Newbie 744 -- Game Over!

[AshKetchummm]

@Zazier I think most of your points are valid arguments, but am curious as to what your reasoning for posting my "think this is the hammer" post. I couldn't really figure out what you're trying to get out of him from that.

Cntr's still my top choice for a lynch, while he did respond to the allegations against him, a lot of his reasoning just dosn't make much sense, while some if it I can relate too to a certain degree.

I'd like to here more from Cntr, as I think his case right now is much more importent then syndromes case.

It's almost like you're trying to draw attention away from him...

[Yaw]

Vote Count:

CntRational (3): Kmd4390, syndromeofadown, Raivann
syndromeofadown (1): ZazieR

Not Voting: alexhans, AshKetchummm, CntRational

4 to lynch

[alexhans]

Catching up from a Cyber-cafe.
First of all... Happy birthday KMD!!!

Ok, thanks. I got my re-read done and I feel confident in a...

Vote:CntR

For all the reasons that have been previously stated by everyone
and I'm not believing his answers today

But I still think the fact that you said Mizz was a townie, and decided to vote for me anyways. I don't think thats just trying to get the game moving along, I don't think a Town player would risk lynching someone they thing it town no matter what

I agree

I'm more cautious during the beginning of the game, but less so later on.

not buying it

Yeah I know it's L1 , sorry alex but CntR is my top suspect by far and I feel my vote is in the right place

It's ok... But I dont like that you say in general all the reasons stated before by everyone... Better quote the reasons you think are valid.

Oh... I guess you did later. when KMD told you to in 254. I like that post better.

Hmm...Blue is at Lynch-1 now...should we wait for him to post?

Really wanting a quick blue lynch here , scummy post. To me this post sounds like- Someone please drop the hammer! Whether it's good for the town or not.

I agree. It's really fishy. Trying to appear cautious but calling for a hammer

mmm... big spot with CnrT responses... Don't know what to make of them.

alexhans is having a birthday today! Happy birthday! You share your birthday with my sister. Unless you just made up that birthday. If that's the case then disregard this =P

Thanks... and no... It IS my real Birthday. Great... tell your sister happy birthday from me... If she is 21 now then that's a big coincidence because we would be born the same day..

alexhans, well, I haven't seen very many insightful and townie posts from this guy, yet I haven't seen anything very outright scummy either. Neutral.

Ouch. guess I'll try to correct that. I'm re-reading and trying to find scum without help.

Thanks to raivann and Zazier too...

NOTE: I want to hear a response first from SoaD before someone may discuss this post. And I'd prefer it if Ash could respond afterwards, but this isn't obligatory.

Noted... Witholding in my notes a little commentary I had.

I'm leaning to a CntR lynch right now. Pending reasons in an organized post. I want him to be able to answer all questions(including mine) before I really decide on his lynch. (assuming nobody unvotes, then I would only vote him and not hammer him)
I think KMD is my biggest town-read right now.
Zaz and Ash are in my list of surveillance.
SoaD and Raivann are neutral.

[Raivann]

It's almost like you're trying to draw attention away from him...

but Zazie was going after CntR pretty hard yesterday though

[Yaw]

CntRational and syndromeofadown have been prodded (no posts for 5 days). Expect a deadline to be set once they're either back or replaced.

[alexhans]

What's up with this? no opinions of my post? That CnrT and SoaD are not active doesn't mean we have to dissapear too.... Ash, Raiv, Zaz, Kmd? you there?

[Yaw]

CntRational has PMed (but is still on the clock for the next prod). No response from syndromeofadown means I'm looking for a replacement for him.

[Kmd4390]

What's up with this? no opinions of my post? That CnrT and SoaD are not active doesn't mean we have to dissapear too.... Ash, Raiv, Zaz, Kmd? you there?

Yeah, I'm here. Zazie is around too. She'll probably post tomorrow.

[syndromeofadown]

NOTE: I want to hear a response first from SoaD before someone may discuss this post. And I'd prefer it if Ash could respond afterwards, but this isn't obligatory.

