The Dark Goma Mafia: Massacre of the Cloth (Game Over)

[Benmage]

What's the point of this? Quantity =/= Quality

To note differing activity levels. Also shows some people who havent posted in awhile.

Vollkan has a relatively low post count, but I didn't highlight him because his posts are generally detailed.

Nothing todo with quantity vs quality, but I am a believer than town tend to be more active players.

[stark]

Spyrex- What would you say to the idea tha from now on, just give yourself the potions?

[dramonic]

If he does that he'll spend half his time using newly gained ability.

[milkshake]

Maybe he could do both in one night...

[Benmage]

I doubt he can even use them on himself.

[VP Baltar]

Spyrex, do you have multiple of the same potions or is it a one shot deal with each of them and its a crapshoot every night?

[dramonic]

pretty sure he specified it was one of each....

[stark]

I doubt he can even use them on himself.

You should ask this first, spyrex

[Papa Zito]

So what do you think about the players that were eager to agree with your third party theory?

I like when people agree with me.

It'll depend on the flip really.

scope hasnt fallen off the radar, even if his post count is low.

True. For him I highlighted his post count. Its absurd, and if you do a quick iso you can see how useless of a player hes been.

NOBODY WOULD JOIN MY SCOPE WAGON.

[dramonic]

Cuz he wasn't the lych for the day PZ.

[SerialClergyman]

Papa Zito is absolutely town, by the way.

I think the last couple of pages have descended into very little to be honest. I don't think there's been a single vote change or much serious scumhunting at all.

I'd like to see more SB votes. All the cool people are on the wagon. Get it done, imho.

PS - to Sajin, i'd be more prepared to wait the extra day if everyone else wasn't a power role of some kind. SB is most likely to be scum in my eyes and her 1-shot isn't confirming so meh, if we lynch someone else we have a better chance of lynching a different protown role.

Also - missing one small thing is excusable, calling out for a claim that had already happened and quite obviously so looks like you've only just skimmed the thread and don't care much. So I'd still rate it as mildly scummy.

[Benmage]

SC do you have any giver info in your PM?

And after receiving information that seems to counter some of what SpryeX says, how can you just write him off?

[SerialClergyman]

Oh, as for the third party stuff, my reasoning goes:

1) Flavour, type, claim are all a little off.
2) Scum isn't likely to target miller with ability.
3) Spyrex could well be a third party (without ruling out either town or scum.)

Since Volkan gave up his info and SB descended into scumminess I'm more happy thinkign Spy is town, but I certainly wouldn't rule anythign out.
Also, Benmage i'm waiting for a reply to a mod pm before I answer your question.

[Snow_Bunny]

And, what are your great plans when I flip up town? Hunt for Spy?

[SerialClergyman]

Wow, I totally mentally anticipated your questions with that simulpost. I'm awesome as.

Also - I had a gut town read on Spyrex, I don't think the explanation offered for the role conflicts is unreasonable and still noone has explained why he would target a miller as scum.

[Benmage]

noone has explained why he would target a miller as scum.

We have no clue what PR's scum might have this game. So its too much speculation.

Did SB ever reveal what the oneshot ability gained was?

[dramonic]

She said it was a one-shot cop

[stark]

One shot investigation

[stark]

I think the last couple of pages have descended into very little to be honest. I don't think there's been a single vote change or much serious scumhunting at all.

Would it be a terrible idea to consider talking about Rosso?

[SerialClergyman]

SB, the 'what will you do when you're wrong' question is possibly one of the worst in the game. I'm limited to doing what I think is right, and I think lynching you is right.

Plus - in this particular case, you are probably the least likely role to be of use to the town anyway. So happily, even if it was a reasonable question I can still sleep easy.

[dramonic]

I think the last couple of pages have descended into very little to be honest. I don't think there's been a single vote change or much serious scumhunting at all.

Would it be a terrible idea to consider talking about Rosso?

What is there you want to talk abut?
Open the conversation dude.

[stark]

SB, when can you use you investigation?

[Papa Zito]

Cuz he wasn't the lych for the day PZ.

WRYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

There's still time!

And, what are your great plans when I flip up town? Hunt for Spy?

Ugh ugh ugh. The whole "innocent blood" business.

We examine the very informative wagon and move on.

Papa Zito is absolutely town, by the way.

Yar.

Did SB ever reveal what the oneshot ability gained was?

Arg.

Ok, you want me to claim, I have a one-shot cop ability. There, happy? It was not the point of hiding the ability, but the eagerness of some of you to make me claim.

[milkshake]

Would it be a terrible idea to consider talking about Rosso?

Rosso = annoying town double voter. Yes?

[SerialClergyman]

We have no clue what PR's scum might have this game. So its too much speculation.

Rubbish. You of all people shouldn't be talking about speculation, some of your theories have been well within the speculative. I see no reason for scum to target a miller who was likely to be knocked off otherwise, with either a negative or positive ability.

Did SB ever reveal what the oneshot ability gained was?

How did you miss this??? Not only is it important, Sajin missed it and was told about it just last page! How did you miss it twice??

Would it be a terrible idea to consider talking about Rosso?

Go for your life. My point was asking more andm ore questions about SPyrex's role isn't scumhunting. If people don't want to vote SB, explain why and tell us who you do want to vote for. The game is getting a bit flat.