Lynch All Lurkers Mafia! GAME OVER

[image]

12 alive, if two lynches go through today we'll have 10 left at night, so assuming that we started with 6 scum (which seems about right for this size game) we're now rapidly approaching LYLO.

Looking at the DGB lynch, rofl's case on her was pretty weak. She was suspicious, yes, but probably not worth lynching had she not asked for it. Especially after DGB flipping town, I feel quite wary of roflcopter.

---

[/url]mafiassk has claimed a post restriction

and i don't believe him

changed my mind, he can die next

[/url]also, outside chance that ssk is scum faking his post restriction. i think its more likely he's town, and either got a real post restriction (in this game? don't make me laugh) or is a complete and total tool faking a pr as town. either way, not really foreseeing him living past day three unless my list is spot on and the scum just get knocked down like dominoes.

Unexplained complete reversal of opinion. Nice.

[/url]lynch before mcqueso hits 72 hours go go

More pressuring to speed lynch based on lurker threats. Not good town play to try to lynch someone who is mildly scummy to prevent

your scumbuddy

someone else from looking very scummy.

[/url]i think empking is town. this read needs additional data. if either you (dgb) or xtoxm flips scum i become more certain of it. this is based on the random ass miniwagon on emp you two put together that looked suspiciously like an attempted diversion from the zwet wagon.

"Additional data" meaning more than none? What is your opinion of Empking now?

[/url]can i just get everyone to understand that when i say
"you are scum because of x, y and z reasons"

and xtoxm, or dgb, or poptajo respond with
"no but you suck at mafia so you are wrong"

it is an ad hom just as much as
"no but you are a flaming homosexual and therefore you are wrong"
or any other character-based reason to dismiss my argument would be?

Upon review, your cases against tajo and DGB were fairly weak. However, you kept continuously hammering at them without supplying any new reasoning; most of your posts were along the lines of "Well you're scum so I don't care what you say." Most of your actual arguments were based on things that happened in the first 12 pages and ignoring what they said in response.

[/url]you ignore the point that no scum in their right mind is about to kill you when you make a juicy mislynch target if you are town.

As you would know.

[/url]eeeeeh. now i'm pretty sure malyss is town, but there really isn't any good reason for me to think this,

except for my role PM. I just want to sound like you're I believe you're town without actually trying to stop your wagon so that I look better when you flip town.

something about her post just seemed awfully sincere.

xyl's case is perfectly sound, but the problem is perfectly sound cases can be made by talented scum against townies who misstep. and its not the case itself that is bugging me about xyl, its his absolute refusal to interact with anything else EXCEPT the malyss wagon. he refuses to take a stance on xtoxm, for example. that is hella scummy.

also, malyss, i for one will not forget your wagon, but i'm sorry to say your wagon itself will not be what helps me catch the scum on it - i've already pinpointed dgb and xtoxm, and i've been zeroed in on x in particular since zwet flipped scum.

[/url]i think antihero is town, so i'd prefer giving him a chance to post after night. malyss is completely non interactive after multiple chances to step it up, and the amount i'll buy the novice/this game is too fast defense only goes so far.

unvote, vote: malyss

"I don't want this wagon shifting off of Malyss and by lynching now I might be able to hit a town power role before she can claim! Even though I just finished lauding her as being town, I'm going to hammer anyway instead of getting one of the people I claim to think is scum lynched."

[/url]

I want to lynch Tajo just to spite dgb, but I think I'll control myself.

i want to lynch tajo just because dgb was wrong. are you going to refuse to do so because you don't bus?

vote: tajo

"Now let's go right back to trying to lynch tajo despite everything that has happened since the zwet lynch."

Roflcopter: I name you scum and call for your lynch.

Vote: Roflcopter

.

[roflcopter]

i like how after i named image as scum yesterday, he's suddenly gung ho for my lynch

i also like how he's using the fact that i drove the dgb wagon against me even though he readily joined it when i requested it of him.

we can lynch image today too. that would be a good day.

image - please explain in detail how my case against dgb was "weak"

[Xylthixlm]

FoS image

[image]

@rofl: I did not vote DGB because you requested it of me. I voted her because

she

was requesting votes.

As for your case on DGB:
Your main point was that she was working against your lynch of tajo. The amount of confidence in his townieness she showed was questionable, but certainly not lynch-worthy.

Further, you accuse her of ignoring the wagon on zwet on D1. She got on it fairly early, left when something else looked scummy to her, and then returned. It is not a terribly scummy thing to not have tunnelvision.

You also point out that she is "trying to discredit you", when you haven't really made any clear case against her, preferring comments like "DING DING DING DGB IS SCUM WEE OO WEE OO RAISE THE ALARM".

---

THIS TOTALLY INEPT, COMATOSE, BRAIN-DEAD TOWN is letting it happen.

[BrianMcQueso]

Yosarian2, can you replace me?

