Open 166-Lovers Mafia (Game Over!) - before 838

[VP Baltar]

Vote Count #2

SpongeBobShortShorts-3 (Kise, Sironigous, dramonic)

Not Voting:

le Chat, Far_Cry, SpongeBobShortShorts

With

6

alive, it takes

4

to lynch. Day 1 deadline is September 18.

[Far_Cry]

/confirm. Hi guys! Happy to play here. I will do a quick reread and then post my thoughts.

[Far_Cry]

Spongebob's "slip" was definitely something to note down, and was also suspicious in my opinion. But L-1 at page 2??? Someone on that wagon is scum.

I've played a few games with Kise before (even a Lover's game not too long ago), and looking at how he's played so far, I believe he is town. I understand why he would attack Spongebob for what he did. I even would understand why he placed a vote.

However, in the case of dramonic and Sir, them jumping on the wagon so quickly was very suspicious. Evidently, we should keep pressure on Spongebob for what he did, however, and L-1 is going too far.

Le Chat sounds, like he's not that suspicious of SpongeBob. He's the only person who hasn't done much in his direction. Therefore, there is a possibility that they are partners (although it is too early to tell.)

What I'm looking for now is 3 things:
1. A good defense from SpongeBob
2. Reasons from Sir and dram why they jumped on the wagon.
3. Why Le chat is very suspicious of SpongeBob.

[Sironigous]

2. Reasons from Sir and dram why they jumped on the wagon.

First and foremost is post 44.
(Spongebob's reaction)


Secondly, everything Kise said is not wrong and Spongebob has done nothing to prove him wrong.

[dramonic]

How many town players would go blatantly agaisnt their own word?

[le Chat]

Le Chat sounds, like he's not that suspicious of SpongeBob. He's the only person who hasn't done much in his direction. Therefore, there is a possibility that they are partners (although it is too early to tell.)

What I'm looking for now is 3 things:
1. A good defense from SpongeBob
2. Reasons from Sir and dram why they jumped on the wagon.
3. Why Le chat is very suspicious of SpongeBob.

Well, we can put it this way: all active player votes are on SpongeBob besides mine and.. SpongeBob's. I'm super glad that you came into this game and didn't hammer SpongeBob right away, because while he has said some stuff that doesn't add up, I don't know if I want to hammer Day 1 on him. I don't know about "not do much in his direction," because I'm paying attention to him and saying whats up when whats up, but currently I'm not comfortable hammering him at all.

That doesn't make me his scumpartner, simply because everyone else will vote him and I wont.

I have to guess you meant "why le Chat is

n't

very suspicious of SpongeBob because I haven't hammered him. It's not that im not suspicious of what he's said. It's just that I'm very very hesitant to end the day. As far as I know both scum are voting SpongBob right now - that would skew this whole thing into it looking like he's the best decision when he's not.

I want to hear more.

How many town players would go blatantly agaisnt their own word?

I don't understand what this is referring to.

[dramonic]

referring to the fact Sponge is saying we should stay in RVS while attacking someone.

[Kise]

/confirm. Hi guys! Happy to play here. I will do a quick reread and then post my thoughts.

Aw crap. Welcome. I promise you I'm not mafia again.

@Spongebob - Care to give a critical analysis of the players/game so far? Like, a decently thorough post?

[Far_Cry]

Le Chat sounds, like he's not that suspicious of SpongeBob. He's the only person who hasn't done much in his direction. Therefore, there is a possibility that they are partners (although it is too early to tell.)

What I'm looking for now is 3 things:
1. A good defense from SpongeBob
2. Reasons from Sir and dram why they jumped on the wagon.
3. Why Le chat is very suspicious of SpongeBob.

Well, we can put it this way: all active player votes are on SpongeBob besides mine and.. SpongeBob's. I'm super glad that you came into this game and didn't hammer SpongeBob right away, because while he has said some stuff that doesn't add up, I don't know if I want to hammer Day 1 on him. I don't know about "not do much in his direction," because I'm paying attention to him and saying whats up when whats up, but currently I'm not comfortable hammering him at all.

That doesn't make me his scumpartner, simply because everyone else will vote him and I wont.

I have to guess you meant "why le Chat is

n't

very suspicious of SpongeBob because I haven't hammered him. It's not that im not suspicious of what he's said. It's just that I'm very very hesitant to end the day. As far as I know both scum are voting SpongBob right now - that would skew this whole thing into it looking like he's the best decision when he's not.

I want to hear more.

How many town players would go blatantly agaisnt their own word?

I don't understand what this is referring to.

What the hell?? What do you mean you don't want to hammer Sponge D1??

