The Dark Goma Mafia: Massacre of the Cloth (Game Over)

[milkshake]

I once knew a Serial Clergyman
Who wanted to out all his countrymen.
But no one would claim;
It would ruin the game,
since there's opportunistical scummymen.

[SerialClergyman]

^^ +1 internet.

[Papa Zito]

I once knew a Serial Clergyman
Who wanted to out all his countrymen.
But no one would claim;
It would ruin the game,
since there's opportunistical scummymen.

That.... that... that was beautiful.

[milkshake]

^^

[Sajin]

I just realized something.

Kscope, who clearly isn't paying attention to anything at all and is therefore scum, voted for tubby, when Benmage was one vote behind tubby. Therefore, Kscope isn't scum with tubby, he's scum with Benmage whose keister he just tried to save.

vote: Benmage

I like this. This is far better than your "it must be bussing!" paranoia. I like me some good chainsaw defense paranoia instead.

unvote; vote: Benmage

[dramonic]

@Elmo: Your predecessor was completely useless. However, due to votecount shenanigan, it has been established you have a decent chance of being a DV. Therefore you are a slight source of controversy.

I hate the bunny claim, but when Plum and Socio and Benmage and Tubby all could be possible scum, the logical thing is to get on the bigger wagon

Unvote
Vote: benmage

[Snow_Bunny]

Ah, I'm so confused with this game. Claims back and forth, some of them which doesn't make any sense at all. I don't know what to think...

Anyways, I'll

unvote

for now. The whole tubby lynch is just too confusing now. Too much wifom, too much possibilities.

[curiouskarmadog]

Official Vote Count (Page 76, Day 2)

Benmage

-8 (vollkan, SerialClergyman, SpyreX, Papa Zito, VP Baltar, DrippingGoofball, Sajin, dramonic)
tubby216 -2 (stark, KaleiÐoscøpe)
KaleiÐoscøpe -1 (Benmage)
DrippingGoofball -1 (tubby216)
Spyrex -1 (Battle Mage)
dramonic -1 (chamber)
Plum -1 (SocioPath)

Not Voting:

Elmo, Kise, Plum, milkshake, LlamaFluff, Vaya, Snow_Bunny

Note: Deadline will be at the earliest, 10/30 3:45 PM EST, with 23 whole votes available, it takes 12 to lynch.

[milkshake]

I wonder what Ben's deal is.

Vote: Benmage

Let's do this thing.

[milkshake]

Is the benmage train mindless or serious? 0.o

I think it's a little bit of both.

Fair enough!

[SocioPath]

@SocioPath
If you don't mind though, could you explain you're reason for RBing Plum? I think she seemed rather town Day 1.

I make people cry, so I figured I'd do what I do best, and make a girl cry.
So I took from that and looked at females, and chose Plum. I mean making younger girls cry is my forte!

But really, gameplaywise I didn't like her stance on KMD.

oh for god's sake...

Kmd, why the fake daykill?

Scumtrap results positive, that's why. I think this is a Kmd-town gambit.

He hasn't been the only one with faux day kills.

[Benmage]

I just realized something.

Kscope, who clearly isn't paying attention to anything at all and is therefore scum, voted for tubby, when Benmage was one vote behind tubby. Therefore, Kscope isn't scum with tubby, he's scum with Benmage whose keister he just tried to save.

vote: Benmage

I like this. This is far better than your "it must be bussing!" paranoia. I like me some good chainsaw defense paranoia instead.

unvote; vote: Benmage

I hate the bunny claim, but when Plum and Socio and Benmage and Tubby all could be possible scum, the logical thing is to get on the bigger wagon

Unvote
Vote: benmage

Such a pussy excuse to vote. I'm town. I think Plum is too. SP is likely a scum who thought they caught scum.

I wonder what Ben's deal is.

Vote: Benmage

Let's do this thing.

My deal? what can you be referring too? my allegiance?


Again lets ask the question. Other than Vollkan or VP voting me can anyone give me a solid answer for voting me? Or are people just frustrated at the random wagons and are being swayed by scum to just lynch.

[Benmage]

Benmage, would you like to revise your claim, or are you happy claiming VT?

Why, so you can believe me unvote and wagon someone else untill they claim. This game is being fucking stupid even the votes on me are awful.

"Oh theres scum buddying him vote him" WTF not vote the scum buddy him

[Papa Zito]

Benmage, can we have a playerlist with comments from you plz?

[Benmage]

Geeeze thats quite the request. I'm still quite sick so the best I can do it give a rough one off the top of my head.

