Scummies 2009 Nominations

[Kison]

• Player Awards
  
  
  
• Best Performance by an Individual (Pro-Town)
  - "Oscar" Award
  • roflcopter in Legends of Literature Mafia - nominated by Caboose
    
  • Caboose in Legends of Literature Mafia - nominated by roflcopter, seconded by Tenchi, thirded by PokerFace
    
  • Porkens in Mini 756 - nominated by Knight of Cydonia, seconded by Juls, thirded by Trumpet of Doom
    
  • OhGodMyLife in Silent Mafia 3 - nominated by Incognito, seconded by charter, thirded by Slicey, etc.
    
  • camn in Open 122 - nominated by VP Baltar, seconded by Kmd4390
• Best Performance by an Individual (Scum)
  - "Oscar" Award
  • LlamaFluff in Mafia 86 - nominated by Claus, seconded by Mr. Flay, thirded by Kison, etc.
    
  • Xylthixlm in Mind Screw Mafia 3 - nominated by Tarhalindur, seconded by MafiaSSK, thirded by Seraphim, etc
    
  • Wall-E in Open 100 - nominated by ThAdmiral
    
  • don_johnson in mini 737 - nominated by Rhinox, seconded by Spolium
• Best Performance by a Team
  - "Goodfellas" Award
  • The Town of Crackers! Mafia - nominated by Korts
    
  • The Mafia of Mind Screw Mafia 3 - nominated by Tarhalindur, seconded by MafiaSSK, thirded by Stef
    
  • The Fallen Angels of War In Heaven II - nominated by shaft.ed
    
  • The Town of Open 118 - nominated by Slicey
• Best Serial Killer
  - "Hannibal Lector" Award
• Best Mafia Catcher
  - "Paragon of Mafia Hunters" Award
  • Spolium in Newbie 705 - nominated by Santos
• Most Cunning Manipulation
  - "The Don Corleone" Award
  • Xylthixlm in Mind Screw Mafia 3 - nominated by Tarhalindur, seconded by MafiaSSK, thirded by Seraphim, etc
• Best Performance in a Losing Cause
  - "Cassandra" Award
  • Mirth in Mini 699 - nominated by farside22
    
  • q21 in War in Heaven II - nominated by Mr. Flay, seconded by DrippingGoofball
• Most Outstanding New Player
  
  
  should have joined the site no later than ~Oct. 2008
  • VP Baltar in Newbie 696 - nominated by Kmd4390, seconded by Incognito
    
  • Gwynplaine in Newbie 707 - nominated by julienvonwolfe, seconded by Tenchi
    
  • Papa Zito in Newbie 762 - nominated by Mastin, seconded by sirdanilot, thirded by OhGodMyLife, etc.
• Most Improved Player
  • populartajo - nominated by populartajo
    
  • Spyrex - nominated by OhGodMyLife, seconded by VP Baltar
• Best Replacement
  • ZONEACE in Family Guy Mafia - nominated by farside22, seconded by populartajo, thirded by LlamaFluff, etc.
• Best IC
• Best Role Claim
  - "Johnny Cochrane" Award
  • Llamafluff in Mafia 86 - nominated by The Fonz, seconded by Jahudo, thirded by BlakAdder, etc.
    
  • mykonian in Mini 707 - nominated by q21, seconded by animorpherv1
    
  • q21 in War in Heaven II - nominated by Simenon, seconded by Adel, thirded by Giuseppe, etc
• Funniest Role Claim
  - "George W Bush" Award
  • Xylthixlm in Medieval Mafia - nominated by Xylthixlm, seconded by Kairyuu
    
  • imaginality in Mini 733, nominated by Mirth, seconded by destructor
  Moderator Awards
  
  
  
• Most Enjoyable Game
  (Large [free market/normal])
  • Adel for Crackers! Mafia - nominated by Raging Rabbit, seconded by Korts, thirded by destructor
    
  • Tarhalindur for Mind Screw Mafia 3 - nominated by Seraphim, seconded by populartajo
    
  • Mr. Flay for War in Heaven II - nominated by populartajo, seconded by shaft.ed
    
  • OhGodMyLife for Medieval Mafia - nominated by Tarhalindur
    
  • Tarhalindur for Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask Mafia - nominated by Kairyuu
• Most Enjoyable Game
  (Mini [theme/normal])
  • Mirth for Mini 733 - nominated by Kmd4390, seconded by imaginality, thirded by destructor, etc.
    
