Devestation wrote:A battle of items would require a higher rate of itemscompared to what we get now,and this might happen.
If I was hohum, I'd drink it myself or let the town decided. Depending on what everyone wanted.Alabaska J wrote:this is noncommittal in almost every way, in addition to the fact you have just parroted a lot of other people's statements. Naomi, if you were hohum, what would you do with the elixir?Naomi_Saotome wrote:Well I don't see why someone's putting words in my mouth...I'm not looking to wash my hands of any misdeeds. I was stating how it's up to hohum to use it or not, seeing as hohum is gone right now no one knows what he intends to do at this point. But the last thing he said was that he wasn't willing to use it.
I'm not saying we shouldn't use it, I don't agree with him there. But there's a lot of other people saying that we should just let it go unused. I'm not sure that ignoring something like this is a good idea, even if we don't know what it might do. It'd be like advocating no lynch D1. We've got to take risks at some point. But the question is what risks do we take?
The way I see it we can pressure him to use it, and tell him what to do with it, but he doesn't have to do it. Not doing what we say to will probably lead to many votes for his lynching. Which is all I was really saying. The majority wants to use it and I would have to agree.
I just don't know about a random dice roll as the decision.
Well, it took me awhile but it looks like we finally agree.Stephoscope wrote:Well, be fair--I advocate that we all vote on whom to force it to. And I'm sure there are more townies than scum that'd be voting...
I see the elixer as a 50/50 hit bad or good. We can't outguess the mod so we don't know what the elixer will do. You can debate as much as you want about it but we will not know how basterdly the mod invented this item.Lamont_Cranston wrote:Ya I know, its almost an act of genius that he left when he did.
@Nyx:What do you think about the relatively high odds that random forcing the elixir will hit a town power role?
Sure, why not. I vote for Lamont. To restate: I believe using it on a player like him is a good idea because it will hopefully make it obvious whether or not he's town aligned, letting us use his enthusiasm for good or letting us get rid of him if he's scum, and make overall scumhunting easier as well.NuevaVida wrote:Ok lets start the voting for the decanter
Hmmm, well I don't want the elixir to go to lurkers, so they're out...Stephoscope wrote:Sure, why not. I vote for Lamont. To restate: I believe using it on a player like him is a good idea because it will hopefully make it obvious whether or not he's town aligned, letting us use his enthusiasm for good or letting us get rid of him if he's scum, and make overall scumhunting easier as well.NuevaVida wrote:Ok lets start the voting for the decanter
I do not expect the drink to kill him outright or any such thing--frankly, I'm banking that it won't.
Naomi wrote:I say let him make the decision because then he alone is responsible for the outcome. If we sit around bickering about whether or not to use it, we're all still just pointing a finger at each other.
So... are you saying youNaomi wrote:If I was hohum, I'd drink it myself or let the town decided. Depending on what everyone wanted.