Mini 854 - Dice Mafia (Over)

[Excedrin]

Talking about thin cases, what's your case to lynch le Chat?

[mathcam]

The lewarcher wagon is solid -- le chat's post in particular is pretty convincing. I have nothing to add.

More interesting:

I would probably HAMMAH! now, but Im just not so sure.

Hmm. This is in pretty stark contrast to the hammer yesterday. When combined with the day 1 hammer (which Rosso can get away with because of his rep, but still is quite handy for scum), gives me an

FOS: Rosso.

As of now, lewarcher and Rosso are my top candidates. I'll

Vote: Rosso

for balance.

Cam

[lewarcher82]

I have no case to lynch lechat. Just a feeling. And the fact I kno I am town.

[Empking]

[0/1] le Chat (2) Lewarcher82, Lewarcher82
[0/1] Excedrin (0)
[0/2]lewarcher82 (2): Excedrin, Le Chat
[0/1]mathcam (0)
[2]Rosso Carne (1) Mathcam

4 to lynch.

[Empking]

I have sent a prod to Le Chat.

[mathcam]

Why is almost no one playing this game?

I think I'm leaning toward Lewarcher. Check this: Yesterday he makes this big deal about how he doesn't want to put the wagon in a Rosso-hammerable position. Then he does it anyway -- we all agree this is scummy. Seems clear that he in fact

wants

to take advantage of the fact that Rosso will hammer.

Now what happens on day 2? He puts le Chat in a hammerable position as soon as he gets the opportunity. My guess is that he's hoping Rosso will blindly hammer anyone he can, and use this to off Le Chat.

Unvote, Vote: Lewarcher

.

Cam

[le Chat]

I answered my behaviour about the Nacho thing, French cat. Also, I have no problems hammering.

I do not know who is scum, but i sure hope there is only 1...

I do a re read, but there is not much to read I am afraid.

You said you voted him because he didn't/couldn't justify the post you thought was scummy. Looking back on Day 1, though, your hesitation to vote nacho based on Rosso's likely hammer is more telling.

[Rosso Carne]

turning it around.

youre right cam, no ones playing.

so my scumhunting is actually pointing somewhere else.

not HAMMAH!ing anyone right now but cam.

[Excedrin]

We can't lynch without Rosso. So, despite wanting lewarcher82 lynched... I'll presume he's town, then lets see if I can find a reason to vote mathcam (as in, figure out what Rosso noticed/is thinking etc).

[Excedrin]

I probably should have made this one post.

Does anyone have any meta on lewarcher82?

I think I might see what Rosso sees.

lewarcher82:
are you opposed to a mathcam lynch today?
also, what's your experience with mafia outside of MS?

[lewarcher82]

I answered my behaviour about the Nacho thing, French cat. Also, I have no problems hammering.

I do not know who is scum, but i sure hope there is only 1...

I do a re read, but there is not much to read I am afraid.

You said you voted him because he didn't/couldn't justify the post you thought was scummy. Looking back on Day 1, though, your hesitation to vote nacho based on Rosso's likely hammer is more telling.

Hi, I can check the thread a li'l more now. Ok, I should put it in the sig perhaps, since it is the 3rd game where people fos me for this.

I always hesitate, because I think before I do things.

Have fun. Rosso may very well be scum. But Le Chat... dunno, it's like a feeling or somrthing I cannot quite focus...

[Empking]

[0/1] le Chat (2) Lewarcher82, Lewarcher82
[0/1] Excedrin (0)
[0/2]lewarcher82 (3): Excedrin, Le Chat, Mathcam
[0/1]mathcam (0)
[2]Rosso Carne (0)

4 to lynch.

[mathcam]

I wish I found someone other than lewarcher or Rosso scummy (since one of the two msut be involved in any lynch), but I'm pretty sure one of those two is scum.

Still pretty happy with lewarcher. He's hamming up his own death even though only a very few posts earlier, Rosso seems to have effectively ruled out a lewarcher lynch.

Rosso -- what can I say? And if you're not lynching anyone but me, why didn't you vote me?

