Mini 851 - Bloodlust Mafia! - Game Over

[RayFrost]

Konowa:

you asking me & chibo or just chibo?

[Konowa]

Chibo. Apologies for not making it clear.

While you are here though Ray, what are your opinions on Chibo thus far?

[Konowa]

Also, we will not be getting anything else of Peabody per rule 10. More points for this being a scummy speed lynch.

[RayFrost]

Chibo. Apologies for not making it clear.

While you are here though Ray, what are your opinions on Chibo thus far?

slight scummy read on him...

Some of his mid-early posts felt a little like he was buddying up to me by agreeing with my opinions and stuff. cuz of that, I can't really argue that his cases themselves are scummy, just the fact he finds stuff suspicious that I find suspicious... mostly after I've stated my suspicions.

[RayFrost]

gah, white screen killed me and I dped by accident.

mod, mind deleting one of those for me?

Done.

[ChiboSempai]

The original source of the wagon was no different than the start of any others. He slipped up, he explained simply at first that it was just a typo, which I proved to not just be the case and it didn't make sense, and people continued. There have been tons of wagons this game so far, it just so happens this one progressed further and faster than the others for some reason. His mess up however was the most hard evidence for anything we have found yet this game, everything else was people's opinions on posts and such, and this was a glaring contradiction staring at us.

The following people voted for Peabody:

Looker
canadianbovine
Zachrulez
RayFrost
Pomegranate
ChiboSempai
AlamasterGM

Peabody admitted back after Zach and before Ray that it was a mistake, but still got 4 more votes. Additionally, Ray flat out didn't accept that it was a mistake, and even called him out on WIFOM. RayFrost recently has been claiming that he wished there was a role claim and has been trying to determine what the scummiest vote/post was, and it doesn't really match up for me.

Judging just from the Peabody situation the people that most came off as scum were RayFront as AlamasterGM imo.

[Rosso Carne]

The original source of the wagon was no different than the start of any others. He slipped up, he explained simply at first that it was just a typo, which I proved to not just be the case and it didn't make sense, and people continued. There have been tons of wagons this game so far, it just so happens this one progressed further and faster than the others for some reason. His mess up however was the most hard evidence for anything we have found yet this game, everything else was people's opinions on posts and such, and this was a glaring contradiction staring at us.

The following people voted for Peabody:

Looker
canadianbovine
Zachrulez
RayFrost
Pomegranate
ChiboSempai
AlamasterGM

Peabody admitted back after Zach and before Ray that it was a mistake, but still got 4 more votes. Additionally, Ray flat out didn't accept that it was a mistake, and even called him out on WIFOM. RayFrost recently has been claiming that he wished there was a role claim and has been trying to determine what the scummiest vote/post was, and it doesn't really match up for me.

Judging just from the Peabody situation the people that most came off as scum were RayFront as AlamasterGM imo.

contradiction, but not really scummy.

i could say that red is blue. its a contradiction.

are you going ot lynch me for it? are you going to supress important day 1 conversation because of it?

maybe you would. you just lynched someone for misquoting someone over a fucking minor and meaningless post.

[RayFrost]

Oh my... I say I find him scummy and then... he finds me scummy...

I have a taste of OMGUSoup. Should that taste be in my mouth?

I called Peabody out on Ate a few times as well, why not at least get

everything

I called peabody out on in that post

Also, I did want a claim. I was not expecting a Quick Lynch.

Also, I believe konowa asked what the scummiest vote was... oh, wait, you agreed with me on that...

so... I can apply the trying to determine what the scummiest vote was argument on you... thta pretty much makes it null/hypocritical there...

[ChiboSempai]

Didn't read any of this page when I made my post, mafiascum went down for a couple mins when I was scouring through the votes on Peabody and it made me take a while to do my post.

Do you mind refreshing on what things I was agreeing with you on Ray? It's not a big deal or anything, I'm just curious. Agreeing isn't technically a bad thing, I mean if I thought the same thing and you had said it first, then I'm agreeing with you, no sense in writing out the exact same thoughts. Almost the entire Peabody wagon was everyone agreeing with each other, Pomegranate even specifically quoted you and saying he agreed with you here:
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 11#1878311

Also, with my last post, I don't know about the whole following your opinion holds since I found your post/vote one of the scummier ones in the Peabody ordeal.

