Newbie 745 - Town wins!

[Gabe]

So Kison and hohum are both in the mafia now? I think you just have something against their playing styles.

[farside22]

Vote count:

Mufasa 1 votes: (Gabe )
Family: Kostic 1 vote: (hohum)
hohum 2 vote: (Bladewing Vorox, Family:Kostic)
Kison 1 vote: (Mufasa)


Not voting:

Kison
Spinach


With 7 players it takes 4 to lynch

[Bladewing Vorox]

I won't be able to post until Friday.

Noted!

[farside22]

prodding hohum

[Family:Kostic]

farside22, please note post subject: 286. To change votes accordingly, thanks. =]

I am going to

unvote. vote: Kison

. I really enjoy your posts, but my vote is based on what Neko had said during his time.

Thanks. All that bold I missed that.
If things don't pick up I will do a mass prod tomorrow and set a deadline.

[Gabe]

I would say that we should lynch Mufasa and check reactions afterwards, but there's plenty we could learn before the lynching.
For example, I'd like to hear what spinach's thoughts are.

[Kison]

For example, I'd like to hear what spinach's thoughts are.

This.

Also, hohum is still MIA.

[Mufasa]

I wouldn't mind voting for hohum, because the way he has lay lowed all game is rather lurkish and as of late he has been out, but I'd only do that if thats what we all come to a decision on.

[farside22]

hohum picked up the prod but has not responded. I will go looking for a replacement

.

[Bladewing Vorox]

I'm back.
I see that few things have changed since tuesday.
I'm going to post my thoughts later.

[Gabe]

I'm back.
I see that few things have changed since tuesday.
I'm going to post my thoughts later.

When?

[Kison]

I wouldn't mind voting for hohum, because the way he has lay lowed all game is rather lurkish and as of late he has been out, but I'd only do that if thats what we all come to a decision on.

What is your stance on Spinach at this point?

@Moderator: Could we get a prod on Spinach, pretty please?

I find Hohum idling out to be interesting. Would he be less likely to do that if he was scum, considering he would currently be ahead of the game?

[Bladewing Vorox]

Well, here are my thoughts.

Mufasa

: He seems to be less eager than he was before but voting for himself was a bad move (and a wierd one too). I don't think he is scum but we should keep an eye on him, just in case of.

hohum

: He is a good player but him asking for more votes on Family: Kostic seems a bit strange to me. I want to hear more from him but he hasn't responded yet.

Spinach

: He doesn't seems active a lot. I'm going to read his posts again and try to find something.

I don't have anything to say about kison, Gabe and Family: Kostic yet.
Sorry for the short post.

[farside22]

prodding spinach. Still looking for a replacement for hohum.

[Mufasa]

I believe that Spinach is Scummy but Hohum is as well. I would hammer either of them. But with their current MIA report we should wait I suppose.

[Family:Kostic]

Pitty Hohum had to be absent right about now, was just beginning to debate him properly.

Similar thing happened with Neko also actually..

Can't say this has been a great learning experience so far tbh..

[farside22]

replacing hohum is qwints.

[qwints]

/confirming replacement

[qwints]

Ok, I finished the re-read. Here is my list of players from scummiest to towniest:
1) Mufasa
*Proposed no-lynch
*Self voted
*A couple instances of role-fishing
*His call to lynch w/i 12 hours (post 152)
*Retreated from votes when criticize
2) Family:Kostic
*Lists scummy factors of mufasa, then says he doesn't see why Mufasa is scum
*Saying mufasa couldn't be scum because too stupid (124)
*His defense saying if scum he wouldn't kill bronc
*His WIFOM attack on spinach (218)
3) Spinach
*Lack of content even when pressed
4) Kison
* neko's claim that he hinted not to claim (204)
* Vote hopping since he came in
5) Bladewing
*Pre-emptive claiming of doc
6) gabe
*Seems fairly patient

If I had to guess right now, I'd say that Mufasa and family are the most likely to be scum with Mufasa being the most suspicious by far.

[farside22]

Spinach has not responded. I will look for a replacement.

[qwints]

In the interests of promoting discussion,

unvote, vote Mufasa

[Mufasa]

cool nice to see a hohum replacement, he was rather dry, but in the art that has become, I had strong feelings for Hohum being mafia, and you comming in and automatically going after me after I reportedly said I'd vote for Hohum, makes me just a suspecious as I was before, you think I am an easy kill therefore my vote is

vote: qwints

[qwints]

I note that Mufasa's OMGUS vote has put me at L-1. I will claim if anyone not currently voting for me asks me to. Anyone who hammers before asking for a claim is scum.

Mufasa, your contention that you are an "easy kill" is absurd. There were, after all, two other players with the same number of votes as you: 1. Secondly, you've had several players who are still alive defend you at one point or another. The fact that you're still alive after all your scummy behavior is proof that you're had to kill.

[Kison]

FoS: Mufasa

I'll vote once Spinach gets replaced unless we're backed up against a deadline.

[Family:Kostic]

Mufasa, don't you already have a vote on kison? Vote jumping is scummy..