camn:
camn wrote:Incognito wrote:
camn:
Why would scum be more likely to soft-claim than town?
Because it is in scum's interest to be perceived as a PR, and thus a poor lynch, but not be a CLAIMED PR, and thus have to deal with why-aren't-you-dead WIFOM.
On the other hand, it is in a townies interest to HIDE their PR status, because then they live longer.
Not that I am saying C was softclaiming. Just that softclaiming and rolefishing often go together.
I wasn't rolefishing GC, and I don't believe GC was softclaiming. I don't believe that GC has role-based on Yos, and I think his case is almost entirely meta-based.
This post gives me strong town vibes. It is generally not in the scum's best interests to highlight tactics that they might want to use later (or, at least, I'd expect an aversion to doing so). The assertive statements at the end are also very town-like.
I do not blame her for jumping on my wagon, because I did look scummy and her vote was not indicative that she wanted to lynch me. The word "compelling" strikes me as honest.
camn wrote:Ether wrote:Hmm. Camn, what was the deal with your vote and unvote, anyway?
Which one?
I wanted you to get more in the game.
Plus I have been kind of gambit-happy lately, and I wanted to see what Yosarian would do.
Keep it up on the first, meh on the second.
Jokey mood strikes me as town.
Dizzy:
DizzyIzzyB13 wrote:Xdaamno wrote:(obvious town read on korts)
Well, that's about all the evidence we need for a Korts lynch. :p
Scum vibes here. This is her only post relating to my wagon that was forming. Strikes me as backseat and cocky.
DizzyIzzyB13 wrote:Korts wrote:Ether: the reason for my Izzyvote is quite simple: she stated an intention to specifically lynch me based simply on the fact that with a week left of Day 1 I decided not to toil away with an increasing amount of reading material and try to interact. I can't believe that she doesn't have any better suspects. It seems more like an alibi-vote than anything.
And thanks for the advice, I will try to make time for some reading.
Please. You deliberately avoided the game and lurked. That's scummy behaviour. You've refused to catch up and contribute. Also scummy behaviour. You've attempted to find other people's opinions to latch on to to avoid the accountability of having your own. That's scummy. When you get enough votes that you h
ave a bandwagon, suddenly you're all over this game like crabs on Paris Hilton.
That's scummy.
Nothing of your behaviour in this game has been townish. You're a good candidate for a lynch, and the best one at the moment. I'm happy with my Korts vote.
What do the rest of you think? Is my Kortscase flawed in any way? I'm willing to yield to a convincing argument, but I'm unable to find one myself.
The joke here seems out-of-place and un-townlike. This is because a town player who is actually making a serious attack would be expected to have a serious attitude.
Ether:
Ether wrote:Sometimes, I don't like myself very much. I woke up much less enthusiastic about my Yosvote than I was when I placed it, finding myself under suspicion that I...didn't really disagree with, and put off addressing it. (On Thursday, I
was
doing a programming cram, but that's Thursday.) This is a recovery mode post; I won't really feel comfortable until I'm interacting again.
Weak town vibes from the self-deprecation.
Yosarian:
I think I always have trouble reading Yosarian, and it's even harder given that I'm the subject of many of his posts.
Yosarian2 wrote:Xdaamno wrote:Yosarian2 wrote:camn wrote: In my experience. . scum don't drop atom bombs on people day 1.
Oh, speaking of which, I'm a miller.
It sounds like TownYos was either waiting for an opportunity, or forgot to say this earlier. Which is it, Yos, if the question is fair?
I was planning to claim miller at some point during day 1, like I said. I didn't really want to do it right at the start of day 1, because I had wanted to let some other conversations start up first, but I didn't want to wait too long either, wanted to make sure the town had enough time to dicuss my claim and act in a rational way about it. (shrug) Seems like the timing worked out pretty well; town had time to talk and think about my claim, got lots of interesting reactions, and it didn't stifle other lines of discussion.
So, Xdaamno, here's the key question for you to answer. If you had to pick someone to lynch, right now, who would it be? The way you haven't really attacked or voted anyone all day is really the main reason I'm suspecting you at this point.
This last paragraph in and of itself just struck me as town. I suppose you were trying to get me to notice it and not forget it? Going down that thought process is something scum do not need to do, and so I think you are town.
Incognito:
Incognito wrote:Aren't you usually a breadcrumbing kind of guy?
Incognito wrote:Ether's
sooooo
cool when she's town.
Your relaxed attitude lately makes me think that if you are scum, there's probably no town players under suspiscion right now.
Kind of incomplete, so I'll try and do a little more when I can before the day ends.
I support the deadline extension, mod.
For now, my vote will sit here:
Unvote, Vote: Dizzy
.