[Konowa]

Chibo, one last question before I get to the point I am trying to make.

Did you find Ray's vote scummy at the time you placed your vote?

[canadianbovine]

Didn't read any of this page when I made my post, mafiascum went down for a couple mins when I was scouring through the votes on Peabody and it made me take a while to do my post.

Do you mind refreshing on what things I was agreeing with you on Ray? It's not a big deal or anything, I'm just curious. Agreeing isn't technically a bad thing, I mean if I thought the same thing and you had said it first, then I'm agreeing with you, no sense in writing out the exact same thoughts. Almost the entire Peabody wagon was everyone agreeing with each other, Pomegranate even specifically quoted you and saying he agreed with you here:
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 11#1878311

Also, with my last post, I don't know about the whole following your opinion holds since I found your post/vote one of the scummier ones in the Peabody ordeal.

really? i found almasters the scummiest.

if peabody turns up town,

FOS almaster

btw chibo i think earlier you posted something about there being 4 mafia and 1 serial killer?

how is the wagon/lynch scummy, are you saying all 7 of the ppl that voted are anti-town, despite there only being 5 anti town roles (4 mafia 1 SK) in the game?

The Setup:

12 players.
3 Mafia.
1 Serial Killer.

where are you getting this 4th mafia player from?

[RayFrost]

Didn't read any of this page when I made my post, mafiascum went down for a couple mins when I was scouring through the votes on Peabody and it made me take a while to do my post.

Do you mind refreshing on what things I was agreeing with you on Ray? It's not a big deal or anything, I'm just curious. Agreeing isn't technically a bad thing, I mean if I thought the same thing and you had said it first, then I'm agreeing with you, no sense in writing out the exact same thoughts. Almost the entire Peabody wagon was everyone agreeing with each other, Pomegranate even specifically quoted you and saying he agreed with you here:
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 11#1878311

Also, with my last post, I don't know about the whole following your opinion holds since I found your post/vote one of the scummier ones in the Peabody ordeal.

Biggest thing that pops into my head is the looker situation scenario stuff.


Also:

Hi CanadianBovine!!!

why don't you say why you found Almaster's vote to be the scummiest?

Also, why not weigh in with why you voted for peabody?

[Konowa]

Anyways, since Chibo has logged off I will go ahead and say what I was getting to. What is really making me twitch is that he apparently found Ray's vote scummy but did not feel it was necessary to comment on until Rosso and I started peppering him about the wagon. I really see no reason

not

to call it out if he thought it was scummy.

At the moment I think that Peadbody is going to flip town. If that happens I am pretty sure that Chibo is scum with someone on the wagon. First gut call would be to say cb.

Regarding Almaster's vote, initial reaction is scummy, but the WIFOM is making my head spin. Once the thread locks down for the night, hopefully I will be able to parse through some of these theories I got floating in my head.

[ChiboSempai]

Not as much no.

He pointed out why he didn't believe it was a mistake, the same thing I had done in my post, but I took a different approach/reasoning to it.

However I found his more posts more suspicious after his posts after Peabody was lynched.

I suppose the exact opposite could be said as well, and that his posts on the past page or two could be the scummy ones, it just depends on which are more true of him. Because on the contrary to why I found the voting posts scummy, the ones on the past page or two could be scummy wanting a role claim and trying to act nonchalant about it trying to ease his way out of the blame of the wagon vote since he was the one primarily against Peabody's excuse.

[ChiboSempai]

EBWOP

Sorry about the delay, I didn't log off, it's just that I'm at work and someone came in to talk to me and discuss work related stuff lol

[ChiboSempai]

@ bovine

wow whoops I forgot its only 3 mafia and not 4. Either way, that just means there is more guaranteed town people that was on the Peabody wagon.

And as told from my post 439 (which I had started typing right after u finished the question but didnt post till then and in result didnt read posts 436,437, and 438 until I finished posting that) I didn't find Ray's vote scummy really until the recent posts from the last page and this one in this recent string of activity.