I've only got time to check in and post once every 1-2 days, and while I thought the three day shot-clock would be supportive of that, the game has moved along at a much faster pace that I can't keep up with.

[MafiaSSK]

FoS image

Lol

[ortolan]

^^^ this guy is a much better lynch seriously. We all agree he needs to die at some point so

Vote: MafiaSSK

[MafiaSSK]

^^^ this guy is a much better lynch seriously. We all agree he needs to die at some point so

Vote: MafiaSSK

Scummy logic.

[image]

^^^To be fair, you have contributed very little comment. Who do you think is scum? Why?

[MafiaSSK]

^^^To be fair, you have contributed very little comment. Who do you think is scum? Why?

Xyl. His current aggressive style.

[Empking]

^^^To be fair, you have contributed very little comment. Who do you think is scum? Why?

Xyl. His current aggressive style.

Isn't that his meta?

[Empking]

i also like how he's using the fact that i drove the dgb wagon against me even though he readily joined it when i requested it of him.

Image: Was it the that Rofl drove it or theway he drove it that was scummy.

[image]

i also like how he's using the fact that i drove the dgb wagon against me even though he readily joined it when i requested it of him.

Image: Was it the that Rofl drove it or theway he drove it that was scummy.

Mostly the way the wagon was driven. He was pushing it again and again with no added points against DGB, asserting the whole while that he was confident she was scum, despite the fact that his case was far from making it a certainty, as we now know.

The way he drove the DGB wagon is not the only point I have against him, though. What I find at least as scummy is how he has repeatedly tried to use the threat of people lurking to push people onto wagons without thinking. Here's another time he did it, that I forgot to post last time...

[/url]LYNCH TAJO BEFORE MCQUESO HITS 72 HOURS. I KNOW THERE ARE ENOUGH ACTIVE PEOPLE IN THIS GAME TO DO IT.

unless there is a doctor in this game, or the scum are afraid of a doctor, i am going to die tonight. please don't be so god damn frustrating with my last 24 hours in this thread messing around with a sub optimal ssk lynch.

And with an appeal to emotion, too!

[Stephoscope]

I would just like to mention that the mason team in this game has to be the most useless in history.

[Yosarian2]

1populartajo: roflcopter
1roflcopter: image

10 Not Voting: Xylthixlm, ortolan, Empking, elvis_knits, populartajo. q21, Antihero, BrianMcQueso, MafiaSSK, Stephoscope
12 alive; 7 to lynch.

[MafiaSSK]

I would just like to mention that the mason team in this game has to be the most useless in history.

QFT

[elvis_knits]

My internet was fucked yesterday and I'm giving a party tonight. I may not have time to give real thoughts until tomorrow, but I thought I'd post so nobody thought I was eaten by sea monkeys.

Also, I don't think rofl is scum.

[populartajo]

Got no result again. If anyone cares, I tracked Xyl.

[populartajo]

I want to lynch Tajo just to spite dgb, but I think I'll control myself.

I want to lynch Tajo just to spite dgb, but I think I'll control myself.

i want to lynch tajo just because dgb was wrong. are you going to refuse to do so because you don't bus?

vote: tajo

These guys are freaking amazing.

Ill evaluate the wagons later. I have a flu and Im not too happy about it.

[Xylthixlm]

Got no result again. If anyone cares, I tracked Xyl.

Does no result = no target?

[q21]

Mod: here is me officially asking to be replaced.

I've missed the last twp lynches due to RL and I don't want to screw up the game for anyone. I asked to be replaced over night, but the rules say I have to ask in thread... so here it is.

Really sorry guys.

[ortolan]

um

We must be getting close to the lurker threshold

[roflcopter]

somebody less lazy than me can do a count

[Empking]

Image: Third scummiest player?

[ortolan]

we're gonna need to policy lynch Mastin soon unless he posts

everyone else has posted today

I agree with rofl that image's case against him is blatantly opportunistic

That being said I don't think the case against her is as strong as rofl is playing it up to be.

As I've said earlier, I long stopped caring about my win condition and just want to prove them wrong, and hope the town loses. I'm sure that sentence is worth 1.5 votes on average. But I just don't care. I'm fighting really hard against the urge to self-vote at this point, and that sentence is probably worth another 1 vote, firm.

However, this post is in and of itself a pretty compelling argument.

Vote: DGB

.

This looks like classic scum trying (badly) to look better out of a mislynch. It's got the classic ingredient of expressing hesitance about a town wagon before the fact with no good reason.

It's extra scummy this time because he actually votes her for her own words subsequently. How can a case "not be as strong as rofl is playing it up to be" yet still be worthy of your vote?

I had a look at back and 1457 and 1465 are also very scummy.

1465 is more casting aspersions on people post-wagon. 1457 is complete WIFOM over the scum's choice of night-kill.

Unvote
Vote: image