I really don't have much to say about this. I now understand completely where you're coming from, and can understand why you're voting for me, and there is really not much I can do to defend myself. So I guess I'll just have to accept that you think I'm scummy and move on.

PS: Expect a huge post from me tonight or tommorow morning. I'm off to disneyland with my family, ciao!

[alexhans]

PS: Expect a huge post from me tonight or tommorow morning. I'm off to disneyland with my family, ciao!

Great. Big post. Good trip. When are you coming back?

[AshKetchummm]

I await Syndromes post, but I don't want too jump on it too soon like i did with blue, let's wait for the replacement to come in this time me thinks.

[Yaw]

Well, syndromeofadown showing up means we don't need a replacement for him any more. Search for one has been called off.

[AshKetchummm]

Woops. That didn't come out right

(I was typing from my new DSi)

It should read-

I await Syndromes post, but I don't want us to jump to a lynch to soon like what happened with blue (mostly my fault).

[Kmd4390]

I await Syndromes post, but I don't want us to jump to a lynch to soon like what happened with blue (mostly my fault).

Do you think your actions regarding Blue were scummy? Would you do it again?

[AshKetchummm]

If you interpret eager to the move the game along as scummy, then yeah sure it most defiantly was scummy.

That was my main purpose at the time, though I most likely would not do it again unless it was believed to be the best move.

[Kmd4390]

Ash, are you worried about looking scummy?

[Raivann]

Is CntR getting replaced?

[alexhans]

Still waiting... I made that effort of catching up from a cibercafé for nothing?

Also posting to say HAPPY BIRTHDAY Zaz I hope you post soon! Have fun!

[syndromeofadown]

I quit.

Sorry you had to call off your replacement search. I thought I could be committed, but too many things which I have no control over are preventing me from posting more than once every 4 or 5 days, which isn't active enough to keep the game going, and is detrimental to game.

Sorry again, but I'm afraid this is for the best. Take care ^_^

[Yaw]

Thanks for letting me know. I'll look for a replacement.

[AshKetchummm]

Ash, are you worried about looking scummy?

It all depends on how you interpret it.

I'm not really sure how to answer that question to be honest...

[Yaw]

CntRational has been prodded again (5 days since his response PM).
ZazieR has also been prodded (5 days since her last post).

[Kmd4390]

Ash, are you worried about looking scummy?

It all depends on how you interpret it.

I'm not really sure how to answer that question to be honest...

Let me phrase it this way.

If you were extremely confident that a player was scum. Let's say 90% sure. And they were at L-1, already claimed (let's say vanilla for sake of argument). Hypothetically, let's say hammering may look scummy and lead to your lynch the next day if you are wrong (it shouldn't, but let's just say it would hypothetically). Do you hammer?

[ZazieR]

Catching up.

I'm still happy with my SoaD vote. There were a lot of things he could have responded to, but he dismisses them all by saying that there isn't much he can do to defend himself. Or he could have explained some of his actions.

Someone else who has caught my attention is Ash.
First of all, I'll explain why I asked CntR the question about that post of yours, after he has answered it.
As for my reason why, he didn't bother twice to wait for a post. But suddenly he warns us that we shouldn't jump too soon on SoaD.
Another reason is post 289. Apparently, the main purpose of his (hammer)vote against Blue was to get this game moving again. Look what CntR did. He also voted Ash to get this game moving again. The difference only was that Ash hammered someone, while CntR put someone at L-1. So I'd like to know from Ash what made CntR's action scummy, while his is not to him.
Also, please note that Ash never mentioned one of Blue's actions. So his vote also came out of the blue, the thing he has accused CntR of.
Question:

The last to post confirm what I've been saying about CNT, not giving any valuable input, and just looking for a lynch it seems like.

How come you've accused CntR of this, but not SoaD?

FoS Ash

I'm fine with a lynch of either Ash or SoaD


(off-topic and non-serious stuff)
Thanks for the birthday wishes For those who haven't given me a gift, join the bandwagon on SoaD That would be a nice gift.

And Kmd, since when do you know when I might post?
I'll forgive you if you'll make/join an Ash bandwagon

[Kmd4390]

And Kmd, since when do you know when I might post?

Just guessing.