Open 122 - Near Vanilla (Game over)

[VP Baltar]

Because if he is one of our powerroles I would rather know now and get his night actions than just lynch straight off because he's a nusiance. Only scum need to hurry a lynch.

[hewitt]

Okay I actually realized that exactly 5:26 during t'ai chi that my vote does not count because I did not

Unvote: maadneet

I actually had faith that VP was going to catch that but never mind nobody did so that was my bad, technically mufasa was at L-2 this whole time after dejkha unvoted.

Vote: mufasa

And VP if he was a power role do you really think that he would be "sacrificing" himself?

The hammar has not been thrown down yet so mufasa if you comply to VP's wishes after you come back from baseball practice that would be great.

[hewitt]

NOW he's officially at L-1.

[VP Baltar]

haha, I have been getting thier names messed up this whole game. Probably because maadneet rarely shows up and mufasa doesn't have an avatar.

I think he might just be frustrated from everyone attacking him. I have read games with newbies doing it before. In fact, one game had someone leave the site altogether because they thought people were being too aggressive. It happens.

Speaking of maadneet, you notice how he never came back after he was called on that disparity in his posts?

[zwetschenwasser]

WHY is it so important to you to keep a useless newb around for another day so we can have this exact same argument tomorrow?

I see your point. I think we should lynch Zwet next then.

Blatant strawman.

[dejkha]

No, I seriously think we should lynch you next. I'm just glad you support it.

[zwetschenwasser]

It was a blatant strawman. Now noone's going to even consider what I said in the post just because you said that I match the description.

[dejkha]

You match the description on a useless newb, so why keep you around after tomorrow? I'm using your logic, buddy. You should support me.

[hewitt]

haha, I have been getting thier names messed up this whole game. Probably because maadneet rarely shows up and mufasa doesn't have an avatar.

I think he might just be frustrated from everyone attacking him. I have read games with newbies doing it before. In fact, one game had someone leave the site altogether because they thought people were being too aggressive. It happens.

Speaking of maadneet, you notice how he never came back after he was called on that disparity in his posts?

Okay see now I feel like I'm trying to be made as picking on mufasa just because he's newer. I'm newer as well I have not completed that many games on this site at all so it's really hard for me to show sympathy just because someone feels attacked.

I did notice that maadneet did not come back to voice his defense after that and my vote would still be on him if I did not believe mufasa was scum as well. I would support a maadneet, mufasa, or hohum lynch right now and I'm confident that mufasa is scum. I do think that he's playing up the newbie card and I think that it was a brilliant play to misvote and not return. He said he was a full time student and that he's at baseball practice gives him the perfect excuse to disappear for a while. I'm not exactly saying that he's lying but it would make the rest of us panic if he misvoted himself (which worked perfectly in my opinion) and then left us to stew it over too much.

[SpyreX]

The moral of the story is in the subset of Madaaneet, Mufasa, Zwet and Hohum there, by nature, HAS to be at LEAST one town.

That is sad. If I could shoot you all right now I would and wouldn't even feel bad if we lost since, well, you're never ever ever going to die and are all being p scummy.

Separately, I still really dont like Kier.

[Mufasa]

Walks in

sees commotion

Grins

ponders, what do they want? a Claim?

Why would I claim doctor if I know i'm going get killed tonight?

what the heck lets do this

Claim: Doctor [/sup]

[dejkha]

Wow. Are you serious? I almost don't even believe it. The reason to claim doctor is so scum burn their NK tonight. Now we can get a second chance for todays lynch.

Vote: Zwet

[VP Baltar]

ok, who did you protect last night and why.

[SpyreX]

Unvote

I hate this game right about now.

Vote: Maadanet

[SpyreX]

I am REAL tempted to call bullshit and say this is a scum-move to get the doc to CC, btw.

[Mufasa]

I protected Kmd for I felt he was the most vulnerable after putting his foot out there and not being on edge with Emp.

[ac1983fan]

unvote

Well, that's certainly an interesting twist....

[dejkha]

I am REAL tempted to call bullshit and say this is a scum-move to get the doc to CC, btw.

