Kelly Chen D2 PBPA
407: Defends KKN, claims scum wouldn't try to indirectly defend FA (isn't that what charter says I did? Oh well, facts, psssh.) Votes the Replacement, FoS BM and Tajo.
410: Kise replaced Paper.
435: Says Replacement is like Mokina, glosses over a BM post about Malthusis 'respecting' her, one criteria of his infected-hunting.
444: Speculates on BM's change of opinion about Mokina, says that the recruitment of The Replacement would be odd.
467: Claims she was the obvious choice for scientist protection, WIFOM about protection targets.
sidebar
KKN post 472: Returns the favor and defends Chen.
473: Says Veerus is scummy. "Shotty asks Rally why Kise. Shotty's voting veerus... if anything seems like seeking a reason to move to Kise... on the other hand I'm pretty sure we didn't have four scum so nevermind." I like how when Chen was re-reading this right after the fact I wasn't scummy but then when she goes back later in the day, when I'm in a more vulnerable position, there's suddenly scum-tells all over.
483: Asks charter how my play yesterday could indicate infection, continues to push Veerus as scum.
485: Rereads charter and RV, doesn't say anything about RV but claims charter could be original scum.
488: Back and forth with BM. Refuses to give opinion on RV.
489: Back and forth with BM.
sidebar
charter's 490: "but his (Shotty's) stuff from yesterday wasn't very scummy."
500: Back and forth with BM.
501: Back and forth with BM. (Essentially none of this back and forth is scum-hunting, in fact it's closer to strategy since all they do is debate number of scum and how they're scum-hunting rather then actually doing it, not to mention the veiled insults.)
509: Back and forth with BM. Defending RV.
532: Defends RV. Unvotes.
549: Lists Replacement, veerus, and charter as original scum.
559: Admits there are points that veerus might not be any kind of scum, why has she been pushing him this entire time then?
560: Points out charter's response to his fucked up reasoning in an earlier posts. Votes charter.
561: Doesn't understand why no one thought Mokina was scummy D1.
566: Totally changes suspicions out of the blue with no posted reasons. Votes Shotty.
570: Clears KKN, in this post now charter "isn't even that scummy" according to Chen.
574: Claims to only be after original scum, says I was scummier on D1 then now, even though earlier when she was doing bandwagon reviews etc I wasn't scummy.
575: Can't explain why she's clearing KKN.
577: Concedes veerus being scum, really? You've been on him all day and like 3 posts from charter and you give up on that so easily? After 3 posts by another person you thought could be scum? Says Rally is prob town.
584: Says Replacement vote is best but will be doing a case on me. Says BM is a poor recruitment choice and is now defending Veerus against scum accusations after she's been on him the whole day, brilliant.
585: Misunderstood something RV said.
586: Mod would make move for scum instead of having no night-action.
587: PBPA of me, highly polarized it draws conclusions without even presenting the facts first.
588: Adds something she forgot about post 22.
592: Posts some more reasons, they don't really make sense however. She points out that I voted for FA instead of switching to Kise? Okay, so I hammered scum instead of going for the NL?
593: Claims I would join a veerus wagon even though she's the one pushing him as scum the whole day and I said I thought he was town? Makes perfect sense. Beautifully skims over all my defenses saying she doesn't care, makes sense why would we care about what people have to say, and interprets (and misinterprets) everything as scummy.
617: Asks me about my KKN thoughts.
623: Points tubby towards 602.
639: Asks tubby a question.
642: Misses poptajo.
646: Anti-prod?
676: Non-committal on BM.
717: Asks BM why he was setting himself up to claim, but still doesn't commit even though she's implying he had a reason to claim.
727: Says she can see BMscum doing what he did, but still doesn't say if she thinks he is scum.
So let's see. So we see KC strategizing with BM. KC has defended BM, RV, KKN, and Veerus at different points in the day. KC has had suspicions ranging from veerus to charter to the Replacement to tajo and to me. She goes through all of these and finally settles on me when she gets some support behind her. Her main suspicion veerus that she pushed throughout the day she gave up after 3 posts by charter who she also suspected at the time. Confirmed town BM had her as a top suspect and this is the person were trusting to lead a lynch? I'd ask anyone using her PBPA as evidence to re-read my D1 without presuming scum and tell me how scummy that actually was.
"By three methods we may learn wisdom: First, by reflection, which is noblest; Second, by imitation, which is easiest; and third by experience, which is the bitterest." -Confucius
