1) You're all damn lucky for the rules of the game. Every game I've read says that if there's not enough votes for a lynch then there's a nolynch. To get one for the highest vote-getter allows much more wiggle room for scum to perhaps not both be on a wagon. From the way I see it, it's very hard to get anybody lynched with no scum on the wagon which is why vote analysis works at all. In a game with two scum, having one on the wagon would make it average difficulty, while having no scum makes it really tough.
At the end of D1, on Mevorra we had: Nureins, Edmund and Belili.
On Weepy we had Pika, Green who is confirmed town, Mevorra and Tubby/wicked.
Obviously weepy was a townie, so I look at the other people on the vote. Pika, Mevorra and Tubby/wicked. Pika was on green when he got to L-1, and then on Weepy for her L-1. Mevorra was on Green for his L-1, on Belili for his L-2, and then on Weepy for her L-1. Tubby/wicked was only on Belili.
Major suspicion continues on Mevorra/xBEKx for being on 3 of the major wagons yesterday, and then today xBEKx is voting tubby for doing basically the same thing Mev did on D1 (vote Weeping to prevent a lynch on Mev). Tubby only being on 1 major wagon keeps my suspicion down on him, but the circumstances to save Mevorra are suspicious. To reiterate: Tubby is only most likely scum if Mevorra flips due to saving a scum partner. I don't understand how you can miss who the NK was though, from either perspective. Scum would know who they kill, and townies would have to be able to look at who's confirmed town. Still more likely that forgetting in this case is a townie tell rather than a scum tell. Also considering my point about how it's somewhat difficult for people to get lynched, I'm curious as to why Mevorra's wagon stalled. One scenario is where they're scum and the partner doesn't want to hammer/get her lynched. Obviously that's not the only scenario, but the way it built up just so much steam and fizzled is strange. With the mev/tubby votes after, it certainly looks like this is the case though.
The other scenarios is that she was scum, and the partner was already on the wagon, she's town, one or both scum were also on the wagon so townies were away from the game/cautious/didn't believe the evidence against her, or she's townie and scum were never on the wagon. I'll need to go through and look at everybody in isolation to get a better feel on that.
xBEKx: Now that I'm caught up, I'm willing to vote you. I would suggest that you claim as my vote would put you at L-1. In the case of you not being scum, this would allow scum to quick hammer you cutting off discussion, while leaving them a free door to another NK and lylo. Yes, this would allow the hammerer to come under serious suspicion and probably lynched, that'd still look like a shorter day with less to really go on to look for a partner if the hammerer was scum.
ALMOST
voting for xBEKx.
