Dust 2 - AshMC1984, Empking
AA23 1 - Gorckat
Empking 1 - dejkha
zwetschenwasser 1 - Mixologist
Khamisa 1 - Percy
Any you know I'm town in those games, how?Dust wrote:In tandem with some of the last games you've posted in, Dej's argument makes a lot of sense, Empking. Scanning over games like Open 131, or Mushroom Kingdom II, you don't actually do much to help the town, and I could certainly understand his position if I had also had 50+ games with you.
And that doesn't really matter because? Considering it made town suspicious of him and stopped him from scum hunting.
On the other hand, other than Dej's almost unhealthy obsession with lynching you, I don't see much wrong with the just finished Pie game, considering he got nightkilled Night One.
Would you try to make sense of a blabbering child or "special" kids that love their helmets? I don't have the patience for that kind of thing. I mostly just ignore what he says unless it's a question or comment that isn't completely stupid/useless.Dust wrote:On the other hand, other than Dej's almost unhealthy obsession with lynching you, I don't see much wrong with the just finished Pie game, considering he got nightkilled Night One. His main problem, and what I feel is the source of your accusation of bad play on his part, is the fact that he is absolutely dedicated to lynching you, and doesn't pay attention to much of what you say, which I feel is a mistake.
Dust, you should note that, as it turned out, it was actually scum that was "suspicious" of me.Empking wrote:And that doesn't really matter because? Considering it made town suspicious of him and stopped him from scum hunting.
@Dust - Emp suggested you were buddying up to Dej and you immediately in post 52 distanced yourself - I'm having trouble seeing it as a natural choice over a tacticDust wrote:
That said, I think that Empking definitely has some problems with his play style, but nothing to warrant persecution on the level that Dej has suggested.
Percy, what are your thoughts on the game? Acemarksman, if you could answer as well, it'd be appreciated.
Dust wrote: Can we get some other relevant, non-biased information on this game? I can't see this going anywhere...
There's no rule to linking to games outside of the site is there? Can you link to those games?AceMarksman wrote:Vote: dust
I have seen dust in other games (not on this site) playing as scum, and in every one where he is scum, he startsexactlylike this. Things to note: stifling of the RVS, which he supports when he's town, being quick to FoS but slow to vote etc.
Yes, because a random voting stage IS useful. There need be no alternative. I don't like meta. I can understand if you don't want to random vote, but you shouldn't attempt to bar everyone from random voting.Dust wrote:Do you think it's scummy to say that an RVS shouldn't be conducted? What would you prefer as an alternative? Do any of you have interesting meta on other players?
He didn't kill anything. That alone started discussion, as you can see.zwetschenwasser wrote:Vote: dust
You start off the game by killing discussion-gleaning phase. Bad cookie!
Felt like fence-sitting and non-comment on a theory issue. Easy for scum to do and appear pro-active.AA23 wrote:@Gorckat - - If you re-read my response, can you please explain how me answering a question exactly how it was asked is buddying up? I was asked about what my opinion on the matter was - my answer gave an opinion on both sides, and my choice was in the post itself (no vote).
I just completed a game with both (as well as Ace). zwet's erratic behavior and Emp's lylo lurking arguably cost the town the game. (My case as scum against Ace was awesome, however )AA23 wrote:@Everyone - - Why is meta being brought up so soon on Zwet and Emp? It's only fair to let each game be it's own, and they'll dig their own holes all by themselves (besides, as I understand it, Zwet has been trying to spruce up his gameplay, and successfully at that)
It's called a "tell". Everyone has them. Figuring out your own makes you better. In this case, you should be thanking Ace. I'm willing to give his info some merit,if he can share how many games he's observed these behaviors, and how many games don't match, as well as their order of occurrence.dej wrote:No to mention how I doubt any player would give themselves away so easily.
AA23 wrote:You're trying to manufacture leadership, but fall into becoming a follower - - that's scummy.
Post numbers?AA23 wrote:You ask a question - I answer it - someone votes me for my answer - you join in and express suspicion toward me