what about my hurting of kinetic didn't seem independent to you?dgb wrote:I'm not sure why, but it didn't look like he was about to be lopped off, so I didn't do it, but I want to reward INDEPENDENT thinkers.
in the face of another wagon thats nearly at its conclusion which you seem to have been in support of not so long ago, and with absolutely no help from other players, yes it isdgb wrote:Is it so wrong to want another player completely obliterated?
thats my plan. people listening to kinetic's beg for heals campaign would set my plan back a little bit.xyl wrote:In that game the scum rage dump was week 4... let's try to have already won by then.
If memory serves that is correctly, yes.roflcopter wrote:does that one ginormous spike on the graph coincide with a rage dump?
Why do you imagine that I said you weren't thinking for yourself?roflcopter wrote:what about my hurting of kinetic didn't seem independent to you?dgb wrote:I'm not sure why, but it didn't look like he was about to be lopped off, so I didn't do it, but I want to reward INDEPENDENT thinkers.
in the face of another wagon thats nearly at its conclusion which you seem to have been in support of not so long ago, and with absolutely no help from other players, yes it is[/quote]Wishbone can die. And he will, in all likelihood, die today. I only had one hurt in the bank, and I wanted to lock in on Juls. She's scum.dgb wrote:Is it so wrong to want another player completely obliterated?
Oh, I get what you're saying.roflcopter wrote:thats my plan. people listening to kinetic's beg for heals campaign would set my plan back a little bit.xyl wrote:In that game the scum rage dump was week 4... let's try to have already won by then.
because your reward of INDEPENDENT thinker kinetic is going directly against my action of hurting himDrippingGoofball wrote:Why do you imagine that I said you weren't thinking for yourself?roflcopter wrote:what about my hurting of kinetic didn't seem independent to you?dgb wrote:I'm not sure why, but it didn't look like he was about to be lopped off, so I didn't do it, but I want to reward INDEPENDENT thinkers.
I disagree with hurting Kinetic with ABR/Juls obvscum roaming free.roflcopter wrote:because your reward of INDEPENDENT thinker kinetic is going directly against my action of hurting him
I just did.roflcopter wrote:so voice your disagreement. healing him would be incredibly, blatantly against the town's best interests.
Is that a threat? You're sounding like ABR.roflcopter wrote:...or we're gonna have a serious problem, you and me
for the purposes of this game, yesDrippingGoofball wrote:Is that a threat? You're sounding like ABR.roflcopter wrote:...or we're gonna have a serious problem, you and me
Yeah, that was my final decision tooXylthixlm wrote:I feel like Kinetic is town, but not strongly enough to heal him instead of hurting someone else.
Haha, OK, as long as we're clear.roflcopter wrote:for the purposes of this game, yes
in terms of how much i love you outside of this game, of course not
<3
I am certainly not treating anyone as confirmed town. Especially not waffle...Kinetic wrote: lol.
I just thought of something:
Anyone who hurts Walt at this point, including any of our other claimed Seraphim, can no longer claim to be town confirmed or believe that our claimed Seraphim, namely rofl or nuwen, are town confirmed.
By hurting Walt you consent to the possibility that Seraphim can still be scum even though we've killed one that was scum. Thus, there is no way you can use the fact that Rofl or Nuwen are Seraphim as a reason for them being town again.
And thus, any Seraphim who later claim to be Seraphim who are hiding now, if they hurt Walt after this point, they are just was well claiming there could be scum Seraphim still alive...
You must argue on the merits of their play, and not their role to confirm them at this point.
I disagree. A scum Ophan can be used to track other Ophan and determine whether it's safe for another member of the scum team to target a player with rage points.vIQleS wrote: (mainly because there's no point to a scum ophan - except as a 'safeclaim' of course...)