  • Machiavellian-Mafia for Prisoner's Dilemma - nominated by The Central Scrutinizer
• Most Enjoyable Game
  (Marathon)
  
  New award proposal: nominated by Stef, seconded by Mr. Flay, thirded by Shanba, etc
  • millar13 for VENGEFUL 5 Version 2 - nominated by Drench, seconded by Empking
• Best Flavor Text
  - "Paperback Writer" Award
  • farside22 for Family Guy Mafia - nominated by pacman281292, seconded by Kmd4390
    
  • kloud1516 for Mini738 - nominated by Wizardcat
    
  • Mirth for Mini 733 - nominated by Kmd4390, seconded by imaginality, thirded by destructor, etc.
    
  • BridgesAndBaloons for Mini 714 - nominated by alexhans
• Best Setup
  • Tarhalindur for Mind Screw Mafia 3 - nominated by Seraphim, seconded by populartajo
    
  • Mirth for Mini 733 - nominated by Kmd4390, seconded by imaginality, thirded by destructor, etc.
    
  • Tarhalindur for Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask Mafia - nominated by Kairyuu
• Best Role
  (new or adaptation) - "Flying Pumpkin That Shoots Lazers Out Of Its Ass" Award
  • Tarhalindur for Townie Speaker for the Dead - nominated by Xylthixlm, seconded by populartajo
    
  • OhGodMyLife for Charlemagne, Town Vehmgericht Master in Medieval Mafia - nominated by Tarhalindur, seconded by Slicey
  Site Awards
  
  
  
• Best Contribution to Mafia Discussion
  - "Professor Mafia" Award
  • JDodge, nominated by Mr. Flay
    
  • Lord Gurgi for this, nominated by PokerFace
• Funniest Player
  - "The Coffee on the Monitor" Award
  • Jahudo for this post - nominated by Pokerface, seconded by OhGodMyLife, thirded by shaft.ed
• Behind the Scenes
  - "Name Should Be In Orange" Award
  • Max, nominated by Empking
    
  • MeMe, nominated by Shanba, seconded by stef, thirded by Oman
    
  • Vel-Rahn Koon, nominated by Shanba, seconded by stef, thirded by Oman, etc
    
  • Mr. Flay, nominated by Shanba
    
  • jeep, nominated by Shanba, seconded by animorpherv1

[Juls]

I would like to do two nominations here:

Nomination #1

Best Performance by an Individual (Scum)

- Casey in Communique

Very pro-town behavior. Claimed hider and was generally believed. In endgame had two townies vote for each other without a second glance at her.

Nomination #2

Best Performance by a Team

- Budja and Casey in Communique

Casey had very pro-town behavior. Claimed hider and was generally believed. In endgame had two townies vote for each other without a second glance at her.

Budja and Casey also deciphered a codex being used by town to communicate and therefore was able to figure out hidden information.

[Simenon]

What is the Best Role Claim award for- the finesse of the claim itself, or its impact on the game?

[ortolan]

either I think?

[Stef]

Third VP Baltar for Most Outstanding New Player in Newbie 696
Third millar13 for Most Enjoyable Game (marathon) for VENGEFUL 5 Version 2
Third Tarhalindur for Best Setup for Mind Screw Mafia 3
Third OhGodMyLife for Best New Role: Charlemagne, Town Vehmgericht Master in Medieval Mafia

[Mr. Flay]

What is the Best Role Claim award for- the finesse of the claim itself, or its impact on the game?

I think it's usually done for the finesse of the role claim itself; if it has a huge impact on the game it tends to get rolled into one of the 'bigger' Scummies like Best Individual Performance. YMMV.

[Budja]

Nomination #1

Best Performance by an Individual (Scum)

- Casey in Communique

seconded. She played excellently.

I don't think I can second the other one .

[Mirth]

I don't know if I'm allowed to do this for an IC in a newbie game, but he totally deserved it:

Nominate: Zorblag
Best Performance by an Individual (Scum)
Newbie 749

[Empking]

Second Tar for best set up for LoZ: MMM

[Zorblag]

Mirth, Troll appreciates the thought here, but Troll must decline the nomination. Troll replaced into a game in which Troll knew the town power roles had already been eliminated and in which Troll's partner (Albert B. Rampage) had already set up the perfect bus for Troll to take advantage of and ride to the end of the game. Troll managed not to screw up Troll's part in the scum victory there but the situation favored Troll most heavily right from the start of Troll's play.

