Lynch All Lurkers Mafia! GAME OVER

[Ether]

3 image (roflcopter, Xylthixlm, Stephoscope)

8 Unvote (Nuwen, elvis_knits, Empking, image, Kinetic, MafiaSSK, ortolan, populartajo)

11 alive; 6 to lynch.

[ortolan]

hai guyz

[MafiaSSK]

Hey MafiaSSK, tell me exactly why you accused me of something a while back?

'Cause I do

[ortolan]

did*

[elvis_knits]

Suggestion: Mastin needs to die today. Yes. But let's lynch him second. Then we see more interaction from him, and learn more when he flips one way or the other.

This was awesome.

vote image

But I also would like to point out that tajo and Xyl acted quite odd with Mastin.

[elvis_knits]

Suspicious post numero uno:

L-3 with very high tendence of L-1.

Mastin, claim or die.

Also, if youd like to survive a little more, share a scumlist with us.

The suggestion that we might let Mastin survive for any amount of time is highly suspicious.

[elvis_knits]

Next suspicious post:

Arg, doc claim.

Why would Antihero targetted me night one?

Oh no, a doc claim!

[elvis_knits]

Trying to help mastin:

I would need a remarkably high confidence in your townieness for that to be a better plan than lynching you right now.

I'm giving you a chance to prove at least part of your story is true here, and you're flubbing it.

To be fair, Xyl also said stuff like this:

Not "claim or die". Just "die".

But I don't know how he went from "no claim or die, just die!" to "let's see if I can help you prove you're town."

Decidedly mixed messages.

[elvis_knits]

OMG let's not forget the malyss lynch that went through to avoid AH getting to 72 hours!

Let's not forget how tajo voted malyss almost spur of the moment.

We should look at how that lynch went down again, because that lynch saved AH from getting lynched D1. This may have critical info!

[populartajo]

Suspicious post numero uno:

L-3 with very high tendence of L-1.

Mastin, claim or die.

Also, if youd like to survive a little more, share a scumlist with us.

The suggestion that we might let Mastin survive for any amount of time is highly suspicious.

No. It is trying to a)see if he could bring a valid point as town or b)see if he could give valid information as scum. Rolf and Xyl also did this in other posts.

You're entering the point where everyhting I do is wrong.

[elvis_knits]

8

Malyss

(

Xtoxm

, Xylthixlm,

DrippingGoofball

, image, q21/kinetic, BrianMcQueso/nuwen, Empking, populartajo)
3

antihero

(

Zorblag

, ortolan,

Malyss

)
2

DrippingGoofball

(Stephoscope, roflcopter)

4 Unvote (

antihero

, elvis_knits, MafiaSSK,

wolfcrier

)

17 alive; 9 to lynch.

9

Malyss

(

Xtoxm

, Xylthixlm,

DrippingGoofball

, image, q21/kinetic, BrianMcQueso/nuwen, Empking, populartajo, roflcopter)
3

Antihero

(

Zorblag

, ortolan,

Malyss

)
1

DrippingGoofball

(Stephoscope)

3 Unvote (

antihero

, MafiaSSK,

wolfcrier

)

17 alive; 9 to lynch.

MALYSS HAS BEEN LYNCHED. SHE WAS A VANILLIA TOWNIE.

Note: I was left off the last vote count, but I was in the not voting area.
ALSO: I put q21 down as q21/kinetic, and BMQ as BMQ/nuwen so that we can remember who replaced who... I often have to refer back and that is annoying.

Looking at the Malyss lynch, it seems likely that Ortolan is town. He could have easily helped lynch Malyss, or atleast not gone against the townie lynch to be voting a scum. I find it unlikely that Ortolan is scum based on him voting AH at the time of Malyss lynch.

[populartajo]

Next suspicious post:

Arg, doc claim.

Why would Antihero targetted me night one?

Oh no, a doc claim!

I was wondering why Antihero "protected" me when there were better options at the time.

In fact, the thing that he claimed doctor protecting me, do you think its more likely that scum think Im town and they hate me to the bones or that Im scum with Antihero/Masttin?

[elvis_knits]

Suspicious post numero uno:

L-3 with very high tendence of L-1.

Mastin, claim or die.

Also, if youd like to survive a little more, share a scumlist with us.

The suggestion that we might let Mastin survive for any amount of time is highly suspicious.

No. It is trying to a)see if he could bring a valid point as town or b)see if he could give valid information as scum. Rolf and Xyl also did this in other posts.

You're entering the point where everyhting I do is wrong.

I can see it that way too -- as trying to get info out of a scum before they die.

I had to present it that way to see how you would explain it.

I'm not trying to see evrything you do as scummy, but you have a number suspect things about you.

Also, you were instrumental in the Malyss lynch going down before AH hit 72 hours.

[elvis_knits]

Next suspicious post:

Arg, doc claim.

