Boost Mafia 2 (Game Over)

[Kmd4390]

I don't see millar as scum right now.

[cateraction]

Boost: Battlemage, KMD, Sajin

[millar13]

Cateraction that was the worst hidden OMGUS i have ever seen in my entire time on this site. Can you please have a real case against me? In many ways, delaying D1 anymore would have done no favors for the town. And Mufasa despite clearly being a town member was giving out too many scum-signs that other players were begin to get mixed reactions. Mastin will be the center of attention, and I am sure I will add my vote if the wagon fully forms (which I expect it will). Until then, my vote stays on you for coming off the most scummy in my mind

[Sir Tornado]

boost Sajin OGML Porochaz

vote Mastin

I guess I screwed up my read on Mufasa.

[Mastin]

Will be V/LA 'til Monday. (Dang it, the only thing worse than being V/LA once a game goes into night is being V/LA when a game comes out of it.)

[millar13]

Will be V/LA 'til Monday. (Dang it, the only thing worse than being V/LA once a game goes into night is being V/LA when a game comes out of it.)

You really are the worst active scum lurker ever

[Porochaz]

Can we hold the votes a little whilst we sort out a few things.

1.Boost
2.Hear properly from BM
3.Hear from people who were quiet yesterday including semioldguy and empking

We had a few lurkers yesterday and BM who resplaced in as the day was ending and I want to here there opinions of day 1 before we lynch.

[Kise]

Boost: Battle Mage
Boost: Sajin

I'll use my 3rd boost for whoever is the next best wagon.

I'm not too sure on Mastin's lynch. It appears that everyone and their mama were on both wagons yesterday, so I have to question whether scum would have bussed him before transitioning over to Mufasa's wagon. Maybe I read it wrong, but I could have sworn that damn-near everyone voted for Mastin at some point. I'll do a re-read tonight.

[Porochaz]

Out of interest why is Battle Mage getting all these boosts. Im not closed to giving him a boost but surely we should have him post something having read the game fully before we do so?

[Kise]

I was told (on Day 1) that we should boost no matter what, and no matter who. I think a better idea would be for us to take turns boosting everyone, like, a game of hot potato.

Does anyone (from BM1) know the direct effects of boosting a player 2 days in a row?

[Porochaz]

Well from the role PM's in boost 1 http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... start=1550 it shows if you boost them more than once the role they have gets more powerful. Also I disagree, I think its much more advantageous to go for who the town thinks is most deserving. (Hence the voting procedure.) I don't think that BM has done anything particularly deserving of a boost thus far due to him replacing in, he hasnt posted much, his replacee is BloodCovanent who I didnt have much impact on the game either.

[OhGodMyLife]

Boost: Sir T

[millar13]

Boost:populartajo

[Sajin]

Too many people voting, too many people not boosting 3 people. I would rather be boosting 3 others as to what we boosted yesterday to spread out boost targets for scum to hit.

unvote: Mastin

fos OGML

- There is zero reason to only be boosting a claimed vanilla. Your either not paying attention or trying to boost a partner or trying to get a lynch to happen without boosts resolving. Any of those possibilities is scummy to me.

Vote count when you get a chance.

[Patrick]

Votecount

cateraction (1) -- millar13
Mastin (3) -- Kmd4390, OhGodMyLife, Sir Tornado
millar13 (1) -- cateraction

Not voting: populartajo, Mastin, Empking, Wiirdo, MissTake, zwetschenwasser, Battle Mage, semioldguy, Porochaz, Kise, Sajin.
16 alive, 9 to lynch.

Boosting

Kise (1) -- Sajin
Battle Mage (4) -- Sajin, Kmd4390, cateraction, Kise
Porochaz (2) -- Sajin, Sir Tornado
Sajin (4) -- Kmd4390, cateraction, Sir Tornado, Kise
MissTake (1) -- Kmd4390
Kmd4390 (1) -- cateraction
Sir Tornado (1) -- OhGodMyLife
populartajo (1) -- millar13

[semioldguy]

As posted in my other games yesterday, I unexpectedly lost my internet last week. I am back and catching up.

