Mini 732: Dr. Horrible's Sing-Along Mafia (Game Over!)

[Yosarian2]

I don't even know what's going on right now because I feel like we're not playing mafia.

Basically true, we're really not; at this point, we're mostly trying to take advantage of the setup and the roles to reduce the chances of a town loss to as close to zero as possible, we're not doing much actual scumhunting at this point.

[Empking]

Vote: Empking

I still think Gorrad is more likely to be scum, but we have room to hedge our bets and we might as well do so. Yos, you're targeting Gorrad tonight, yeah?

Yes.

Empking: Because you could be scum. I'm not really sure, you've generally havn't said much, but it's possible. From my point of view, there are 4 of you who could be scum, and using this plan, we lynch or vig 3 of you; those odds sound really good to me.

Apart from if you or your buddy is scum which is very likely.

[Yosarian2]

Vote: Empking

I still think Gorrad is more likely to be scum, but we have room to hedge our bets and we might as well do so. Yos, you're targeting Gorrad tonight, yeah?

Yes.

Empking: Because you could be scum. I'm not really sure, you've generally havn't said much, but it's possible. From my point of view, there are 4 of you who could be scum, and using this plan, we lynch or vig 3 of you; those odds sound really good to me.

Apart from if you or your buddy is scum which is very likely.

You know, the fact that you keep insinuating I'm scum in a situation where I'm basically confirmed town is part of what makes me suspect you here, empking. Scum wouldn't want me to be confirmed town here, now would they...

And how is "me being scum" now "very likely", exactally?

[Plum]

Vote: Empking

I still think Gorrad is more likely to be scum, but we have room to hedge our bets and we might as well do so. Yos, you're targeting Gorrad tonight, yeah?

Yes.

Empking: Because you could be scum. I'm not really sure, you've generally havn't said much, but it's possible. From my point of view, there are 4 of you who could be scum, and using this plan, we lynch or vig 3 of you; those odds sound really good to me.

Apart from if you or your buddy is scum which is very likely.

Wait, does 'your buddy' refer to me, Emp? Bit curious.

Emp, again, the main reason I like this plan is that while Gorrad is still the most likely to be scum in my opinion, this plan gives us extra room by both ensuring Gorrad gets killed if he's scum and giving us the most Town-controlled kills we can get to cover as many bases as we can. As Yos said, the plan is an attempt at the optimal solution to bring down the possibility of a scum win here as far as we can.

Emp, do you have a case on Yos2 and/or his 'buddy'? You say that it's very likely one of the two is scum, so could you argue the point, please?

[Empking]

Vote: Empking

I still think Gorrad is more likely to be scum, but we have room to hedge our bets and we might as well do so. Yos, you're targeting Gorrad tonight, yeah?

Yes.

Empking: Because you could be scum. I'm not really sure, you've generally havn't said much, but it's possible. From my point of view, there are 4 of you who could be scum, and using this plan, we lynch or vig 3 of you; those odds sound really good to me.

Apart from if you or your buddy is scum which is very likely.

You know, the fact that you keep insinuating I'm scum in a situation where I'm basically confirmed town is part of what makes me suspect you here, empking. Scum wouldn't want me to be confirmed town here, now would they...

And how is "me being scum" now "very likely", exactally?

You're not basically confirmed town.

You or the person you choose not to kill is very likely as your most likely to not kill the person trying hardest to stay alive and you're likely scum as you keep on saying "I'm confirmed town" at every possible opportunity.

[mith]

Vote Count:

3 to lynch.

Empking: 2 (Plum, Yosarian2)
Plum: 1 (Empking)

Not Voting: 2 (Gorrad, hasdgfas)

[Gorrad]

*Prodded*

Vote: Empking

Well, let's try this plan. Make SOMETHING happen.

[Yosarian2]

All right, Bad Horse. It's curtains for you. Lacy, gently wafting curtains.

[mith]

Final Vote Count:

3 to lynch.

Empking: 3 (Gorrad, Plum, Yosarian2)
Plum: 1 (Empking)

Not Voting: 1 (hasdgfas)

Empking, Bad Horse (TOWNIE Pseudo-Ascetic) has been lynched. It is Night 5. Choices due Tuesday, April 21, 17:00 GMT.

[mith]

Resigned to defeat, Moist takes aim at Captain Hammer for a parting shot. Fan Club Boy jumps in front of it, taking one for the team. (Everyone's a hero in their own way.)

And then Moist gets a face full of Hammer. Er. Hammer's fist. Not

that

Hammer.

Gorrad (MAFIA) and hasdgfas (TOWNIE) are dead. Town wins!

[Plum]

Sweet. Good game, everyone. Gorrad, you just wanted a quick and painless end, yeah?

[Plum]

Also - mith, thank you for stepping in to moderate when Glork disappeared.

[Gorrad]

Aye. Quick and painless. Plus I wanted in for Inventor mafia and there was no CHANCE I could have survived the next day, so I wanted to take Yos down with me.

[Yosarian2]

Good game, everyone.

Yeah; I've known Gorrad was probably the scum for a while now, basically ever since he didn't take that info role; just wanted to be safe, and abuse the known role combinations to their potential.

Empking: To answer your question from before the end of the game; the idea was that, if I was going to try and kill Gorrad, he would roleblock me (or die, as he did). So, he clearly wouldn't be able to kill. Also, if I was being jailkept, no one would If the scum was either plum or hascow, then if they killed, they would have had to either kill Gorrad (no loss there; we were going to lynch him anyway) or one would have had to kill the other. Say hascow was the scum; if he killed plum, then we would know Gorrad was town (since gorrad can't kill while roleblocking me), and so we would have lynched hascow for an easy town win. This way it was basically an almost certain town win no matter who was scum.

[hasdgfas]

sorry for completely sucking after about day 1. A mod leaving makes me just stop caring, as sad as that may be.

[TonyMontana]

gg -.-

[MeMe]

last post