And I never said you ARE Sponge's partner; it's just an early suspicion.

Yes, you are right, I messed up my last post. I meant to say why you

weren't

suspicious of SpongeBob.

/confirm. Hi guys! Happy to play here. I
will do a quick reread and then post my thoughts.

Aw crap. Welcome. I promise you I'm not mafia again.

@Spongebob - Care to give a critical analysis of the players/game so far? Like, a decently thorough post?

At least you are better than Saberwolf; he's trying really hard to blow a hole in my roof.

And yes, I would also like to see an anlysis from SpongeBob.

[dramonic]

...blow a hole in your roof?

[Kise]

It's the lingo they use at the YMCA.. not that I've been there or anything.

dram, I just realized that we have 1 game with each other in Little Italy, NY, Coney Island AND the Theme Park. Lol, if we were both playing in RTR, I'd swear WE were in the YMCA.

[dramonic]

I don't get it ><

Where does the YMCA comes in in this?

[Kise]

Young man! Are you listening to me?
I said, young man! What do you want to be?

[le Chat]

What the hell?? What do you mean you don't want to hammer Sponge D1??

And I never said you ARE Sponge's partner; it's just an early suspicion.

Yes, you are right, I messed up my last post. I meant to say why you

weren't

suspicious of SpongeBob.

/confirm. Hi guys! Happy to play here. I
will do a quick reread and then post my thoughts.

Aw crap. :lol: Welcome. I promise you I'm not mafia again.

@Spongebob - Care to give a critical analysis of the players/game so far? Like, a decently thorough post?

At least you are better than Saberwolf; he's trying really hard to blow a hole in my roof.

And yes, I would also like to see an anlysis from SpongeBob.

I don't want to hammer Spongebob Day 1 because I don't want to end the Day without hearing from him more. And it's not that I'm not suspicious of Spongebob, I just don't want to hammer him without hearing from him.

[VP Baltar]

SpongeBobShortShorts has been prodded.

[dramonic]

@Le Chat: Looking at things, we'll be hearing from his replacement.

@Kise: It's fun to stay at the YMCA! I still don't get it XD
Either use clearer, cruder terms so that my feeble mind can get it, or drop the issue as it's confusing me

[le Chat]

This game is going a lot slower than my others... I am waiting on Spongebob to respond and I know everyone else is too but we don't have to wait for him to respond to continue our discussion. I guess things have stagnated because you all have your votes on him and are satisfied with the vote?

dramonic, kise, sir: are you all really satisfied with your vote on Spongebob?

I am going to feel robbed if he replaces out with... well, everyone's suspicion but mine. But I CURRENTLY feel robbed that we are not discussing anything at all.

[Sironigous]

This game is going a lot slower than my others... I am waiting on Spongebob to respond and I know everyone else is too but we don't have to wait for him to respond to continue our discussion. I guess things have stagnated because you all have your votes on him and are satisfied with the vote?

What would you like to talk about?

dramonic, kise, sir: are you all really satisfied with your vote on Spongebob?

Yes.

[le Chat]

If we lynch one of the two mafia, doesn't matter which, we win. Scumpairings should be a very important factor in this game but we haven't even brought them up yet seemingly because everyone has been waiting for Spongebob...If you are satisfied with your vote on Spongebob, who do you suspect to be his scum-partner?

[Sironigous]

If you are satisfied with your vote on Spongebob, who do you suspect to be his scum-partner?

...

By process of elimination, his partner is you or Far_Cry...

I can't tell which one more than the other though.

[VP Baltar]

Amished replaces SpongeBobShortShorts. Thanks Amished.

[Amished]

Heyheyhey!

So, 3 pages doesn't take long to read. I fail to see how Kise thought that Sponge was trying to be in a leadership position. Also, since Siro was getting us out of the RVS anyways, I don't see how spongebob was scummy for "keeping with the normal flow of traffic" so to speak. Spongebob liked RVS stages, Siro started to get out of it, so Spongebob continued to get out of it as the game had already turned serious.

Sironigous looks slightly suspicious for his one-example vote hop (refer Sironi to "if only scum did something, they would never do it in the first place as it'd give them away"). Dram, however is extremely suspicious for hopping on a weaker reason to vote for Sponge/me.

[Kise]

I CURRENTLY feel robbed that we are not discussing anything at all.

Unvote; Vote: le Chat

Discuss that.

[Amished]

@Kise: Don't feel that your wagon was going the way you wanted so you decided to vote switch now that it stalled?

[Kise]

Ninja'd.

Welcome.... I thought Amish didn't use computers(???)