Mafia 96 - Murder in Emerald City (Game Over!)

[Wickedestjr]

@Lowell - I am not the only person who has made comments like the one in post 636.

[Wickedestjr]

@Lowell (again) - Why did you wait until now to post these opinions. Have you completely missed days 2 and 3?

[iamausername]

-=Vote Count #45=-

Xylthixlm (4) - roflcopter, Wickedestjr, Lowell, curiouskarmadog
Namttam (2) - SerialClergyman, Kmd4390
Hayker (1) - molestargazer
molestargazer (1) - Hayker
Lowell (1) - Xylthixlm

Not Voting (4) - Achilles, Namttam, Kublai Khan, Faraday

7 to lynch.

[Lowell]

@wicked- because I haven't had time. Chill out. To continue.

From page 31:

751- wicked says good points by VP, but he wants to hear from mastin before voting [-, really?]
753- wicked votes mastin [+, better]
768- mastin leads with 7 votes
788- wicked annoyed by ppl voting mastin (mufasa, Lowell) [-, derailment]
796- ckd votes mastin [+, not cerulean]
813- wicked still annoyed by people voting mastin (ckool)
815- mastin claims emerald roleblocker
830s-840s- votes pile onto mafiamann
908- namttam votes VP [-]
943- kmd enters, votes rofl [+, good entry posts]
958- hayker votes rofl

Getting closer to the D1 lynch. Some thoughts:

1) It's stupid that we didn't see mastin claiming "Mafia Roleblocker" as him being Mafia Roleblocker

2) People who look town:

kmd

- his behavior at entering is good, as is his contribution

3) People who look bad:

rofl

- usually I do whatever he tells me to do in mafia games, but that might be a bad idea here. His only presence is to reassure us that KK is a miller.

namttam

- always seems to be on the wrong side of everything. The VP vote makes no sense, even without hindsight

4) People who look REALLY bad:

wicked

- he's falling all over himself trying to protect mastin. His 751, followed immediately by 753 make no sense. In addition, his whining about people voting masin in 788 and 813 looks bad. Yes, yes, I realize those three votes (Lowell, mafiamann, ckool) were cast without much or any explanation, but WICKED HIMSELF WAS VOTING MASTIN ALSO, and supposedly found him scummy. I find it hard to believe that a town voting his best instinct would be angry when other people join the bandwagon. He's trying to play both ways: being on the mastin wagon early, but complaining when it gets closer to lynch. Very very scummy.

[Lowell]

From page 41 (still Day 1):

1007- mole enters, votes mufasa [meh]
1000s- ppl push for a mafiamann claim
1030- hayker hammers, following townie claim
1034- mafiasmann, kise, mufasa (town) and zazie (vermillian scum) dead

DAY 2
1051- xly enters, vote hayker
1054- lowell votes hayker
1055- KK votes lowell for going w/ the flow [+, fair]
1067- hayker votes rofl
1073- rofl votes mastin [+]
1082- xyl votes mastin [+]
1084- KK votes mastin
1095- kmd votes rofl [-]
1099- rofl opints out kmd's buddying w/ mastin [+]
1103- namttam votes VP [?]
1110s- rofl and kmd argue pointlessly
1125- ckd votes ckool
1164- ckd convinced, votes mastin, still suspects ckool [+]
1186- wicked votes ckool after convincing himself [----, mastin the other suspect]
1206- SC votes ckool [-, protecting mastin]
1214- namttam votes rofl
1220- KK votes ckool
1223- hayker votes ckool
1226- ckool leads with 5 votes, mastin, rofl have 3 each
1228- xyl votes ckool
1237- rofl votes ckool
1241- ckool cliams VIGILANTE, claims N0 kill

Thoughts:

1) People who look good:

rofl, KK

- for sniffing out the mastin headfake

ckd

- he joined the mastin wagon at a good time for someone who isn't aligned with mastin. The two roleblockers point is a good one, and scum might want to try to ignore that, and wouldn't use that opportunity to join the bandwagon

2) People who look bad:

wicked

- as ever, defending mastin. Right after ckd switched his vote from ckool to mastin (after the two town roleblockers was pointed out) but leaving the door open for voting ckool, wicked jumps in with a post saying "hey, maybe ckool is scum," then a post voting ckool.

SC

- also seems eager to not lynch mastin

[Lowell]

The rest will come tomorrow.

[roflcopter]

fallen

- look again at 528, 535, and 537. Zazie lightly coaches fallen, fallen says "hey what gives", and zazie reminds him that they should be talking about ckool. Unlike zazie to behave this way, and do it so quickly.

remember everyone, fallen angel and xyl are the same person

[Xylthixlm]

Same player slot, not same person.

[Faraday]

v/la for next 2 days. sorry for short notice.

[iamausername]

-=SpyreX replaces Achilles=-

[SpyreX]

Sup, replacement in the house (not even sure who I replaced yet).

I'll be playing catchup now.

[curiouskarmadog]

as being a replacement too...I dont envy you

[SpyreX]

Up to page 28 and I swear if you haven't killed Mastin the "OHH GOD I AM SO SCUM IT IS OOZING FROM MY PORES" I will kill a kitten.

There are others.

[SpyreX]

Another note:

Seriously. Follow me here.

Megaposts are like chocolate. They are nice every once in a while.

Instead, we have a bunch of fat babies who probably can't roll over anymore. My lord almighty. GET ON A TREADMILL

[SpyreX]

@Rofl, Lowell, Faraday, Empkings Alt, Mufasa via 34-35:

WHAT IN THE HELL?

Not all 5 of you can be scum. No way.

What in the hell was that. Seriously.

[SpyreX]

Ohh Zaz was scum what a surprise there

We hath a pro-town killing role as well. Guaranteed.

[SpyreX]

I swear to god if ckool is the lynch kittens on the other side of the UNIVERSE will tremble in preparation for the kicks coming.

[SpyreX]

Ohh hay look at that he's the vig. MORE SURPRISES 'in ON IN

[Kmd4390]

Funny how Spy is right about everyone who has

already flipped

.

[SpyreX]

:O Well I'll be damned I thought for sure Mastin/Zaz were going to be the same group.

That doesn't change TOO much but kills my "swarm tactics theory" a little.

[Xylthixlm]

Funny how Spy is right about everyone who has

already flipped

.

This is the fundamental reason why I don't put too much weight on opinions in replacement/catching-up posts.

That applies to Lowell too.

[Kmd4390]

@Rofl, Lowell, Faraday, Empkings Alt, Mufasa via 34-35:

WHAT IN THE HELL?

Not all 5 of you can be scum. No way.

What in the hell was that. Seriously.

^This is the only post that mentions living players so far. And it's basically a "you all did something scummy, but can't all be scum" which pretty much says nothing.

[SpyreX]

I'm still catching up you silly goose(geese). I'm on 61.

I have SHOCKING REVELATIONS when I'm done.

No kidding those shouldn't be huge piles of super information - they are just the most obvious notes as I'm going along.

[SpyreX]

... Wicked is the mason partner?

God damnit.

(note this means I believe Hayker and THROWS OUT a ton of my ideas)

[SpyreX]

... TWO neighbor sets and masons?

The secret 4th neighbor is scum. Hands down.