Newbie 792--Mafia Island ~ Mafia win!

[Papa Zito]

I wouldn't mind giving it a shot. There are rather rigorous rules about games on here though, so it may have to be done offsite.

[Indigo Heron]

Here's my question to IH - who would you have investigated in Night 3?

I honestly wasn't thinking about you. I was thinking about Thesp, and I just had to investigate him to make sure that he was scum.

Also, moderator, can we have a rematch?

[Khelvaster]

I can PM the Road to Roam and Little Italy list mods and see if either one of those two would clear a new game. Non-game people are definitely allowed to talk in-game once the game's over.

I'm so impressed with this group of players for wanting to replay with the exact same group. This game's definitely being nominated in the Scummies--it was awesome to read. I was especially happy with the relatively low wall-of-text frequency .

[AGar]

I'm game for a rematch if we get one.

Of course I hope I don't draw scum because now you all know how I think...

or do you? Muahahahahaha.

[AGar]

Also... what are "The Scummies"?

I'm not gonna lie, I haven't ventured much outside of Newbie 792 and the Scumleague Fantasy Football thread here.

[Shrinehme]

Heheh... I was lured to this thread by the flavor ["Mafia Island" in the title made it stand out among the other Newbie Games, ya'know?], so I occasionally leafed through a few pages in my free time. Indigo Heron receiving a result on Night 2, Thesp's play-style, MiteyMouse surviving Night 3, ect. were all factors that kept me interested.

I laughed at AGar's "Victory is mine!" line, in the final vote.

I'm a bit disappointed that I missed out. It looked fun. Congrats to AGar and Boxman.

[AGar]

I laughed at AGar's "Victory is mine!" line, in the final vote.

Haha thanks. I was so excited, especially because I had missed out on the initial chance when Darkstrike premie voted on Thesp earlier in the day by like

5 minutes

.

[Wickedestjr]

Good game AGar, I had no clue you were scum. I thought that Thesp was scum, and considered Darkstrike being scum, but never did I think of you being scum. After my lynch I still thought that Thesp was scum, and was suspicious of his desire to get rid of somebody that claimed cop.

Thanks for moderating this Khelvaster. This was a fun game.

[Indigo Heron]

I can PM the Road to Roam and Little Italy list mods and see if either one of those two would clear a new game. Non-game people are definitely allowed to talk in-game once the game's over.

Please do.

I'm so impressed with this group of players for wanting to replay with the exact same group. This game's definitely being nominated in the Scummies--it was awesome to read. I was especially happy with the relatively low wall-of-text frequency .

Scummies? Seriously? Wow. I'm honoured to be a part of this game, then.

[Darkstrike_11]

I echo the thanks to khelvaster, the flavour was awesome!

And I would be incredibly up for a rematch, it would be really interesting! It would be interesting to see if people's playstyles changed or not. I don't see why we couldn't just carry on in this thread, "792pt2" or something.

Plus next time we'll know not to think AGar is a confused newbie but a CRIMINAL MASTERMIND. I can't help but think that having played a match with everyone already a town win is more likely. Then again, I hadn't seen enough of players like tracker to have a semi decent meta.

Roll on game 2!

[MiteyMouse]

Wait...was there really only 1 replacement this whole game? Now, that is something really special everyone!

[Wickedestjr]

Yeah but that was at the very beginning of the game, so even better.

[Khelvaster]

I need people to second these Scummies nominations:

Thesp for best IC
Agar for best newbie

Scummies topic is at http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.php?p=1829777

[Khelvaster]

I just modded Newbie 792. It was the best newbie game I've ever seen played. The players agreed, and a couple of them just asked me in-topic if it would be possible for me to re-mod this same setup, but to shuffle the roles. Is there any possibility I could open another Newbie up with this playergroup in it? Literally everyone wants to play again, so signups would not be an issue. I've never seen so many newbies fall into enjoying mafia so quickly, and I'd like to humor them. What do you say about this?

The game link is:

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... &start=725

Sure, reroll it as Newbie 833. It's not going to affect anything, and if you need replacements it will actually help the queue out because you'll be pulling players from there to replace.

Glad you guys had a good time!

When you get the list together of who is getting which roles just PM me and I'll use your list to construct the Queue post for the game.


Vel

We're in business. I've sent PMs out to everyone.

In:

Boxman
Mitey Mouse
Tracker
Thesp
Indigo Heron
Papa Zito
Darkstrike

Waiting to hear from:

Wickedstjr
AGar

[MiteyMouse]

So...we're rerunning? This should be fun...again!

[Boxman]

Cool.

Really great job, AGar. You were amazing.

[Papa Zito]

Where did Thesp go?

I think we should use the same roles and just try to catch AGar. lawl

/in since I can't PM from my phone.

[Khelvaster]

As much as I'd like to make AGar scum just to see him lynched on d1, that won't happen...oh wait...I just gave sensitive game data away. Maybe I'll make him scum after all...Crap. Now what do I do? Perhaps if he's town, you'll think I made him scum just to trick you. Hmmm...that would make it really clear for him to be scum, no?

All joking aside, I'm using random number generation (either dice or random.org) to pick roles.

[tracker]

darkstrike i don't quite understand what you mean, can you clarify it for me please?

[Thesp]

Sorry I'm late responding to the thread - I was out on vacation this weekend, got in late Sunday night, and work was killer today. Nonetheless, I did follow along on my wife's Treo, and when I saw that AGar had posted, and had voted for Darkstrike_11, I momentarily was happy we'd won. Then I actually

read

his post. Well played, AGar. I had a moment's hesitation about you, but darkstrike_11's reasonable but unfortunate waffle on someone who ended up scum steered me the wrong way, and I wouldn't have voted correctly at all. Well done!

I had an absolute blast with this game, and I would be honored to play with each and every one of you again. (I've re-upped for the redux as well. ) I'll have more thoughts to post later when I don't have to run, but I loved every bit of this game! Thanks to all of you for playing!

[Indigo Heron]

Well, I know who I'm random voting for Day 1.

[tracker]

Indigo, i was lookin around on the sight and stumbled across a mini-theme chess mafia game, that looks incredibly interesting,(if you EVER need a replacement in that game let me know) though i don't know which faction you're on i do believe the town has the the game in the bag in under 10 moves. and i currently can't see any way around it.

[Indigo Heron]

I know that. Black probably knows it too, and I expect a resignation from them in 5 moves (if they are smart).

[AGar]

Khelvaster, I'm down to play, but I haven't gotten my PM yet from you. o.O

[Khelvaster]

oooh, crap. I totally forgot to PM you. I don't know why. Anyway, you and wickedstjr both said /in, so the new game's going up as soon as I can get some flavor going.