Newbie 830: Game Over

[Jed Cooper]

On my initial analysis from my notes, a Mae-Sponge scum team seems possible. I think Sponge setting up mislynches yesterday is pretty condemning.

[Jed Cooper]

Its not usually a good idea to analyze the NK because scum can so easily use it to mislead the town. But Milk suspected Dark, Moose & CSL.

[Jed Cooper]

I think if we dig he made a few passing comments on Sponge too that didn't make it into my notes.

[Thok]

Official Vote Count

SpongeBobShortShorts (1): (DarkLightA)
Maemuki (1): (Jed Cooper)
DarkLightA (0):
AlmasterGM (0):
AfroLaX (0):
moose200x (0):
Jed Cooper (0):

Not Voting (5): (Maemuki, AlmasterGM, SpongeBobShortShorts, AfroLax, moose200x)

With 7 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.

[Jed Cooper]

CSL (5): (Jed Cooper,

My Milked Eek

, moose200x, SpongeBobShortShorts, AfroLaX)

This is the final on the CSL wagon. I think our two best suspects from

this

list are Sponge and Moose.

[Jed Cooper]

@Mae:

Do you have any town Meta you can point to where you are so reluctant to vote?

[SpongeBobShortShorts]

Crap, Milk's not scum. Well, you all know where I stand.

Vote Moose

I should've stuck with my instincts and now an innocent Vanilla is dead. You won't get away this time Moose! *shakes fist*

[Jed Cooper]

Mae: Lurkers tend to be mafia. Old saying "it's better to keep your mouth shut and appear a fool then to open it and prove it" She didn't even vote. Sadly we have no info from her.

Well, how would you react if you saw two players at L-1, and then you were the only one that didn't vote yet?

Also, this defense is inadequate as you never voted for anyone the whole day except to RVS safely with everyone else.

Why were you so eager to vote in the RVS but not in the actual day??

[moose200x]

Crap, Milk's not scum. Well, you all know where I stand.

Vote Moose

I should've stuck with my instincts and now an innocent Vanilla is dead. You won't get away this time Moose! *shakes fist*

Are you serious? You all but said Me and Eek were scum mates and now that eek is cleared you still think it's me?

[SpongeBobShortShorts]

I thought Milk being scum was dependent on you being scum, not the other way around. And that defense leads me to believe that you killed him to clear your name because you misunderstood my argument.

[moose200x]

I thought Milk being scum was dependent on you being scum, not the other way around. And that defense leads me to believe that you killed him to clear your name because you misunderstood my argument.

I gotta be honest, I think that is the best argument you've made all game.

[AfroLaX]

ROFL

At this point, given what SBSS has said since he joined the thread & especially what he is saying against moose now... Well, it makes me lol but on a more serious note, I can't justify pressuring anyone else with my vote right now as much as I can him. Therefore:

Vote: SpongeBobShortShorts

[DarkLightA]

Crap, Milk's not scum.

He sais "Crap, milk's not scum".. If he thought that Eek was mafia, then why doesn't he yell "Hooray!" about not wasting a leech on it?

thought Milk being scum was dependent on you being scum, not the other way around.

Ok, so connecting this to the other statement by you that I quoted, this would be your opinion:

Sponge's opinion, as seen by me:

"I thought that Moose was scum, but then I changed my vote to CSL, and leeched a townie. Now, since Moose

obviously

is a mafia, because my instincts tell me so, it's unfortunate that Eek was a townie, because if Moose really is a mafia then Eek can't be his scum partner.


See how it doesn't make sense?

[SpongeBobShortShorts]

It might not have made sense, but

moose called it a good argument

. If someone were wrong, especially if it put me in danger, I wouldn't say they had a good argument. I would find holes in it. Moose knows his own posting better than any of us do. He of all people should be able to tell us why I'm wrong. Instead, he doesn't do that. He tells me I have a good argument. If you want to lynch me, I guess I can't stop you, but moose isn't defending himself like he would be I were wrong.

[moose200x]

I thought Milk being scum was dependent on you being scum, not the other way around. And that defense leads me to believe that you killed him to clear your name because you misunderstood my argument.

I gotta be honest, I think that is the best argument you've made all game.

One more question, did you think to kill eek or was it your partner?

[SpongeBobShortShorts]

Also, I don't know how my point didn't make sense.

