The Manor: Chzo Mafia (Game Over!)

[Sajin]

I'll happily drink it.

As tempting as it would be to get you the hell out of this game, I think I'll hang on to it for now.

BTW it must be used today or not at all.

[Sironigous]

Decanter. Interesting.

lol modding.

[Stephoscope]

hohum, understanding that no one here knows what effect the mysterious liquid is going to have, would you be willing to conduct a vote and then force the drink onto whomever's voted for?

[hohum]

I'm willing to accept input from others. Sure. I don't think it has to be anything as formal as a vote. An informal staw poll would do.

I swiped it though, so I guess it's up to me.

If you had the opportunity to pick a recpient now, who would it be and why?

[hohum]

Devistation: It's reasonable to expect other people to be vocal about my actions.

I wasn't sniping at him for doing so. If you were reading you would have realized that I mistakenly called him out because I didn't see Lamont's answer right away.

Happy now?

[Stephoscope]

If you had the opportunity to pick a recpient now, who would it be and why?

I say give it to Lamont. He's been posting a lot and seems to want to control the game, so it'll be good to throw a wrench into things to try and determine if he's town or if he has scumbuddies.

[Sajin]

Well the question is do we think its harmful or beneficial. If we think its beneficial we should give it to someone very pro town looking. If we think its harmful, we give it to someone not looking great.

@hohum reguardless if it is or not before you use it I want to know whether YOU think its a good thing or a bad thing. Answer before you use please.

[Stephoscope]

Well the question is do we think its harmful or beneficial. If we think its beneficial we should give it to someone very pro town looking. If we think its harmful, we give it to someone not looking great.

For the record, I personally am not even going to guess if the drink is good or bad. Who knows? I am more interested in the overall goal of lynching intelligently.

[hohum]

I agree with steph. All premutations as to the potential effects lead to WIFOM.

[Sajin]

Many things are WIFOM, your point? Its still beneficial information. I would still like to know your intent before you give/force it on someone. I am not going to vote you for being wrong about the effects. I will vote you for not declaring your intent on an action.

[Amished]

I guess I'm of the opinion that if xtoxm wants to take the risk, he might as well drink it. Either he's like a townie with a less powerful role and doesn't feel that important, has a role that helps prevent bad things from happening (nk's, dayvigs, whatever) or a gambling scum. Either way with something you don't know the effect of it might be worth it to try on a volunteer.

[UnofficialRulerOfEveryone]

I am sort of here... Problems with the last two days and the weekend (I completely forgot about you guys Monday ), I am reading and should post after school tomorrow, so expect SOMETHING in the next ~20 hours.

[Pyromaniac]

LOL! I just spent a while waiting for someone to respond to my post at the bottom of page seven, not realizing that I was at the bottom.

FoS Shadow Knight

[hohum]

Many things are WIFOM, your point? Its still beneficial information. I would still like to know your intent before you give/force it on someone. I am not going to vote you for being wrong about the effects. I will vote you for not declaring your intent on an action.

You're approaching this as if you're not going to have a say or like I've already made a decision. I've already said that I'm going to take input from the group before I make a decision.

[Sajin]

I have made a decision to vote you if you do not declare whether you think it has positive or negative effects, yes.

My only input is that you do not test it on yourself, anyone else but you. Town needs information about each other and if whatever it does helps confirm someone later so much the better.

[hohum]

Seriously?

Vote me then. Because I don't KNOW whether it's a positive or negative effect. The item PM doesn't fucking say.

[Sajin]

I want you to declare intent.... What part of that is unclear?

I understand you don't know. I want to know what you think it does.

[Amished]

Sajin, you're basically asking him to outguess the mod for something that's a 50/50 chance anyways. The only way I see this going is you trying to crucify hohum for it later on no matter what which is definitely anti-town. What are you really trying to accomplish here?

[hohum]

Why? What good will my speculating do?

[Amished]

EBWOP: In fact, the more I think about it:

Unvote
Vote Sajin

[hohum]

I'm down with that.

Unvote, Vote Sajin

At least until he can sufficiently explain how speculation is effective scum hunting.

[Naomi_Saotome]

well, I missed some interesting stuff....
I agree, I'd like to why he's so persistent about what you think the liquid does/will do

[Kratos]

Considering we're only 50% sure of it's effects, why not give it to someone who we're not sure if they're mafia or not?

Although, not to bring in the wine glass, but most would assume that the drink is detrimental, so I think the mod may make it beneficial for that reason.

[Amished]

We're not even 50% sure. It could give you info but make you go silent for the rest of the day. Or just make you go silent. We have no idea what it does, nor will we find out beforehand. Trying to outguess the mod will not benefit us in scumhunting. In any way.

[Amished]

EBWOP: Besides, how do you propose we find out if anybody is mafia or not with any certainty. ......../facepalm