Newbie 830: Game Over

[Jed Cooper]

/confirm

[Jed Cooper]

I have to say that I get suspicious of My Milked Eek due to his "interesting" vote..

Vote: My Milked Eek

Get the discussion going, and

my vote is open for change

.

Sounds scum-aware to me.

Vote Dark

[Jed Cooper]

I have to say that I get suspicious of My Milked Eek

due to his "interesting" vote..

@Dark:

Also please explain the bolded.

[Jed Cooper]

I have to say that I get suspicious of My Milked Eek due to his "interesting" vote..

Vote: My Milked Eek

Good, your vote tells us 2 things:

1) your vote isn't random
2) something is off with my vote according to you

If you could elaborate on the second thing please.

Is this some sort of scum tactic?

Obviously.

No, seriously, it is easier for us to tie posts to a person with visual material, such as avatars. It also adds more character to you as a poster/player, imo.

I disagree on every count.

Could you please give details on this? Also, are you saying that they might be scum together?

[Jed Cooper]

I have to say that I get suspicious of My Milked Eek due to his "interesting" vote..

Vote: My Milked Eek

Get the discussion going, and

my vote is open for change

.

Sounds scum-aware to me.

Vote Dark

My idea was that My Milked Eek voted for a pointless reason (the avatar). Now, you are the only one supporting him.. Now,

that

seems scum-like to me.

Could you please give details on this? Also, are you saying that they might be scum together? (milk)

No. MY question is why is Milk defending you here. Are you two scum buddies?

[Jed Cooper]

No. MY question is why is Milk defending you here. Are you two scum buddies?

Who am I defending where exactly again?

I'm just questioning the "easy treatment" you are giving Dark in a "coaching him through it" kind of way.

Then Moose said he disagreed with your points on all counts and the idea came to me that maybe you both were scum?

[Jed Cooper]

I want to make sure that dark understands what he's saying, it appears to me he isn't really aware of the gravity of his vote for me and his following posts. Don't think that I'm not suspicious of his behaviour right now. I just don't see it fitting to vote him just yet.

Ok. Point well taken.

[Jed Cooper]

@Mae:

What is your opinion of Dark with all of his posts now taken into consideration?

[Jed Cooper]

Unvote: My Milked Eeek. Vote: Belili.

He isn't saying anything. This needs to change.

And for that matter, I think Veril has some explaining to do as well..

[Jed Cooper]

@Jed, I think he's definitely trying his best to try and find scum...or he is scum or he's trying to wave the suspicion off him to another person. One of the two.

A rather interesting opinion/comment as it tells us absolutely nothing about your opinion on darklight. And even if it does, it leaves a lot of wiggle room for you. Either way, I don't like this post.

Right and I noticed that she accused him but didn't vote him...

[Jed Cooper]

Moose, I don't mean to be confrontational here or anything but I am starting to agree with Milk here. You are starting to display an anti-town attitude. Being reckless doesn't make person obvtown you know...

[Jed Cooper]

CSL, I would like a rundown of your views on the various players in the game if that would be ok?

[Jed Cooper]

I'd like to say something here:

We are only 5 pages in and we are already looking at a lynch.

I think the best thing we can do right now is try to focus on who would be Moose's scum buddy.

For starters, I'm going to look for anything that might show a Dark-Moose scum team.

I would also like to point out that CSL has replaced in here and has effectively brought us to L-2 in less than a page...

[Jed Cooper]

@Moose:

What do you think of Dark's play so far? How about the other players?

@Dark:

What do you think of Moose's play so far? How about the other players?

[Jed Cooper]

Moose, before you go can you please make a list of players and your analysis of them?

[Jed Cooper]

@Maemuki, Belili, My Milked Eek:

What is your opinion of Moose's play and who is his most likely scum buddy (if you think he is scum) or who is most likely scum (if you think Moose is town)?

[Jed Cooper]

Yes, well just so you know, it is

very

common for scum to "bus" their partners on the way out so as to alleviate suspicion.

But I am especially waiting to hear from those 3 as they aren't yet voting him.

[Jed Cooper]

But I am especially waiting to hear from those 3 as they aren't yet voting him.

Neither are you. What do you think of moose's play?

Nothing personal but I find his style of play deplorable and I would have dropped the hammer already if it wasn't so early in the game.

[Jed Cooper]

Whom I do have a nagging feeling about is CSL:
- fence sitting
- trying to appear a bit too protown
- eagerness to lynch

I got the exact same read here as well.

[Jed Cooper]

@All:

Does anyone have a town read on CSL?

[Jed Cooper]

Jed, Maemuki & AlMaster: What are your thoughts on this & on moose in general?

Btw, Where on Earth is Belili?

Well I think the Moose question is moot really... Oh wait is that the sound mooses make??

No but really I think his playstyle is anti-town and an easy place for scum to hide. For both of the aforementioned reasons, I am not against his lynch.

[Jed Cooper]

@Almaster:

What percentage chance do you think there is of Moose being scum here?

[Jed Cooper]

[b[@All:[/b] Do you snore when you sleep and if so, would you be willing to wear a CPAP mask if your doctor recommended it?

