There are some that probably shouldn't be, but that does not give you the right to withhold your thoughts. Yes, if you're not careful with stating your town reads, you start painting NK targets. However, a scum group's agenda is to kill off people until they are the only ones around. If they kill somebody from another scum group, they're still a step closer to winning. Do you remember Mafia 91, where you were Sicilian Mafia and there was also a Japanese Mafia?MonkeyMan576 wrote:That's right, I think it's scummy to ask for someone's opinion on who is town. I don't want to help scum, so I'm not answering the question. Do you think all questions should be answered weather they are pro-town questions or not?StrangerCoug wrote:semioldguy is not scumhunting? *scoffs*
Also, you're misrepresenting Brandi. She asked for who youTHINKis town, not whoDEFINITIVELYis town. She wants your opinion, and you're not giving it to her.
Yes, I remember. In my opinion, giving town reads is similar to claiming, and you don't want to give the mafia that kind of info unless you have to.StrangerCoug wrote:There are some that probably shouldn't be, but that does not give you the right to withhold your thoughts. Yes, if you're not careful with stating your town reads, you start painting NK targets. However, a scum group's agenda is to kill off people until they are the only ones around. If they kill somebody from another scum group, they're still a step closer to winning. Do you remember Mafia 91, where you were Sicilian Mafia and there was also a Japanese Mafia?MonkeyMan576 wrote:That's right, I think it's scummy to ask for someone's opinion on who is town. I don't want to help scum, so I'm not answering the question. Do you think all questions should be answered weather they are pro-town questions or not?StrangerCoug wrote:semioldguy is not scumhunting? *scoffs*
Also, you're misrepresenting Brandi. She asked for who youTHINKis town, not whoDEFINITIVELYis town. She wants your opinion, and you're not giving it to her.
Please enlighten me on the first part of this sentence.MonkeyMan576 wrote:In my opinion, giving town reads is similar to claiming, and you don't want to give the mafia that kind of info unless you have to.
Town don't know about the possible makeup of the town aside from themselves, and I don't see how sharing town reads on other people gives anything away about a town setup as we don't know anything about the setup. Scum know more about the setup than town do becaus they hve the identites and roles of their buddies, town doesn't have that. Scum know who the "possible makeup of the town" are. Town doesn't, so how is this helping them exactly?MonkeyMan576 wrote:Either way you're giving scum info about the possible makeup of the town.StrangerCoug wrote:Please enlighten me on the first part of this sentence.MonkeyMan576 wrote:In my opinion, giving town reads is similar to claiming, and you don't want to give the mafia that kind of info unless you have to.
You should vote for him.semioldguy wrote:In my opinion you have greatly overreacted to this vote on you.fuzzylightning wrote:@Chamber, so I am just supposed to take your vote and go with it, without seeing a single reason as to why you voted for me, or that you even acknowledged my presence at all in this game [outside of that vote]?
semioldguy wrote:Town don't know about the possible makeup of the town aside from themselves, and I don't see how sharing town reads on other people gives anything away about a town setup as we don't know anything about the setup. Scum know more about the setup than town do becaus they hve the identites and roles of their buddies, town doesn't have that. Scum know who the "possible makeup of the town" are. Town doesn't, so how is this helping them exactly?MonkeyMan576 wrote:Either way you're giving scum info about the possible makeup of the town.StrangerCoug wrote:Please enlighten me on the first part of this sentence.MonkeyMan576 wrote:In my opinion, giving town reads is similar to claiming, and you don't want to give the mafia that kind of info unless you have to.
I don't have a secret agenda. Not wanting to point out who the town players are for scum *is* pro-town, and not laying out who was lurking brought you out, so that strategy obviously worked as well.Starbuck wrote:I think I've been more pro-town than you have been with taking your reactions and actions into consideration. My vote is placed on the person that I think is the scummiest.
I have been thinking for myself, thank you, but if you want others to trust you, especially if you are town. Why don't you point out who you need to point out? Secret agendas and not laying everything out are ways of scum, not town.