Cam

[Excedrin]

lewarcher82, please respond to some of the questions I asked in #84

[lewarcher82]

@Excedrin dude sorry I am on V/LA... about your questions:

1) I do not know about Mathcam: I hate the way LeChat is lurking, and I am convinced Rosso is town (I know I am, and if he were mafia in this situation he would have hammered me), so mathcam's post FoSing and voting Rosso is *possible* scum. I may hammer, if no new idea occurs to me.

2) Tbh, I have played mafia for 3 years. I have played human mafia, I have played FB mafia and I have played epicmafia.com, where I missed a bronze trophy for 60 points (darn, now I deleted my account anyway) and I had 68% wins and a mafia-stalker stat of 9W - 1L, so I guess I can be a pretty dangerous scum.

[Empking]

Around a week till deadline.

[mathcam]

@Excedrin dude sorry I am on V/LA... about your questions:

1) I do not know about Mathcam: I hate the way LeChat is lurking, and I am convinced Rosso is town (I know I am, and if he were mafia in this situation he would have hammered me), so mathcam's post FoSing and voting Rosso is *possible* scum. I may hammer, if no new idea occurs to me.

Sucking up to the only person who can lynch you, eh? I think that argument is completely specious -- even with his "always hammer" meta, surely a scum Rosso would get some flack if he quickly hammered two townies in a row. And you may hammer who?

2) Tbh, I have played mafia for 3 years. I have played human mafia, I have played FB mafia and I have played epicmafia.com, where I missed a bronze trophy for 60 points (darn, now I deleted my account anyway) and I had 68% wins and a mafia-stalker stat of 9W - 1L, so I guess I can be a pretty dangerous scum.

Man, everything you say just reeks of scum to me. This one says to me "Hey look, I can't be scum. Scum wouldn't be so honest about dangerous they can be as scum." Maybe even a bit of "Sure look scummy, but that just means I'm town! Let me tell you, if I were actually scum, you would have noooo idea...."

Cam

[Excedrin]

1) I do not know about Mathcam: I hate the way LeChat is lurking, and I am convinced Rosso is town (I know I am, and if he were mafia in this situation he would have hammered me), so mathcam's post FoSing and voting Rosso is *possible* scum. I may hammer, if no new idea occurs to me.

Ok, thanks. I basically have no vote today. If you place both of your votes on mathcam, Rosso will hammer and end the day.

Apparently Rosso won't hammer le Chat and I'm not interested in voting le Chat, presumably mathcam doesn't want to vote le Chat.

nolynch is another option. I suspect that if you place both votes on nolynch you might get 2 additional votes for it.

[mathcam]

Unless someone comes up with a compelling case, I'd rather not vote for anyone other than the two I've mentioned. No lynch is a good idea, but it comes down to whether or not archer and Rosso decide to collectively off someone.

Cam

[lewarcher82]

1) I do not know about Mathcam: I hate the way LeChat is lurking, and I am convinced Rosso is town (I know I am, and if he were mafia in this situation he would have hammered me), so mathcam's post FoSing and voting Rosso is *possible* scum. I may hammer, if no new idea occurs to me.

Ok, thanks. I basically have no vote today. If you place both of your votes on mathcam, Rosso will hammer and end the day.

Apparently Rosso won't hammer le Chat and I'm not interested in voting le Chat, presumably mathcam doesn't want to vote le Chat.

nolynch is another option. I suspect that if you place both votes on nolynch you might get 2 additional votes for it.

I do not like the sound of this, tbh, but I dunno why. Since this is a nightless game, I would like to think about it, and since I am V/LA I will post again as soon as I can.

[lewarcher82]

math: what is the point of a nolynch in a nightless game?

[mathcam]

To re-distribute votes. Though you're fortunate enough to be on the receiving end ofthis particular distribution, you have to admit the current vote set-up is a little precarious for the town.

Cam

[lewarcher82]

To re-distribute votes. Though you're fortunate enough to be on the receiving end ofthis particular distribution, you have to admit the current vote set-up is a little precarious for the town.

Cam

aye, that be true!

Rosso, again, why are you not hammering me?

[mathcam]

I'd rather lynch an absent Rosso than an active lewarcher. If deadline nears, I'm jumping ship to Rosso. This is pathetic.

Cam

[lewarcher82]

I know that I am town, which implies that, if Rosso were mafia, he would have no reason whatsoever not to hammer me (except perhaps trick me and buy my trust for a possible lylo... dunno...). Anyway I am not voting him...