Open 173: Pie E7 Game over

[Scien]

Holy crap... He gambled...

Sigh... damn it. I can't really fault him for that I suppose... but damn it.

[VP Baltar]

lol, I thought you knew when I hammered you Scien....I caught hohum's second breadcrumb when he said he would have a better read on you Day 2.

[MiteyMouse]

After a very short Day, the Scum were decisive in their actions. Scien would be the target of the Day! After he was out of the way, Dramonic and VP Balter quickly overtook the remaining Town.

Scien...

Vanilla Town

Papa Zito...

Vanilla Town

Hohum...

Town Cop

Dramonic...

Maia Goon

VP Baltar...

Roleblocker

You are welcome to talk about the game at this time! Thanks for playing everyone!

[Amished]

OMFG hohum.

Why would you do something like that? Stupid (obvious) breadcrumbs and a stupid D1 hammer. I'm done with this game. Jesus Christ.

There's NO reasoning behind any of your play in this game.

(VP, why did I get your NK? )

[Amished]

You make me want to club a baby seal. Seriously.

[dramonic]

Cause you're the only one with a brain

[dramonic]

Well, a rationnal one anyways.

[hohum]

what a fucking joke

[Toro]

I know I wasn't in this game, but I like reading up on Pie E7's all I have to say is.

OMG Hohum.

[hohum]

yes I gambled. Blame this loss squarely on me.

[VP Baltar]

VP, why did I get your NK?

I figured that you would be the hardest person to get a lynch on. Plus, if you got onto my scum trail I was worried that I wouldn't be able to throw you off.

Dram, why did you never reply in our night talk about the signals! I was worried you didn't see what I said, so I was hesitant about voting.

[VP Baltar]

Yeah, that was too big of a gamble hohum. I think you guys could have caught me perhaps if you had really done some hardcore scum hunting today, but the quick hammer was rough on town.

[hohum]

Yeah, that was too big of a gamble hohum. I think you guys could have caught me perhaps if you had really done some hardcore scum hunting today, but the quick hammer was rough on town.

I had 0 credibility left after charter flipped town after his tirade and I had my money on Scien+Dramonic.

I actually was | | that close to pushing dramonic under the bus.

Scien: I like your new play style anyways. Don't fix it.

[Amished]

Thanks for the compliment, though I thought you were the cop (my comment on hohum/WIFOM was because he was first to confirm, and I thought that Mitey would send out scum PMs first, so to have him confirm during the original posting was him getting the first PM by scum).

Course, I didn't see anything else that I thought was pro-town by him, so it wouldn't have mattered.

BTW thanks for the compliment

[hohum]

I can't wait until charter chimes in with something profoundly ignorant to say. I don't really care what he has to say (I probably deserve to hear it), but I will say one thing to him: You need to spend less time arguing theory and more time scum hunting.

[dramonic]

I was in the woods VP ^_^;

[VP Baltar]

The hohum vs. charter argument was hugely beneficial day 1 in pushing attention away from dramonic. You know I think you are a good scumhunter hohum, but I think you guys both suffered from the same problem in that arguement, which was allowing your emotions to make you over confident in your reads. Lord knows I have done it before, and it almost always leads to failure.

Charter was right about me, but I think he went for the kill way too soon. Had he waited a little bit more time to let me make some bad posts, I think he could have had me cornered.

[Scien]

I will actually grow some confidence here and say if you think no one but Amished had a brain than you are clearly lacking in sight, and you got very lucky here that Hohum's gamble didn't pay off.

I had you dead to rights, and it doesn't matter if it was a mistake or not.

There were a few good players here. Just because you are critical of them means nothing.

[Amished]

Knowing how the setup works helps a lot though, and you can go from there. Scum have a reason to try to abuse the setup, while town can look for said abuses.

Scien: Your catch on Dram was better than I made it out to be, so I apologize for that; though you tunneled on charter way too much IMO. He was clearly right about the setup and to have a wrong conclusion be hammered at him so often and early on (and then lead to a case against him) would make anyone angry. I think that's where the charter suspicion started, and I could see that perfectly coming from a townie; so that's why nobody was going to convince me that charter was scum.

[dramonic]

It was humour.

shooting Hohum or PZ would have been unhelpful, since they were both easy enough wagons after the quickhammer of day 1

You could have been called out for your pretty intense tunneling on me and Hohum was suspicious of you

Amished would have been hella hard to get lynched, you have to agree.

Those are the real reasons.

[Scien]

lol, I thought you knew when I hammered you Scien.

I definitely thought Hohum was lying. Never thought he would false result claim. I pinned it on Hohum and you with Dramonic town at first... then when he claimed town, thought you got fooled into hammering.

No where along that path did I even consider someone Hohum as cop. How could I?

[Scien]

It was humour.

Oh... sorry then. I was getting all defensive lol.

[Scien]

then when he claimed

town

scum, thought you got fooled into hammering.

[dramonic]

Well, if there is one thing I learned in this one it's to look more closely for the topic when I receive my PM XD

[Amished]

Yeah, I figured you just looked in the wrong forum or something dram... lol /facepalm