Mini 828 - ProzacMod 3 - Lost Mafia - Over

[Amished]

Oh, right, you weren't in early. You could have played off Drench's attitude early on, but you replaced in D1 since you were heavy for defending xRx all of d2 and all of that. (need to go back to check when you replaced in..) I was saying what would've happened on D3 had you done what I would've expected out of a town cop.

I'll point you to the wiki page, because that explains it much better than I can. http://www.mafiascum.net/wiki/index.php ... Too_Townie Seriously. Too townie = scum DOES NOT FOLLOW AT ALL. I don't give a shit if "it's a scumtell for you" because it's not a scumtell. Just like freeways aren't evil and because somebody is 7 for 7 at finding scum, they can still be wrong.

I'll humor you with "if you turn town cop" though. I will try to figure out why you would've gotten an ability as town; but I don't think (with the claimed roles) that a scum cop makes sense. With your story of how you got it at the beginning of D2, xRx is clear. Then by PoE, the scum are squarely in VP, ckd and BM because EMP and ZA *are* cleared.

[curiouskarmadog]

come on emp vote me....Reck is....you know Zone will (if he isnt already)....VP will surely follow...

all the scummy kids are doing it.

[Amished]

EBWOP: I was right about when Santos came in (page 11). That was well before xRx claimed and you could've explained everything "my" way if you're actually telling the truth.

[Santos]

curious / vp pissing contest is so last week. now its emp / curious lol

I'll point you to the wiki page, because that explains it much better than I can. http://www.mafiascum.net/wiki/index.php ... Too_Townie Seriously. Too townie = scum DOES NOT FOLLOW AT ALL. I don't give a shit if "it's a scumtell for you" because it's not a scumtell. Just like freeways aren't evil and because somebody is 7 for 7 at finding scum, they can still be wrong.

Whatever man. You've done nothing to scum hunt except try over and over to use a hypothetical case and strawman against me. You've also not even bothered with a name claim or full claim,

which would be useful to the town seeing as every fucking power role possible is already out there

.

Or prove me wrong. [/blatant role fish, baiting, you shits]

[Santos]

EBWOP: I was right about when Santos came in (page 11). That was well before xRx claimed and you could've explained everything "my" way if you're actually telling the truth.

Your way would have had RECKONER singing for a Santos lynch the next day if he turned up town.

If he flipped scum, then yes, we would have a very different mafia game,

but that is not what we have so please, hypotheticals are over and I appreciate you playing.

[Amished]

OMFG. Seriously, I'm done talking to Santos.

[Amished]

.. what? How would xRx being singing for *your* lynch when he's dead and flips town. Reread what I'm saying and then come back to me when you actually understand what you're reading.

[Santos]

Because he already said in thread that it would be a smart scum move for me to claim cop and that I could have really role-thiefed him.

[Porochaz]

The mod is back on track votevount

Reck - 1 - CKD
CKD - 2 - Zoneace, reckoner
VP Baltar - 1 - Santos
BM - 2 - Emptyger, VP Baltar

Not Voting - Battle Mage, Amished

With 8 alive it takes 5 to lynch

Deadline is the 23rd of October

Santos

Friendly request, If you want to highlight something, please can you use underlining or italics instead, when you bold it, I slow down my votecount scans to check... asking for mod questions is fine to do by bolding as is votes.

To all Players

Please check General Discussion, if you have not done so already.

[Porochaz]

Questions have gone out. These are the last questions of the day.

[EmpTyger]

Amished:
Er, why are you arguing with Santos? I mean, don't answer if you don't want to, but no one else needs convincing. I mean, I was asking him questions because I was gauging how he reacted to inconsistencies towards BM vs inconsistencies towards Reckoner.

---

CKD:

hey emp, why dont you just vote me then? Afraid of being on another townie lynch?

also, did you mention reck's lie in that long post? think I missed it....so I guess you think that LyingReck is town? why?

Yeah, you missed it. Basically, I think Reckoner is town because there are 3 players who have been lying more suspiciously than he: Santos, BM, and you. And I can't vote you because I only have one vote and BM needs it more than you right now, sorry. Maybe later.

and emp, I keep saying this but you keep ignoring it....I havent changed my mind...I THINK THAT RECK IS A BETTER LYNCH..

why do you have such a problem with that?