Why would Antihero targetted me night one?

Oh no, a doc claim!

I was wondering why Antihero "protected" me when there were better options at the time.

In fact, the thing that he claimed doctor protecting me, do you think its more likely that scum think Im town and they hate me to the bones or that Im scum with Antihero/Masttin?

It could go either way. It's complete WIFOM.

[populartajo]

Next suspicious post:

Arg, doc claim.

Why would Antihero targetted me night one?

Oh no, a doc claim!

I was wondering why Antihero "protected" me when there were better options at the time.

In fact, the thing that he claimed doctor protecting me, do you think its more likely that scum think Im town and they hate me to the bones or that Im scum with Antihero/Masttin?

It could go either way. It's complete WIFOM.

Yes, therefore any argument that says that Im scum because of his doc claim is bogus.

[elvis_knits]

Next suspicious post:

Arg, doc claim.

Why would Antihero targetted me night one?

Oh no, a doc claim!

I was wondering why Antihero "protected" me when there were better options at the time.

In fact, the thing that he claimed doctor protecting me, do you think its more likely that scum think Im town and they hate me to the bones or that Im scum with Antihero/Masttin?

It could go either way. It's complete WIFOM.

Yes, therefore any argument that says that Im scum because of his doc claim is bogus.

And nobody is saying you're scum based on his doc claim, so it's a non issue.

[populartajo]

Suspicious post numero uno:

L-3 with very high tendence of L-1.

Mastin, claim or die.

Also, if youd like to survive a little more, share a scumlist with us.

The suggestion that we might let Mastin survive for any amount of time is highly suspicious.

No. It is trying to a)see if he could bring a valid point as town or b)see if he could give valid information as scum. Rolf and Xyl also did this in other posts.

You're entering the point where everyhting I do is wrong.

I can see it that way too -- as trying to get info out of a scum before they die.

I had to present it that way to see how you would explain it.

I'm not trying to see evrything you do as scummy, but you have a number suspect things about you.

Also, you were instrumental in the Malyss lynch going down before AH hit 72 hours.

If Malyss had been protown and Antihero inherently scummy then I could give you this point. AH coming up scum means that I took a bad decision there.

[populartajo]

Next suspicious post:

Arg, doc claim.

Why would Antihero targetted me night one?

Oh no, a doc claim!

I was wondering why Antihero "protected" me when there were better options at the time.

In fact, the thing that he claimed doctor protecting me, do you think its more likely that scum think Im town and they hate me to the bones or that Im scum with Antihero/Masttin?

It could go either way. It's complete WIFOM.

Yes, therefore any argument that says that Im scum because of his doc claim is bogus.

And nobody is saying you're scum based on his doc claim, so it's a non issue.

Rolf.

[populartajo]

Suggestion: Mastin needs to die today. Yes. But let's lynch him second. Then we see more interaction from him, and learn more when he flips one way or the other.

This was awesome.

vote image

Does this make more sense coming from a scum pov?

I could bet that scumpartners would be more pendant of Mastin flip.

[elvis_knits]

tajo, is this what you're referring to?

mastin's doc fakeclaim makes tajo even more likely to be scum.

I think rofl was referring to the fact that mastin claimed doc, not that he claimed you as his target.

But you could be right.

We will have ot ask him.

[elvis_knits]

Suggestion: Mastin needs to die today. Yes. But let's lynch him second. Then we see more interaction from him, and learn more when he flips one way or the other.

This was awesome.

vote image

Does this make more sense coming from a scum pov?

I could bet that scumpartners would be more pendant of Mastin flip.

Do you think image is town?

[elvis_knits]

but it should still be noted that the more vanilla and goon flips we have, the less likely a tracker in this setup becomes

[populartajo]

I cant decide. There are some points that make me want to lynch him but there are some points that make me think he is town or very intelligent scum. Do you think he is scum?

[populartajo]

but it should still be noted that the more vanilla and goon flips we have, the less likely a tracker in this setup becomes

It should also be noted that we have confirmed masons and a confirmed roleblocker in the setup.

[elvis_knits]

I think image is scum, yes.

I think his latest comment about delaying the mastin lynch is scummy. You can put WIFOM in there and say it's too scummy to be scum. But you could have also said that Mastin lurking for 72 hours was a very stupid thing to do, and that scum wouldn't try it. Well, they did try it. Scum did try to lurk and get an extra kill, and then he tried to talk us out of lynching him.

Scum have many reasons to try to delay mastin's lynch. One of them being that if we lynch mastin second, maybe another scum can lurk over the 72 hour mark, and we can only lynch one of them. Then then earn lurker points anyway.

But we can't know for sure that Mastin had ulterior motives, you are right. However, that does not negate the reasons I thought he was scum before. That also does not negate the fact he helped lynched malyss instead of AH.