[ChiboSempai]

Uhg I hate not being able to edit, the second part of my last post 441 was obviously in response to Konowa's 438

[Konowa]

wow whoops I forgot its only 3 mafia and not 4. Either way, that just means there is more guaranteed town people that was on the Peabody wagon.

*twitch*

[Konowa]

Anyways as note to the general populace again, if the game opens on the weekend, I will not be around till Monday.

[almightybob]

Votecount 1.6

ChiboSempai - 2 (J-Fox, Konowa)
AlmasterGM - 1 (Haylen)

Peabody - 7 (Looker, canadianbovine, Zachrulez, RayFrost, Pomegranate, ChiboSempai, AlmasterGM)

Not voting - 2 (Rosso Carne, Peabody)

END OF DAY 1

Peabody screams as the mob leap on top of him and subdue him.

"What are you doing?? Get off me!" he shouts as you drag him towards a large wooden stake surrounded by kindling.
"Oh god no. Please, I swear I'm Town!" he yells, but the mob unflinchingly strap him to the pole. Then one of you produces a flaming torch.

As it arcs through the air towards the petrol-soaked wood at Peabody's feet, the look of terror in his eyes will haunt each of you forever. You turn away as he is engulfed in the flames, and cover your ears to block out the screams of agony.

"What have we done??"

Peabody,

Townie

, was lynched on Day 1.




It is now

NIGHT

. This thread will be locked until Day 2 has begun. No-one may discuss this game outside this thread, unless your role permits it. You may still PM me at any point.

All night choices are due to me within 72 hours of this post.

[almightybob]

The sound of a large explosion makes you snap awake. As you groggily stagger to the window, you see a scene of total carnage. You rush outside.

Rosso Carne's house is now a pile of rubble and ash. Parts of it are still on fire, and as you watch, Rosso drags himself out from under a mound of bricks. His broken body reaches out for help, before a final breath escapes his lips.

Looking round in shock at the rest of the Town, you realise that someone else is missing from the group.


Looker's house seems fine from the outside, but upon closer inspection it seems the lock has been broken. Pushing open the door, you take a tentative peep inside.

"Looker? Looooookerrrrr? Come see, Rosso's been blo- Oh my God."

Looker lies slumped on the floor. Blood and brains cover the opposite wall. It looks like he was shot execution-style in the back of the head.

"Jesus, this is carnage!"

Rosso Carne,

Townie

, was killed on Night 1.

Looker,

Townie

, was killed on Night 1.

DAY 2 BEGINS

List of living players, in alphabetical order:

AlmasterGM
canadianbovine
ChiboSempai
Haylen
J-Fox
Konowa
Pomegranate
RayFrost
Zachrulez

With 9 alive, it's

5

votes to lynch!

Konowa and Haylen are both V/LA until Monday.

[RayFrost]

FoS: chibosempai

for finding me suspicious only after konowa started questioning the stuff and not really having much in the way of suspicion (reaching). Scummy enough for a FoS but not a vote in of itself just yet.

[ChiboSempai]

That doesn't make sense that I became suspicious of you only after Konowa's questions, it was after your recent posts. I don't have to come out and say everything I'm thinking at every moment, but if I'm asked questions, I will answer (as long as it's not something I can't blatantly just say out of the blue). I explained why I was suspicious of you. Nothing too serious, but something to note.

The night kills were surprising and could tell us something... So there were two night kills, and since we have the mafia and a serial killer, does this rule out the chance of a vigilante? That, or can one of the 3 possible killers (mafia, sk, vigilante) forego their night kill? Only Vigilante can do that right? unless the mafia could as well?

[Zachrulez]

Why do you care if about ruling out the vig Chibo? Are you concerned about it?

FOS

Also, I will go insane if Alamaster is not scum, that hammer was just ridiculous, and done without bothering for a claim.

Vote: Alamaster

[Pomegranate]

It seems to me that Looker was probably killed by the mafia; he appeared townie yet not particularly helpful. I think that there are probably only two killing roles/factions, so probably either Mafia+SK or Mafia+Vig. Rosso Carne was probably killed by either the Vig or the SK.