The Replacement - 1 (DraketheFake)
tubby216 - 3 (Light-kun, Netlava, TheReplacement)
Netlava - 2 (HowardRoark, tubby216)
Not Voting - 1 (JereIC)
7 alive, 4 to lynch
-Mod
(Vote Count accurate as of Post 887)
By everyone seeming scummy, I didn't mean everyone. Mostly the players that were alive.How did those two appear town while everyone felt scummy?
I didn't want to discount the possibility of LK being scum quite yet.Seeing him as a SK, he can wait; but as scum, why? The rest of post 7 is the case against JereIC. I will highlight this piece
I thought it may have been faked before checking who I replaced and realizing that there is no point in faking outbursts.So you thought his outburst were faked? To what end?
That's my read on him.HR wrote:Why?I do think that DtF is the most likely to be town from the players remaining
I would really like you to address this.I wrote:Setting up an out for a mislynch? Trying to avoid intentionally bussing? Actively lurking? Having others play the game for you?post 42 made Fri May 29, 2009 4:48 pm wrote:I'm not comfortable with multiple wagons during Lylo. It makes it easier for scum to quicklynch at any given moment. We should really decide on who to lynch before voting.
At the moment Tubby and Net are voting for each other, so it's unlikely they're both mafia. If scum are really one mislynch away from victory in the Antarctic, it's more likely they'd be pushing for the mislynch rather than bussing each other.Light-kun wrote: To clarify: I still heavily suspect Jazzmyn and Netlava as scum. Howard is my other guess.
Since it won't matter tonight, I WILL be shooting one of my suspects tonight. Also, Tubby isn't number 1 on my scum list:
Percentages:
Netlava: 45%
Tubby: 39%
Jazzmyn: 35%
Howard: 34%
Sorry Howard, but scum look good (from my perspective), so I doubt a mafiaoso would replace out right now, so Jazz is almost as likely to be scum as you. Netlava I feel has been active lurking most the game where as Tubby contributed. His claim, however, looks like complete bullshit, and I know that I shouldn't buy into flavor this much (I don't...) I just don't see two different roles being the same species. I'm going with hence my vote.
ok this is what we should be looking at, i am not even the top of his list for scum but he wants to vote for me anyway?? and i cleared him??JereIC wrote:At the moment Tubby and Net are voting for each other, so it's unlikely they're both mafia.Light-kun wrote: To clarify: I still heavily suspect Jazzmyn and Netlava as scum. Howard is my other guess.
Since it won't matter tonight, I WILL be shooting one of my suspects tonight. Also, Tubby isn't number 1 on my scum list:
Percentages:
Netlava: 45%
Tubby: 39%
Jazzmyn: 35%
Howard: 34%
Sorry Howard, but scum look good (from my perspective), so I doubt a mafiaoso would replace out right now, so Jazz is almost as likely to be scum as you. Netlava I feel has been active lurking most the game where as Tubby contributed. His claim, however, looks like complete bullshit, and I know that I shouldn't buy into flavor this much (I don't...) I just don't see two different roles being the same species. I'm going with hence my vote.If scum are really one mislynch away from victory in the Antarctic, it's more likely they'd be pushing for the mislynch rather than bussing each other.
Which makes Howard's earlier hawk-vote for Tubby a conundrum.
Actually, if I were mafia (since that is the one thing I'm obviously not), mafia voting each other wouldn't be a bad move because it: Distances AND to win, you just change your vote to another person via bandwagon, other person changes their vote and this is all done in one post (unvote/vote), so there really isn't a disadvantage. It's possible the mafia discussed that town would definitely suspect 1 or 2/3 of them and they want us to be confused on the last 2/3 people. I think that this is all a bit of speculation though.JereIC wrote:At the moment Tubby and Net are voting for each other, so it's unlikely they're both mafia. If scum are really one mislynch away from victory in the Antarctic, it's more likely they'd be pushing for the mislynch rather than bussing each other.Light-kun wrote: To clarify: I still heavily suspect Jazzmyn and Netlava as scum. Howard is my other guess.
Since it won't matter tonight, I WILL be shooting one of my suspects tonight. Also, Tubby isn't number 1 on my scum list:
Percentages:
Netlava: 45%
Tubby: 39%
Jazzmyn: 35%
Howard: 34%
Sorry Howard, but scum look good (from my perspective), so I doubt a mafiaoso would replace out right now, so Jazz is almost as likely to be scum as you. Netlava I feel has been active lurking most the game where as Tubby contributed. His claim, however, looks like complete bullshit, and I know that I shouldn't buy into flavor this much (I don't...) I just don't see two different roles being the same species. I'm going with hence my vote.
Which makes Howard's earlier hawk-vote for Tubby a conundrum. :?
Actually, it might also be that he set the vote as a trap, figuring that if a townie stopped by and voted tubby he could unvote and claim the townie was trying to pull a speedlynch.Light-kun wrote:Actually, if I were mafia (since that is the one thing I'm obviously not), mafia voting each other wouldn't be a bad move because it: Distances AND to win, you just change your vote to another person via bandwagon, other person changes their vote and this is all done in one post (unvote/vote), so there really isn't a disadvantage. It's possible the mafia discussed that town would definitely suspect 1 or 2/3 of them and they want us to be confused on the last 2/3 people. I think that this is all a bit of speculation though.
Having him not kill last night also helped to narrow the scum pool.JereIC wrote:Unfortunately, having him not kill last night screwed up the math, and we've got basically no advantage to having him kill tonight.
I disagree with this, as if he shot yesterday, and he shot a townie, there might not have even been a today. Having him not kill last night ensured that we'd still be playing today.JereIC wrote:Unfortunately, having him not kill last night screwed up the math, and we've got basically no advantage to having him kill tonight.
Good point! How did you manage to not get quicklynched with 2 "confirmed" pro-town players on your wagon? (Admittedly, JereIC jumped off your wagon).tubby216 wrote:here is what i do not understand, i cleared LK and i cleared JereIC thats two confirmed pro- town players, and yet these are the guys that want me lynched.