Ok, I see what you mean, AA. But still, Dust claiming as Mafia has it's pros and cons. Pros being he stays alive for the day and attracts a NK, leaving the real Seer to do his job, which benefits town and mafia. Cons being, he could've potentially outed the real Seer and there would've been one less mafia member (keep in my these are pros and cons from his PoV).
This is all if he's fakeclaiming though. He may be the real seer and this talk could be meaningless. Instead of talking about "if"s for now (which we've done enough of), we should talk about how people have reacted to the claim, which AA has been doing a pretty good job of. Here's my list of people on the wagon.
Ace - For trying to mislead the town into thinking Dust has used an apparent scum meta in multiple games whenever he was scum. This was proven as a lie when Ace said that this only happened once when he was later called on it. Reference to posts 152 to 154
Zwet - Obviously for trying to get a counterclaim. I'm thinking a very likely werewolf.
Emp - Only loosely though, because of post 106 where he asks for a claim and tells people not to CC if he claims Seer. Like someone else said, he could've been communicating with a partner. That partner obviously being Dust. I'd also say possible werewolf.
AshMC1984 - He's made 4 short game relevant posts out of the 172 that have been made. What's there to say? Lurking scum? He unvoted after Dusts claim (his vote remained there from the RVS and he apparently never got around to changing it) and votes Zwet for voting without good reasons and trying to get a CC. He, however, doesn't mention Ace, who had the same reason for voting Dust as Zwet.
AA23 - AA has been seemed pretty town to me in the sense that he hasn't done anything scummy that I remember, and has been generally telling us all with good reasons, who could be scum on the wagon as well as providing different possibilities.
Percy - Hasn't done much of anything scummy, but at the same time, nothing much pro-town either.
Zwet/ Ace Werewolfs (Most likely) - Supported in posts 152 and 154.
Ace/ Ash Mafia (Possible)- Ash ignores Ace's reason for voting Dust, but doesn't ignore Zwet, who used the same reasoning.
Emp/ Dust Werewolves - Emp asked Dust to claim and mentions how a Seer shouldn't CC should that be the claim. If this were the pairing, it could be for two reasons. He hints at Dust to claim Seer and it would also keep his partner alive while making it look like he's keeping the towns best interest in mind.
Hopefully, when people have time, we'll have more opinions.
"You say that all my posts are stupid like a motherf***ing SOB. I'm sick and tired of your constant BS." - Zwet to me.
"Fuck you... You're a pompous, ignorant fool, dejkha, and I don't appreciate your incessant badmouthing of me." - Zwet