Same here, but if that's the case: Real Doc, do not claim.

I also don't see how he can miss the obvious benefits of claiming doc (if he is) if he's about to be lynched.

[Kmd4390]

Unvote; Vote: Mufasa

It's fascinating that Kreriov is blatantly buddying up to Mufasa.

So you're voting for mufasa because kreriov is buddying up with him? With that reasoning I would've thought vice versa...

I agree with hewitt. Being buddied up to is NOT a scumtell. Buddying up, however, IS a scumtell. Also, examples of this to back up your statement would be nice.

Okay just to let everyone know since it seems the majority is online and posting when I come back from t'ai chi at 6 I full-heartedly plan on hammering mufasa. I believe he's scum for the reasons I stated in my after-lynch post but I will not hammer until after 6. I believe this gives enough people time to question mufasa as they will or remove their vote as they will. It also gives mufasa a little bit more time to explain and just for the record I dislike that little appeal to emotion mufasa.

Would you have hammered if he hadn't claimed by then?

That looked like a hammer...

Unvote

Wasn't bolded properly.

it would have been if he could type in his coding correctly. whew

What makes you think he did it wrong unintentionally?

Notice how he typed it out instead of clicking the bold button on the editing tool.

I always type it out and wouldn't be surprised at all if I'm not alone in that.

WHY is it so important to you to keep a useless newb around for another day so we can have this exact same argument tomorrow?

Do (or did) you think he is scum, or is this Empking all over again?

unvote

Well, that's certainly an interesting twist....

Got anything else to say?

Same here, but if that's the case: Real Doc, do not claim.

If mufasa is scum claiming doc, no counter claim leaves him alive as scum and makes a later doc claim more suspicious considering a real doc knows Mufasa to be scum right now. A counter claim lynches us scum for sure (and if Mufasa flips doc, we have scum tomorrow). I think if Mufasa isn't doc, the real doc SHOULD claim. Yes, I realize that if Mufasa is scum, the doc claim was a good move to out the real doc, but after his claim, why would a real doc NOT claim?

Basically, Mufasa is doc unless I see a counterclaim.

[ac1983fan]

unvote

Well, that's certainly an interesting twist....

Got anything else to say?

I believe Mufasa's claim. It makes sense that the mafia would try to kill you, arguably the most pro-town player in this game.

[Kmd4390]

unvote

Well, that's certainly an interesting twist....

Got anything else to say?

I believe Mufasa's claim. It makes sense that the mafia would try to kill you, arguably the most pro-town player in this game.

What about your suspicions right now?

[Mufasa]

There shouldn't be a counter post because I am the real doctor, and if there is a counter post I am going to assume full well that the person that counters me is scum trying to get rid of the real doctor

[ac1983fan]

What about your suspicions right now?

I'm unsure, I'll have to reread.

[VP Baltar]

What makes you think he did it wrong unintentionally?

Judging from his sign up date an countless logic holes in his arguments it seems to me that he isn't experienced enough to be so tricksy. Also, I type out all of my coding as well and miss stuff all the time if I don't do preview first.

[dejkha]

If mufasa is scum claiming doc, no counter claim leaves him alive as scum and makes a later doc claim more suspicious considering a real doc knows Mufasa to be scum right now. A counter claim lynches us scum for sure (and if Mufasa flips doc, we have scum tomorrow). I think if Mufasa isn't doc, the real doc SHOULD claim. Yes, I realize that if Mufasa is scum, the doc claim was a good move to out the real doc, but after his claim, why would a real doc NOT claim?

Basically, Mufasa is doc unless I see a counterclaim.

Actually, I think my reasoning is good, but I wasn't going to say it until tomorrow. Then as I was typing this, I realized I'd probably get NK'd.

Basically, if he's not the real doc, claiming doc is an easy way to out the real one, obviously. But I didn't want the real doc to be outted today because of a fake claim. Making losing the real doc a certainty wouldn't be good so soon. So I wanted to wait and see what the NK turned out to be. That may make it easier to decide what to do with him depending on what happens. Unfortunately I can't say more than that for reasons I shouldn't yet reveal.