I'd like to refer to the people on Zwet's band wagon: Box, Slicey, Percy, Zakeri, Sudai, Qwints, Whoot. Percy is confirmed scum, Qwints has been pushed to another plane. That leaves us with Box, Slicey, Zak, Sudai, and Whoot. I hate analyzing Zwet lynches because so many people hate his meta and lynch on that /facepalm.
The hammer is clearly the scummiest part, speedlynching at its finest. Whoot's first post said he wasn't new to mafia and since then he has played the newbie card multiple times. We have his roleclaim, Crovax, a black creature that turns against the Weatherlight crew. Honestly if I were to assign him a role he would be a mafia traitor imo, but the miller claim fits, albeit a bit more roughly. I don't believe the miller claim, Whoot has sent mixed signals since he joined the game and before his speedlynch he contributed little. He replaces in on page 4, posts nothing of content except for 1 post on page 5 about a flavor theory in another game, disappears for 2 pages and then comes back for the speedlynch. If I knew I was a miller, I would be getting my pro-town ass in gear to draw a NK and/or avoid an investigation. His only defense has been some lame policy lynch idea about a role that Zwet wasn't, WIFOM (see 291 i.e.), and emotional appeals. The self-hammer was interesting, but it doesn't convince me since he tried to reverse it with a technicality in the way he typed it in and then let the town convince the mod to not kill him. Dropping him off somewhere else is simply a bad plan, we have a decent lynch right in front of us and throwing him to another town where they have to waste another day deciding if they should lynch him is a waste of time.
Box: There have been several things pointed out about his D1 vote that I'm not going to bother to reiterate. He has a valid point that the speedlynch prevented him from unvoting if he wasn't on at the time. One thing I would like to note is that if Whoot flips scum there's been a TREMENDOUS amount of distancing between Boxy and Whoot.
Slicey: Go Skar-, fuck wrong game. At any rate, I felt like he knew Zwet's meta well and voted against it anyways, I can't really make anything out of this because he was V/LA at the time of the lynch and couldn't have affected it.
Zak and Sudai both struck me as town on the first re-read, I'm leaning more neutral towards Star and Head, they both struck me as less than fully involved. Star didn't DO anything on D1, she said things and contributed some, but lack of actions (i.e. voting, building cases) doesn't do it for me. Head has popped in to avoid prods it seems. He generally says something useful when he does show up, but he's gone most of the time. I'd note for D2 that he's not joining the Whoot bandwagon.
Most if not all of these impressions are based on D1 rather than D2. D2 has been very unhelpful because Whoot is such an easy target. We need to see his alignment to move forward in a meaningful fashion, right now all we have beyond his scuminess is speculation. All this said, I have no problem ending the day.
Vote: Whoot1234
"By three methods we may learn wisdom: First, by reflection, which is noblest; Second, by imitation, which is easiest; and third by experience, which is the bitterest." -Confucius
