The Manor: Chzo Mafia (Game Over!)

[dramonic]

I should have bolded the names, that post is hard to read -_-

[Lamont_Cranston]

I can agree with maybe 50% of your analysis but I have a totally different scummy list than you do. We would only agree on Rock & Sironi...

[Lamont_Cranston]

@Devastation:

What is your read on Dramonic?

[dramonic]

Not a problem, if we have different view on people it helps avoid blind bandwagonning.

[dramonic]

yes, I know that was stating the obvious.

Care to explain why you disagree bout Pyro Xtoxm and Set, or is there a post where it's explained thatI conveniently missed? :3

[Lamont_Cranston]

Pyro has been so town of late it hurts. Xtoxm I have had a town read since D1. Set is cutting a very strong town profile. I wouldn't support wagons on any of them.

[Lamont_Cranston]

yes, I know that was stating the obvious.

Care to explain why you disagree bout Pyro Xtoxm and Set, or is there a post where it's explained thatI conveniently missed? :3

I can answer specific inquiries about any one of them.

[dramonic]

I have none in particular, although I consider Pyro's change in playstyle after pushing Naomi so much to be quite radical. It's very strange at best.

Although, it is a positive change, so I wouldn't lynch him for upgrading his play.

This leaves Rock, Sironi and Zazie if I'm not mistaken?

Conveniently, only one of them is on my higher scum list

Vote: Rockatansky

I'm not about to refrain from voting just to avoid people going agaisnt me yelling "OMGUS VOTE!", as I know it isn't one.

[Lamont_Cranston]

Well I have my reasons why Rock is on my scummy list, what are yours?

[Pyromaniac]

You shouldn't not vote for someone whom you think is scum because they are voting for you. And my play style hasn't changed. We have just received new information.

[Stephoscope]

Dev came about as close to quoting the Town role pm as he could without getting modkilled. Unless scum were given copies of it (and why the mod would do that rather than just quote the town role pm in the rules is beyond me) then he is town.

While I certainly wasn't a fan of everyone starting to claim vanilla...is there anyone else who has *already* claimed vanilla who can confirm this?

Devestation's statement was believeable, but fairly generic.

[ZazieR]

@Stepho

For the love of God...

I am Janine. I am an investigative reporter, and am Innocent.

I can check one player each night, and learn his or her role and alignment.

I investigated Naomi last night. Her roleclaim was legitimate. She is Trilby.

Please protect me tonight.

So what is Naomi's role? And why didn't you claim it in this post?
Because I'd expect that your role would be 'investigative reporter' if your claim is true. So please explain.

Hi Stepho

[Stephoscope]

@Stepho

For the love of God...

I am Janine. I am an investigative reporter, and am Innocent.

I can check one player each night, and learn his or her role and alignment.

I investigated Naomi last night. Her roleclaim was legitimate. She is Trilby.

Please protect me tonight.

So what is Naomi's role? And why didn't you claim it in this post?
Because I'd expect that your role would be 'investigative reporter' if your claim is true. So please explain.

Hi Stepho

Hi! I already answered that.

Also, Elmo is a confirmed Innocent, right? Elmo, what's your opinion on Devestation's roleclaim?

[ZazieR]

Dev came about as close to quoting the Town role pm as he could without getting modkilled. Unless scum were given copies of it (and why the mod would do that rather than just quote the town role pm in the rules is beyond me) then he is town.

While I certainly wasn't a fan of everyone starting to claim vanilla...is there anyone else who has *already* claimed vanilla who can confirm this?

Devestation's statement was believeable, but fairly generic.

Two players have already pointed out that it matches.
Either three scum outed themselves, scum know the Innocent PM or it matches.
The first is already not true. Which leaves 2 and 3. I''m leaning towards the third.

[ZazieR]

@Stepho

For the love of God...

I am Janine. I am an investigative reporter, and am Innocent.

I can check one player each night, and learn his or her role and alignment.

I investigated Naomi last night. Her roleclaim was legitimate. She is Trilby.

Please protect me tonight.

So what is Naomi's role? And why didn't you claim it in this post?
Because I'd expect that your role would be 'investigative reporter' if your claim is true. So please explain.

Hi Stepho

Hi! I already answered that.

So you''re saying that the results you''ve gotten was that she''s Trilby and Innocent? So in other words, you''re saying that Trilby is her role?

[Stephoscope]

2283 and 2284, dear.

[ZazieR]

Don''t call me dear *glare*
You''ll regret it if you do it one more time.

So in other words, you''re saying that Trilby is her role?

Just answer with yes or no as punishment for calling me dear *glare*

[ZazieR]

Also, you didn''t answer why you didn''t claim back then that extra part.

[Stephoscope]

Don''t call me dear *glare*
You''ll regret it if you do it one more time.

So in other words, you''re saying that Trilby is her role?

Just answer with yes or no as punishment for calling me dear *glare*

I am not going to do that because my PM does not say "The name is THIS and the role is THAT and the alignment is THAT". I have already mentioned, carefully and in different places, all the relevant information in my PM...and if the mod was at all consistent, Naomi will be able to verify it.

[Stephoscope]

Also, you didn''t answer why you didn''t claim back then that extra part.

I didn't see a need to do so (rightly or wrongly, I was thinking of "Trilby" as her role), and certainly didn't want to risk a modkill. But it shouldn't matter, since Naomi hasn't even been back, has she? So it's not like I'm reading her and making stuff up, or something. She should be able to verify my investigation.

[ZazieR]

She has posted after you''ve claimed, yet didn''t address it.

[ZazieR]

Mod, does this game only show allignment when somebody flips?

[ZazieR]

Naomi

, please respond to Stepho''s claim.

Elmo

, if possible, could you a full role PM claim? You''re one of the two reasons as of now why I''m not voting him.

[dramonic]

Let's do a post analysis of Rock

1. Attacks Lamont with his reasons for voting being ridiculous.

2. Speculation about how the shotgun shell is apparently not a vig item. Of course it's to be used as a supository

3. Accuses Xtoxm of flooding the thread with item speculation without actually bringing an intelligent explanation to the shell (mind you, it's a pretty obvious item)

4. Plays victim

5. vigvote dev without ANY explanation

6.

Also, someone just have me prodded once all this vig nonsense is over with.

Nice way of not participating. He's not even V/LA, he's just running away. Useful way to avoid suspicion, when you don't say anything.

7. Use of fail logic to push more of his illusions on the town about lynching Lamont

8. Fails to understand basic logic when faced with it

9. Twists people's intentions to fit his needs.


Yeah, he's scummy alright.

[Devestation]

Setael

Protecting

?

I think I must have gotten the wrong Impression over to you