dank wrote:
Anyway, I'm a bit suspicious of the bw on khamisa. Yes, she's been more or less useless, but lets look at it from a practical point of view.
Suspicious of a bw on an (at minimum) anti-town player? so... who do you think is scum that's on the bw, then?
Khamisa is reasonably experienced. She's been in other games, and has been much more active, as others have pointed out.
As the antithesis said earlier... experience doesn't say a thing about skill levels
Is it actually reasonable to assume that less activity, while it does not help town, implies that she is scum? I find this to be a very elementary argument that has a load of exceptions to it. Reasons for khamisa's behavior could include lack of real life time, or quite possibly, a general disinterested townie mindset (since she has now claimed townie), which i'm sure all of us (I know I have) all been in. To be honest, on the list of her behavior, her being scum and blatantly not voting or contributing anything is at the very very bottom of the list.
less activity isn't the problem. NO SCUM HUNTING OR CONTENT is the problem. Don't misinterpret the case. She has refused, pretty much directly, to post any content or scum hunting or, really, anything of worth.
It just doesnt make sense if you think about it for a little bit. If you're scum, you blend in. You don't blatantly stand out from fear of making a mistake and not contributing anything. A first time player of both mafia scum and mafia in general who has no clue of the game and its enviroment may do this, but an established player like khamisa most certainly will not.
"Too scummy to be scum" logical fallacy. Experience doesn't dictate ability, as already said, and her hide can't be saved by her being oh so scummy making her town.
Khamisa has been very anti-town and has not been helpful to the town. I think the chances of this behavior being a result of her being scum are very low, and I do not believe in policy lynches, so I will not be voting her atm. I do suspect some mafia have jumped on the bw however, since its setting up to be an easy lynch with a good deal of support, even though the reasoning, in my opinion, is pretty bad.
Going after somebody that is anti-town is better than jumping on a potential townie that is seemingly pro-town in the hopes of finding scum, especially when anti-town can also mean scum. Higher probability.
Regarding rayfrost, i'm going to
unvote
for now, because I haven't been following the game that much lately. I'll catch up and let you all know my suspicions a bit later.
You haven't been following the game much, yet you have a seemingly thorough defense of khamisa? Contradictions are scummy, my friend. Your seemingly thorough (but still terrible) defense of khamisa and general shading of the bandwagon as scummy have been noted. Thank you and have a nice day.
Also, Haylen: Post.
Agreed