[OhGodMyLife]

Sir T claimed vanilla?

[semioldguy]

Through to page 21 at the moment, and will be posting every few pages as I go.

I don't like ConsonantM coming only to say that he won't be posting in this game. Saying that he has been working on a post, but then going back and saying that he didn't work on it at all despite being online to do so. As in all my past two games with Mastin, I don't like his style of quoting in his posts, and I think his posting is anti-town as it is hard to follow and seems to commonly misrepresent.

I dislike Kise's playing dumb in general and not picking up on the need to boost two more people on Day One.

Sajin seems to have a level head about things thus far and doesn't seem scummy to me. Likely town in my opinion that if boosted would use any potential abilities well.

Boost: Sajin

[Mufasa]

bahhhh Goo town

[semioldguy]

Through page 24 now,

I agree with Sajin about spreading out the boosts so we don’t either superpower a scum player or paint a huge target on a potentially powerful town player. Plus the more boosts are spread out the more difficult it will be for scum to pick off all the town who have received boosts.

Strongly dislike Kise’s softclaim on page 22, and his full claim reeks in my opinion. It’s testable, but not in a way that the town would want to test. As pointed out by several, his claim is not very useful for his role by the way that he went about it. I also dislike his speculation about his own role and possible boost powers he might get. I don’t like Sir Tornado’s vanilla claim on the same page, as reasons for such were pointed out.

[Kmd4390]

Can we hold the votes a little whilst we sort out a few things.

1.Boost
2.Hear properly from BM
3.Hear from people who were quiet yesterday including semioldguy and empking

We had a few lurkers yesterday and BM who resplaced in as the day was ending and I want to here there opinions of day 1 before we lynch.

I agree about holding off on lynching. I disagree about holding off on voting.

I was told (on Day 1) that we should boost no matter what, and

no matter who

. I think a better idea would be for us to take turns boosting everyone, like, a game of hot potato.

Disagree with the bolded. Boost people you think are town.

[semioldguy]

Page 27, next post will be back to current page.

Obviously I would like to hear from BM

after

he receives his role rather than before.

Requested by Papa Zito when I wasn’t able to catch up earlier; my top scum candidates as of that post request are Mufasa (who was lynched), Kise and to a lesser extent Wiirdo.

I forgot Zwetschenwasser was in this game as I was reading. I find it odd how his posting isn’t as frequent as I have seen of him in other games. I don’t like how millar13 criticizes others and lumps himself into that same group. He looks bad since the final boost hadn’t been resolved yet when he was asking people to choose sides, when it had already been discussed multiple times why boosting needs to come first.

@ Sir Tornado and Miss Take:
Why do you find Kise to be likely town? I find him suspicious for his playing dumb when I know he is a better player and his poor handling of his role/claim.

[semioldguy]

Cateraction’s explanation makes no sense as he says he is not voting for Mufasa because it has been decided that the boosts should be resolved first, which is a good reason, but his vote is on another player. If that was your reason for not voting Mufasa, then why hadn’t you already unvoted to reflect not voting until all boosts resolved?

millar13 seems very jumpy as the day comes to a close. Willing to help in letting the hammer fall on the player he doesn’t find suspicious and believing that it doesn’t implicate him at all is total crap. The actual hammer from millar13’s point of view was dumb as well, especially in light of his willingness through to today to jump onto a Mastin wagon when it forms. There was a Mastin wagon yesterday, what was wrong with that one if you were so sure that Mufasa was town?

Vote: millar13

_ _ _ _ _

I’d like to see more from Battle Mage. I liked his first post, but he hadn’t received his role at that point yet and I’d like to see him expand upon what he began in his first post a little more.

[semioldguy]

Sir T claimed vanilla?

Yes, page 22.

[OhGodMyLife]

Unboost: Sir T

Boost: semioldguy, Kmd, MissTake

Lets sort out these boosts and lynch Mastin.