[Benmage]

Lets seeee:

1.) tubby216: I'm willing to believe the hider claim. Even with the safeclaim could've been an easy thing to do for a future safeclaim. I'm curious why he hid behind milk? Because he was very obvious town? Just stay on top of his night actions in the future.
2.) Vaya: I think Vaya is scum. Shes been off the radar and her play is worse than what i've seen it.
3.) Battle Mage: No read. He went into bouts of active to inactive off the top of my head i dont recall.
5.) Papa Zito cicero: Town, i forget why.
6.) VP Baltar: Town i think, but I dont get how he can think I'm scum.
7.) SpyreX: Confused. I think theres still a good chance hes scum. Noway a town SpyreX thinks i'm scum, we've just been in like 3 games where I was town...and has my play changed at all?
8.) SerialClergyman crywolf20084 Cass: What'd he claim, toucher...theres more to it i forget. Thinkin town.
9.) milkshake: Town.
10.) Snow_Bunny: Idno.
11.) dramonic: Town.
12.) Benmage: Scum
13.) SocioPath: Confused. Had a town feeling. I dont like the RB claim. Could be scum.
15.) DrippingGoofball: Obvscum
16.) Sajin: Scum
17.) LlamaFluff Porkens: No read
18.) chamber alvins95: No read
20.) Plum: Town
21.) Kise: Neutral-Scum
22.) vollkan: No read
23.) Elmo Rosso Carne: No read
24.) stark: no read, maybe scum
27.) KaleiÐoscøpe : Policy lynch

[Benmage]

safeclaim, i meant breadcrumb.

And dramonic should be scum, not town.

[stark]

I am really pissed at tubby wagon being de-railed.

@

Plum

: Was there something in the information you got that indicated tubby was town?

------------------


Regarding Benmage wagon above.

I'm pretty sure we already determined claim-switch-claim was a bad strategy

[Plum]

I am really pissed at tubby wagon being de-railed.

@

Plum

: Was there something in the information you got that indicated tubby was town?

No. I'm not voting right now and in the near future - this weekend, I hope - I'll do a reread of him and Benmage and possibly KScope. I hesitated because he claimed his true Rolename; this makes me somewhat more inclined to believe he's Town but it's not my final word on his scumminess.

[stark]

I am really pissed at tubby wagon being de-railed.

@

Plum

: Was there something in the information you got that indicated tubby was town?

No. I'm not voting right now and in the near future - this weekend, I hope - I'll do a reread of him and Benmage and possibly KScope. I hesitated because he claimed his true Rolename; this makes me somewhat more inclined to believe he's Town but it's not my final word on his scumminess.

--------------------

Look at KK.

His rolename is "The Scribe".

There is nothing in that name that would indicate scum or town.

Obviously you and "your partner" received accurate information last night.

But given the nature of the rolenames in this game, there is no reason for scum to lie when nameclaiming.

[DrippingGoofball]

I've never, ever seen stark be so town.

[Vaya]

Also, it seems more likely that SocioPath is a town RB'er who came forward believing he had caught scum in a lie than him being a scum RB'er in this situation.

I don't necessarily agree with this. Scum RBs are far more common and often claim they are town RBs so they don't have to fake their results. The fact that he claims to have blocked Plum gives me serious pause. I would like to hear his reasoning as well for picking her because that makes no sense to me from a town perspective.

What I'm thinking though is that I'm not sure if Sociopath would come out and attack Plum like that if he were scum and knew that she was town. If Plum were lynched for "lying", he would probably end up looking bad after she flipped town. So I think its a bit more likely that he is town who thought he caught scum than scum trying to get town lynched.

Still, I really do agree that Plum seems like a weird target for town to RB. I don't understand his reason for suspecting her.

@SocioPath
Of all the people in the game, is Plum really the one you felt was most likely to be scum? Did you not feel their was no one scummier that you could have targeted instead?

Also, would you mind fullclaiming, giving us your name and paraphrasing flavor? Since you've already claimed your ability, I don't see any harm.

[SocioPath]

@SocioPath
Of all the people in the game, is Plum really the one you felt was most likely to be scum? Did you not feel their was no one scummier that you could have targeted instead?

Seriously, is that all you have to ask? Paranoid much?

Also, would you mind fullclaiming, giving us your name and paraphrasing flavor? Since you've already claimed your ability, I don't see any harm.

At least this is asking something different.

The Causer of Weep.
(I make people cry, although unlike in real life, it says I don't enjoy doing such. )

I sell fish. Trying to save money so my preggo wive can pop out the child closer to the Goma.

[milkshake]

The Causer of Weep.

Admit it, you're the Weeper.

[VP Baltar]

SP-why did you pick Plum to block. Do explain.