[Jed Cooper]

@CSL:

1) How much experience have you had playing Mafia?

2) Why are so acting so defensive?

[Jed Cooper]

What do you mean no clue?

Don't you see how you are suddenly backtracking heavily?

Why aren't you taking action with the courage of your convictions like a townie should?

Are you also aware that it is a scum trait to be weak & waver over one's convictions?

So I ask you again, why are you being so defensive?

[Jed Cooper]

Afro, moose is somewhat correct. If he turns town on lynch, you're going to look suspicious. IGMEOY

I

really

don't like this post.

Unvote, Vote CSL

[Jed Cooper]

Don't go for that gun CSL, I need you alive...

[Jed Cooper]

I have to admit that CSL is actually

more

scummy in my eyes than even Moose is.

@All:

What is your opinion of CSL?

[Jed Cooper]

@CSL, not like that, I'm surprised at how everybody changed their suspicions so quickly.

I know, but how I was the one commenting at the time, you would direct it to me...right?

I sure did, he didn't take the vote off since RVS. Not sure what that means though.

Mae, what it means is you have been fence sitting this whole game. The only vote you've been comfortable with is your RVS vote along with everyone else's.

Saying, "I don't know" a bunch of times sounds really scum-aware...

@Mae:

Who do you think is scummier and why:

1) Dark
2) Moose
3) CSL

Please analyze each.

[Jed Cooper]

@Sponge:

Don't you see CSL as

more

scummy than Moose? I mean I have seen 3 categories of potential scum in this game so far, each one worse than the next:

1) Dark -- Newbie scum looking behavior
2) Moose -- Intentional newbie scum looking behavior
3) CSL -- Unintentional scum-like behavior (trying to look town)

Isn't 3 obviously worse??

[Jed Cooper]

Because unintentional means a scum-slip. It means acting like scum-trying-to-look-town.

[Jed Cooper]

Well the best thing to do as town is to scum-hunt confidently and efficiently; say what you mean and mean what you say.

Right now I don't like how Spoonge is voting Moose over you. I think its obvious you are more scummy here...

[Jed Cooper]

People say things by mistake all the time. I've typed out sentences that accidentally revealed more than I wanted people to know before. If you don't reread what you post before you post it you're liable to make mistakes like that.

Are you serious? I'm not buying this. Why are you so invested in this severely weak argument?

[Jed Cooper]

Just so you two know: I'm pretty sure exactly one of you is scum. Y'all voted for each other pretty early, moose has been pretty dang scummy and CSL has been uncomfortably buddy-buddy with me this whole time. If the person who gets lynched flips town I'm going for the other one next.

Ya, and what if

you're

scum and setting up mislynches?

[Jed Cooper]

I need clarification

right now

on this "blue=cop" thing. Do we have a claimed town cop or not?

[Jed Cooper]

I think that after my re-read and analysis I will make the following decision:

Vote Mae

[Jed Cooper]

On my initial analysis from my notes, a Mae-Sponge scum team seems possible. I think Sponge setting up mislynches yesterday is pretty condemning.

[Jed Cooper]

Its not usually a good idea to analyze the NK because scum can so easily use it to mislead the town. But Milk suspected Dark, Moose & CSL.

[Jed Cooper]

I think if we dig he made a few passing comments on Sponge too that didn't make it into my notes.

[Jed Cooper]

CSL (5): (Jed Cooper,

My Milked Eek

, moose200x, SpongeBobShortShorts, AfroLaX)

This is the final on the CSL wagon. I think our two best suspects from

this

list are Sponge and Moose.

[Jed Cooper]

@Mae:

Do you have any town Meta you can point to where you are so reluctant to vote?

[Jed Cooper]

Mae: Lurkers tend to be mafia. Old saying "it's better to keep your mouth shut and appear a fool then to open it and prove it" She didn't even vote. Sadly we have no info from her.

Well, how would you react if you saw two players at L-1, and then you were the only one that didn't vote yet?

Also, this defense is inadequate as you never voted for anyone the whole day except to RVS safely with everyone else.

Why were you so eager to vote in the RVS but not in the actual day??

[Jed Cooper]

@Mae:

Do you have any town Meta you can point to where you are so reluctant to vote?

I don't know if I'm allowed to do this, but I actually do. It's an ongoing game, but I'm dead.
Look at Newbie 817, I never voted after the RVS [I didn't know who was more scummy], and I flipped town.

PBPA is on the works.

Unvote, Vote Sponge

[Jed Cooper]

Ya its really early to hammer. Let's wait until we hear from everyone. I think everybody should post their top 2-3 scum suspects with reasoning before we hammer here and we should wait until everyone does it before the hammer drops.

[Jed Cooper]

Well everyone really needs to list their top 2-3 scum suspects with the reasons because this is seriously much to early to be lynching in the day without a cop guilty peek or something.

[Jed Cooper]

^^^ this is nice but we need your view on the top 2-3 scummy people and why. Well now we will have to wait until she gets back tomorrow. Well that's good anyway because we can be discussing who the second scum is...