I'm still waiting for you to give an actual, specific reason why. Denying that you changed your mind is not a reason.
Not when the fact is that you attacked everyone except Reckoner and consistently had Santos as a willing-to-lynch, up until I launched a real attack on Santos.
And especially not when you gave "I changed my mind" as your reason the first 2 times I asked you: [1461, 1512]

[xRECKONERx]

WHY IS BM GETTING AWAY WITH DOING NOTHING

VOTE: BATTLE MAGE

GOD DAMMIT.

[Amished]

@EMP: I make it a point to address things directed at me. As Santos had a decently sized "argument" (I hesitate to use the word, as an argument typically has a valid starting premise) I responded. As he's turned from inconsistent to unreasonable, I'm now ignoring him.

It looks like I get to be next in line for BM since ckd thinks he {BM} is a disinterested townie; and Santos is too busy asking you and VP questions to pay attention to the rest of the game. /dibbs.

One last chance to claim everything BM.

[ZONEACE]

I received a question. FINALLY.

[xRECKONERx]

I need to know who Jack and Sayid are RIGHT NOW before I respond to the second part of my question that the mod has sent me.

[ZONEACE]

yeah, thats sounds like a good idea, just start revealing people to one of our suspects.

[VP Baltar]

Yeah, I don't understand the need for that either. You're going to have to give more information about your question and the need to out any potential role info before anyone should do that, Reck. You're starting to sound like Santos now.

[VP Baltar]

Also, I'll address the other stuff that came up over night in a bit after I get my work done for this morning.

[Battle Mage]

come on emp vote me....Reck is....you know Zone will (if he isnt already)....VP will surely follow...

all the scummy kids are doing it.

Sorry, but i think it's my turn to hang.

Sorry all, but i'm going to concede. Knowing nothing about the show, and having tried for 3 hours to find any positive slant on flavour i can for my character that would be even remotely believable, i've decided it'd be insulting to even try.

So yep, i'm scum. Lynch Lynch Lynch!

BM

[VP Baltar]

@Santos-I don't feel the need to reply to you because you're simply speaking any nonsense you can come up with to avoid your lynch. If you were making any sort of legitimate argument as to why I or anyone else was scum, I would be more than happy to debate you about it. As it is, you first launched a massive rolefishing campaign (which failed miserably) and now you are pursuing the fairly typical scum posting of "what happens when I flip town"? I know it sucks when you are caught scum and people take you as a foregone lynch, but you have to try harder than that.

Also, this:

Oh, and I'm still looking for something substantially impressive from VP Baltar other than an attempted victory at a pissing contest with myself.

psst, I'm winning

shows that you have a pretty low estimate of my intelligence if you think it's going to irritate me.

One other thing, I'm curious as to why you would be so heart set on myself or Amished being scum when you are claiming that Reckoner BLATANTLY LIED about his cop ability. You're simply not making any kind of sense and yet wonder why people think you are scum.

hey emp, why dont you just vote me then? Afraid of being on another townie lynch?

also, did you mention reck's lie in that long post? think I missed it....so I guess you think that LyingReck is town? why?

and emp, I keep saying this but you keep ignoring it....I havent changed my mind...I THINK THAT RECK IS A BETTER LYNCH..


why do you have such a problem with that?

*headdesk* Are you really going to do this again? It might have gotten you out of a lynch once, but don't expect the reverse psychology to work a second time.

[Amished]

Unvote
Vote: Battle Mage

Pretty obvious.

[EmpTyger]

Unvote: Battle Mage

[EmpTyger]

Do not lynch Battle Mage yet.

He's absolutely the lynch today, but first we need to give people a chance to answer questions get a modreply. But keep him at 3 votes in case there's another deadline shenanigan like D1.

---

Reckoner:
Zoneace and VP are right. You say why you need to know first.

---

Amished:
To save me from looking back through the entire thread, can you quickly clarify when you got your question?

[Amished]

On D3 before I replaced in. CDB was the one that got it and answered it. I didn't ask for an exact time that it was sent or received, just got a copy of the question, what CDB replied and what (if anything) the mod responded with; without timestamps.

[EmpTyger]

Reckoner:
Actually, hold on before saying anything. I'm checking something.