Mini 788 - Fantasy Mafia [OVER]

[ortolan]

Not quite, old chum. I voted you for no great reason, true, but it was your suspicious reaction that got me to keep my vote on you. I fully believe you've overreacted to a total of what? 3 votes? And then you try and twist what I've said to the most negative of its connotations.

Suspicious reaction? Please point me to this. Overreaction? It wasn't a reaction at all, it's me attacking you for failing to move beyond a vote you on one hand claim is "random" but then also pretend it's justified as a non random vote because of my "suspicious reaction" (still waiting for clarification) to being voted in the first place. Which is it- do you suspect me, or not? If you do, please give reasons. If you do not, then make a case against someone- we're 6 pages in and a lot has happened- if you can't find anything suspicious you're not trying hard enough. As it is your equivocation about the status of your vote on me is giving you an excuse for not actively participating in the game (as is your discussion of topics irrelevant to either this or seemingly any other game).

[Shadow Knight]

Going back to re-read later. I'll post something of substance then.

[Mixologist]

I did read it. If I'm looking for something in particular, in this case your reaction, I'm not going to give a reason. To me it seems you are overly defensive off of this one vote. If you instead asked why I was voting you, I probably wouldn't be as suspicious as I am.

[ortolan]

^^ are you talking to me?

my reply wasn't addressed to you

[Mixologist]

It was directed to Starbuck.

However, since I have your attention, what do you think about her bringing up the possibility of someone being lynch immune?

[ortolan]

The only thing that's holding me back on KMD is his vote on Andy, but that still could be a cover. Maybe there's a way that the votes can be redirected and/or deflected, or maybe someone is immune lynch. My reasoning behind thinking this is because I'm currently playing a game on the View Askew forums which is an all power Avengers game and we just finished an all power DC Comics game. I don't know if any of that could come into play in this game, but this is a "Fantasy" mafia game, so anything is possible.

The impression I get is that she is speculating (almost certainly incorrectly) about roles which may or may not be in this game based on her experiences on another site.

[Starbuck]

I try to take all my mafia experience into consideration when I play any game.

The games that I spoke of were "all power" games. There weren't any "you are just town and all you can do is vote". Some people were immune to lynch, some immune to vig, others could block someone's actions. I wouldn't be surprised at all to run into these type of roles here on this site. It was just an idea of what MAY be, especially because this is a FANTASY themed mafia game.

It just may be worth the thought is all.

[Kmd4390]

Star, taking shots at "everyone" is me thinking I have the 3 scum found and going after those three players. How am I being insulting or defensive?

Goat, you (or anyone else here) probably won't face my real wrath. I've been warned by a List Mod recently, but the game is ongoing. XD

Star, I'd say we should probably stop discussing roles that could be in the game. There is no reason to speculate on anyone's roles just yet.

[Starbuck]

I think it's a perfect time to speculate of roles. What if we end up voting out someone who is a potential help for the village?

[Kmd4390]

Are you honestly suggesting that power roles should claim?

Unvote, Vote Starbuck

[Starbuck]

I never said anything about claiming and I would appreciate it if you didn't put words in my mouth.

I just said we should take into consideration what could possibly be out there.

[Kmd4390]

I think all we need to know is that it's possible that some power roles might or might not be in the game. That is all. We shouldn't speculate on what specifically we have. Town has no info to gain (no Night 0), but scum can decide which role is most valuable for us and base their NK on what we discuss, eliminating our most powerful role before it ever gets used.

[Starbuck]

You have a point. All I was doing was discussing. But seeing how quickly you jumped, you just got a bit more of my suspicions.

[Kmd4390]

I'm suspicious for not wanting to expose power roles? Interesting logic there.

[Starbuck]

When did I say I wanted to expose them? I just wanted to discuss the possibilities of what might be out there. You keep putting words in my mouth and I do not like your bullying towards myself or others as you have been doing.

[Shadow Knight]

Eh, KMD is always arrogant. Problem is sometimes he's right, so I can't fault him for it.

[Kmd4390]

When did I say I wanted to expose them? I just wanted to discuss the possibilities of what might be out there. You keep putting words in my mouth and I do not like your bullying towards myself or others as you have been doing.

If you want to find role possibilities, see the wiki or Llama's past modded games. If we discuss it, it helps scum pick up hints on who may have what role.

[Sudo_Nym]

Not quite, old chum. I voted you for no great reason, true, but it was your suspicious reaction that got me to keep my vote on you. I fully believe you've overreacted to a total of what? 3 votes? And then you try and twist what I've said to the most negative of its connotations.

Suspicious reaction? Please point me to this. Overreaction? It wasn't a reaction at all, it's me attacking you for failing to move beyond a vote you on one hand claim is "random" but then also pretend it's justified as a non random vote because of my "suspicious reaction" (still waiting for clarification) to being voted in the first place. Which is it- do you suspect me, or not? If you do, please give reasons. If you do not, then make a case against someone- we're 6 pages in and a lot has happened- if you can't find anything suspicious you're not trying hard enough. As it is your equivocation about the status of your vote on me is giving you an excuse for not actively participating in the game (as is your discussion of topics irrelevant to either this or seemingly any other game).

Is it so hard? Or are you making it hard? I personally believe you've overreacted to a few votes far beyond what a legitimately innocent person would. Sure, my initial vote was random. But it has ceased to be such, and yet you keep harping on that that is somehow significant. I can unvote and revote you, if that'll help you. Plus, you've now gone to great lengths to misinterpret my posts to make me look bad on more than one occassion.

[Kmd4390]

When did I say I wanted to expose them? I just wanted to discuss the possibilities of what might be out there. You keep putting words in my mouth and I do not like your bullying towards myself or others as you have been doing.

If you want to find role possibilities, see the wiki or

Llama's

Sens'

past modded games. If we discuss it, it helps scum pick up hints on who may have what role.

Fixed.

[Andycyca]

Andycya why did you unvote in 139?

Because even if he is suspicious of me , I don't find him scummy right now

[orangepenguin]

Alright, I am getting caught up. I think it would be beneficial, probably day 2 or 3 (some time later on) if we did a mass flavor claim. Anyone agree? Disagree?

I will post sometime later on though.

[TonyMontana]

Alright, I am getting caught up. I think it would be beneficial, probably day 2 or 3 (some time later on) if we did a mass flavor claim. Anyone agree? Disagree?

I agree, and think day 3 would be a good time.

[Empking]

Alright, I am getting caught up. I think it would be beneficial, probably day 2 or 3 (some time later on) if we did a mass flavor claim. Anyone agree? Disagree?

I will post sometime later on though.

I disagree.

[ortolan]

Why?

I have little problem with the idea in principle, I don't see any punisher roles being based on flavour

[Empking]

Why?

I have little problem with the idea in principle, I don't see any punisher roles being based on flavour

I don't think we should make descisions now when we can make them later.