I said "If moose is scum, Eek might be scum."
Moose hears "If I'm scum, we're both scum."
He thinks "If Eek dies, then SBSS won't think I'm scum"
He kills Eek.

Unless someone cares to point out something else that might have happened, this is what I think the sequence of events is.

[SpongeBobShortShorts]

I thought Milk being scum was dependent on you being scum, not the other way around. And that defense leads me to believe that you killed him to clear your name because you misunderstood my argument.

I gotta be honest, I think that is the best argument you've made all game.

One more question, did you think to kill eek or was it your partner?

Oh you hush, moose. I'm VT, like I said.

[SpongeBobShortShorts]

I mean killing Eek was my idea and I said I'd take the fall for it because my partner's a roleblocker and therefore more necessary.

NOT REALLY OK? GAWD.

What kind of answer were you honestly expecting? This isn't like Legally Blond, where you can ask "Boyfriend's name?" and get the answer "Chuck" if the closeted poolboy doesn't want to tell you about his boyfriend.

[AfroLaX]

So given the clustered posts, ranting, and generally incoherent or CrapLogic-based responses... I take it that SBSS doesn't handle vote pressure too well.

Um, I know this might be a bit far-fetched but SBSS appears to be in a bit of a panic so I wouldn't be surprised if he slipped up... I'd like some clarification on the following:

This game is an open set up F11 game. We have a 1 in 4 chance of using any of the following set ups.

a. 1 Mafia Goon, 1 Mafia Roleblocker, 1 Cop, 1 Doctor, and 5 vanilla townies
b. 1 Mafia Goon, 1 Mafia Roleblocker, and 7 vanilla townies
c. 2 Mafia Goons, 1 Cop, and 6 vanilla townies
d. 2 Mafia Goons, 1 Doctor, and 6 vanilla townies

I mean killing Eek was my idea and I said I'd take the fall for it because my partner's a

roleblocker

and therefore more necessary.

Point: Only two setup possibilities contain roleblockers.

[AfroLaX]

EBWOP:

Expect a VLA from me for about ~18 hours. I'm going to sleep now and then I have university for a large chunk of the day tomorrow.

My vote against SBSS stands.

[SpongeBobShortShorts]

You missed the line directly after it.

"NOT REALLY OK? GAWD"

I was joking because moose asked a stupid question. I don't know what the setup is.

[moose200x]

So given the clustered posts, ranting, and generally incoherent or CrapLogic-based responses... I take it that SBSS doesn't handle vote pressure too well.

Um, I know this might be a bit far-fetched but SBSS appears to be in a bit of a panic so I wouldn't be surprised if he slipped up... I'd like some clarification on the following:

This game is an open set up F11 game. We have a 1 in 4 chance of using any of the following set ups.

a. 1 Mafia Goon, 1 Mafia Roleblocker, 1 Cop, 1 Doctor, and 5 vanilla townies
b. 1 Mafia Goon, 1 Mafia Roleblocker, and 7 vanilla townies
c. 2 Mafia Goons, 1 Cop, and 6 vanilla townies
d. 2 Mafia Goons, 1 Doctor, and 6 vanilla townies

Pwned

I mean killing Eek was my idea and I said I'd take the fall for it because my partner's a

roleblocker

and therefore more necessary.

Point: Only two setup possibilities contain roleblockers.

[moose200x]

^^^ messed up

[moose200x]

So given the clustered posts, ranting, and generally incoherent or CrapLogic-based responses... I take it that SBSS doesn't handle vote pressure too well.

Um, I know this might be a bit far-fetched but SBSS appears to be in a bit of a panic so I wouldn't be surprised if he slipped up... I'd like some clarification on the following:

This game is an open set up F11 game. We have a 1 in 4 chance of using any of the following set ups.

a. 1 Mafia Goon, 1 Mafia Roleblocker, 1 Cop, 1 Doctor, and 5 vanilla townies
b. 1 Mafia Goon, 1 Mafia Roleblocker, and 7 vanilla townies
c. 2 Mafia Goons, 1 Cop, and 6 vanilla townies
d. 2 Mafia Goons, 1 Doctor, and 6 vanilla townies

I mean killing Eek was my idea and I said I'd take the fall for it because my partner's a

roleblocker

and therefore more necessary.

Point: Only two setup possibilities contain roleblockers.

pwned

[DarkLightA]

I think there's something off with your "joke" SBSS.. My vote against you stands.