-Zorblag R`Lyeh

[Albert B. Rampage]

I don't know if I'm allowed to do this for an IC in a newbie game, but he totally deserved it:

Nominate: Zorblag
Best Performance by an Individual (Scum)
Newbie 749

Second. Easily.

[afatchic]

I would like to nominate Best town or whatever that would fall under ( not sure where to look to find the exact awards) in Mini 773: Welcome to lynchville.

Here is the link: http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... &start=750

Two of the three scum were at L-1 day 1.

Scum lynched Day 1
Scum lynched Day 2
Scum shot night 2, game over.

[Kublai Khan]

I would like to nominate Best town or whatever that would fall under ( not sure where to look to find the exact awards) in Mini 773: Welcome to lynchville.

Here is the link: http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... &start=750

Two of the three scum were at L-1 day 1.

Scum lynched Day 1
Scum lynched Day 2
Scum shot night 2, game over.

Second

. We rocked and I want a scummie.

[alexhans]

I would like to nominate Best town or whatever that would fall under ( not sure where to look to find the exact awards) in Mini 773: Welcome to lynchville.

Here is the link: http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... &start=750

Two of the three scum were at L-1 day 1.

Scum lynched Day 1
Scum lynched Day 2
Scum shot night 2, game over.

Second

. We rocked and I want a scummie.

You couldn't help yourself eh? XD

Anyway... Town ruled that one. Town could've won with only one casualty if the doc had protected the claimed tracker.

[Mr. Flay]

Don't bloody well nominate/second yourself. It's poor form.

[Xylthixlm]

Don't bloody well nominate/second yourself. It's poor form.

I agree.

• Funniest Role Claim
  - "George W Bush" Award
  • Xylthixlm in Medieval Mafia - nominated by Xylthixlm, seconded by Kairyuu

[PokerFace]

I am still against Millar getting an award for Most Enjoyable Game (marathon) for VENGEFUL 5 Version 2. That game required no real work on the mod's part and if anything his mod error as well as interference from people outside the game is what made it fun. You don't deserve an award for errors or people outside the game doing stuff.

@Kison,

Flay and Shanba seconded and thirded the idea for a most enjoyable Marathon Game award. They did not second and third millars game respectably. Also isn't Flay's War in heaven a large theme? Is there separte catagories for best large theme vs best large normal? Should there be separate catagories?

[Kison]

@Kison,

Flay and Shanba seconded and thirded the idea for a most enjoyable Marathon Game award. They did not second and third millars game respectably.

I'm pretty sure the list has them seconding/thirding the award proposal and not the game?

Is there separte catagories for best large theme vs best large normal?

There wasn't last year, which is where the format came from.

[PokerFace]

@Kison,

Flay and Shanba seconded and thirded the idea for a most enjoyable Marathon Game award. They did not second and third millars game respectably.

I'm pretty sure the list has them seconding/thirding the award proposal and not the game?

Yay that's what I was saying. I think I mixed up the 2 lines of which was for the award being made and which was for millar's game getting it. Yep I read that wrong while at work. Totally my bad. I got nothing wrong with the award being made, I just think it should go to somebody that put alot of effort into running their game.

Is there separte catagories for best large theme vs best large normal?

There wasn't last year, which is where the format came from.

Ok, I was just asking the general question if they should be separate. Was wondering if that should be discussed of it it didn't matter.

[populartajo]

Oh I didnt think my proposal would be like accepted. I was only joking with xyl.

I would like to remove my selfnonm for most improved player award.

[Kmd4390]

Best Performance by an Individual (Pro-Town)

- "Oscar" Award
camn in Mini 672 - nominated by VP Baltar, seconded by Kmd4390

Shouldn't this be for Open 122?

If it's for Mini 672,

Unsecond

, but

Nominate Camn for best protown performance in Open 122.

[Kison]

Hmm. You got me there. Thanks!

[MiteyMouse]

I don't know if I'm allowed to do this for an IC in a newbie game, but he totally deserved it:

Nominate: Zorblag
Best Performance by an Individual (Scum)
Newbie 749

Second. Easily.

Third!

[Juls]

I want to nominate Jahudo for

Most Enjoyable Game

(Mini [theme/normal]) for Mini 783 Cowboy Bebop Mafia

[ZONEACE]

Hmm, no one nominated my Family Guy claim while I was gone. Oh well. A best replacement nomination is pretty bitchin. (I don't think i've ever been nominated for a scummy in the almost 6 years I've been a member)