Why do you care what is the "right thing to do" to no be scummy or suspicious. You should be more concerned with doing what is right for the town instead of what is right to make you look good.jasonT1981 wrote:So uvoting a claimed cop is suspicious? how?????
Not keeping your vote on a claimed cop who is uncountered is the right thing to do I would think... not scummy or suspicious.
jasonT1981 wrote:Keep watchingcanadianbovine wrote:Nice softclaim here. This one can go either way, and im not fully done with season 5 [im on about episode 6] so im unsure of what side you'd be on.Jason wrote: No, but I have shaped the lives of others for many years and keep calm under pressure... even when guns are pointed at me accusingly like they have been in this game
But my eyes have been on some people for many years. You never know where you will find me... Portland, Miami or maybe even Tustin, California
re: Bolded...I thought that was implied in what I saidZONEACE wrote:Looking back, something bothers me.
Why do you care what is the "right thing to do" to no be scummy or suspicious.jasonT1981 wrote:So uvoting a claimed cop is suspicious? how?????
Not keeping your vote on a claimed cop who is uncountered is the right thing to do I would think... not scummy or suspicious.You should be more concerned with doing what is right for the towninstead of what is right to make you look good.
I mean, I could respond to it because there are still points there that I disagree with you on, but I think it might be best if we leave that for now before it just becomes a huge distraction for the town. I think we've both made our points clear enough.emptyger wrote:Most of what I posted is a defensive response to your attacks, so if you don’t have response to it, then I’m done too.
You're welcome to call it that if you'd like. It doesn't nullify that is what you were doing. What is strange to me about you and jason, however, is that you seemed to be suspicious of jason, so I don't know why you would try and detract from attacks on him. With Jebus, I don't have much of an opinion either way yet, nor do I think attacking someone who clearly needs to be replaced is helpful to the town's end.emptyger wrote:I’d like you to explain how what you’ve done with Jebus isn’t the exact same thing you’ve said is a suspicious thing I’ve done to Jason.
I'm curious as to why Juls would help research a point that she claims to have disagreed with. Seems very strange to support a line of quetioning and then in hindsight call it bad.emptyger wrote:Also, what do you think about this?
I disagreed with the declaration that "if this is true then he is scum" part. I didn't think it was an unreasonable question (asking if the Marshall was in Season 5), I just didn't agree that it absolutely 100% made him scum because of the answer. You have still avoided telling me where I said anything about Reckoner other than his claim seems off.Emptyger 398 wrote:Pop quiz:
Player A makes a statement that you disagree with. You’re town. Do you:
(a) State that you disagree with A’s conclusion.
(b) Go to lengths to show that A’s premise is true.
See above.VP 404 wrote:I'm curious as to why Juls would help research a point that she claims to have disagreed with. Seems very strange to support a line of quetioning and then in hindsight call it bad.
That was intended to mean that the mod might have given unexpected roles to people to prevent us making assumptions about what role each character might be. Given that this is a very character-specific game, I was suggesting that perhaps the mod had not given every Lost character a role that you'd predict in order to keep the set-up more ambiguous. I was specifically thinking of the recent WWF Royal Rumble mafia game I played in which wrestlers who weren't tag team partners in real life were mason partners in the game and several wrestlers were jobbers (the flavour name of vanilla townie) when they would not have been called that in RL. In short, I was saying that Kate not being an obvious choice for cop shouldn't make us think that Reckoner isn't one.Juls wrote:I don't understand what you mean by this comment. Please specifically explain the italicized part.Locke Lamora 333 wrote:Kate as the cop is the bit I don't like but it could just bein there to stop us guessing the other roles.
What was implied was that you thought you were doing the right thing. I didn't see any particular inclination to help the town, nor did you make much effort to question the claim or direct your suspicions elsewhere if you did believe Reckoner. That implies to me that you thought you were doing the right thing to look town, not to help the town.jasonT1981 wrote:re: Bolded...I thought that was implied in what I saidZONEACE wrote:Looking back, something bothers me.
Why do you care what is the "right thing to do" to no be scummy or suspicious.jasonT1981 wrote:So uvoting a claimed cop is suspicious? how?????
Not keeping your vote on a claimed cop who is uncountered is the right thing to do I would think... not scummy or suspicious.You should be more concerned with doing what is right for the towninstead of what is right to make you look good.
This.VP Baltar wrote:Dear Everyone,
Stop talking about breadcrumbing.
Thanks,
The Management
As it seems I am not near lynch yet according to what is the current vote count (by my count)VP Baltar wrote:The silence in this game disturbs me. It seems you're Mr. Popular, Jason. I suggest claiming asap.