at a smaller scumgroup OR Elmo being town.

But, seriously. I will flat out policy lynch someone who doesn't deliver 3 suspects in their next post. The zombie empire and the allies therein will make it happen. I guarantee it.

Complacency will end. By a rope if it has to.

[chamber]

post

[SpyreX]

Unvote, vote chamber

I'm 100% fine with this.

[Benmage]

Good summary Spry.

Top 3 suspects hrmm…

1. SP: I think hes scum who thought he caught some other type of scum/3rd party.

2. Vaya: her play doesn’t match my experience with/is overall plainly poor and scummy.

3. Sajin: this coasting is unacceptable and totally matches a personal scum meta on him.

Honorable mentions would goto:

Dramonic: plays been poor...doesn’t match previous town play…theory on his JK/SK is bad…although I don’t have much experience with him…so maybe he just isn’t good??

Elmo: 14 posts = scum.

Kise: I don’t like the odd play/also coaster style.

On a side note. I think SpryeX might be town. This play is similar to things I’ve seen from him(he just has a terrible read on me for some reason.) A lesser degree in WoT(I think activity, maybe RL played an issue here). But also in Mini 758.

[Benmage]

Unvote, vote chamber

I'm 100% fine with this.

I dont even get what his PR is, unless its like some VT useless thing...i'm baffled by him but is play is worthy enough of a lynch. Though we just policy-lynched us into our own doom like 2 games ago....then again a scum died at night...

2am=rant

unvote vote chamber

[SpyreX]

Waaayyy too much meta Ben but by god that may be the first post in a long while you've taken a stand that I can easily read.

I like it.

Now, vote chamber.

[Benmage]

to slow u lose

[SpyreX]

I'll happily lose this battle.

[Benmage]

I'll happily lose this battle.

Oh shizznitch(2am epiphany). You were scum that game we/I/not u policy lynched into oblivion. You s.o.b you fuck me over again and its over!

[SpyreX]

Which one?

(Not scum this time though, tia).

[Benmage]

Which one?

(Not scum this time though, tia).

Mafia 98. 842 was lost by Reck. I'm done for tonight this is why i have over 200 posts!..but hopefully most people skim this blur.

[chamber]

Unvote, vote chamber

I'm 100% fine with this.

I dont even get what his PR is,

unless its like some VT useless thing

...i'm baffled by him but is play is worthy enough of a lynch. Though we just policy-lynched us into our own doom like 2 games ago....then again a scum died at night...

2am=rant

unvote vote chamber

Some VT useless thing that proves its a VT usless thing, or at very least that I'm changing the weather and no one is saying its effecting them.

[curiouskarmadog]

Vote Count (Page 94, Day 3)

dramonic

-3 (Snow_Bunny, milkshake, Papa Zito)
milkshake -3 (dramonic, Plum, tubby216)
tubby216 -2 (stark, SocioPath)
Papa Zito -2 (LlamaFluff, chamber )
Snow_Bunny -2 (Elmo )
SerialClergyman -2 (Battle Mage, VP Baltar)
chamber -2 (SpyreX, Benmage)
Benmage -1 (Kise)

Not Voting:

SerialClergyman, Sajin, Vaya

Note:

Deadline will be at the earliest 11/14 at 5:00 PM EST. With 20 whole votes available, it takes 11 to lynch.

[Papa Zito]

This is simple enough. Three suspects. Everyone. Next post.

1. Dramonic - My gut is screaming gut here and I'll buy everyone in this game a pony if I'm wrong. My vote is not moving from here.
2. Snow_Bunny - You forgot the part where she somehow managed to use her one-shot investigation on a dead player. Haha.
3. Battle_Mage - The very definition of an active lurker.

[Papa Zito]

EBWOP: My gut is screaming scum. lulz Also I'm hungry.

[tubby216]

milkshake,
snowbunny

SC

^scum

[VP Baltar]

Spyrex, honeybear, there are so many people I want to lynch it's like trying to choose a bed to sleep in at the Playboy mansion.

If we want to get all old skool on this, then my top lynchees in terms of play this game would easily be:

1) Sajin
2) Vaya
3) Chamber (I think his role is confirmed, but he could be a basic mafia goon with mild confirmation ability)

If we are factoring in scummy and suspicious play in relation to claimed roles, then both Sociopath and SerialClergyman are in the mix for me. I don't believe that everyone who has claimed thus far is town. Until I hear a better explanation from SC for how he is playing his role thus far, I don't really want to move my vote (though I do recognize that we are stagnating and need to reach a decision soon).

On the other hand, we do need to deal with the SB situation, which I'm not thrilled about wasting a lynch on since she's probably town, but it needs to happen and I don't think the scum are going to do it for us now. The DGB investigation is convenient.

[dramonic]

Milkshake
Milkshake
and say, milkshake


and SB
And Chamber

[SpyreX]

These are being compiled. Others do need to chime in.

I am serious about my vote for chamber. Once this whole business is done I may be crusading for that to be the lynch.

[VP Baltar]

Heh, I was actually going to compile these and point out who the majority clearly wants to lynch.

[SpyreX]

Babycakes, if you want we can do it... together.

[VP Baltar]

It's business time

It is Wednesday afterall.

I'll probably just throw everything into an excel document and see who comes out on top.