Open 130 - Vengeful Mafia (Over!) before 762

[TDC]

I think we should look back on MoS if we find an obvious townie.

If we find an obvious townie we'll not lynch him anyway (and he'll not get vigged either), so what's the point of making him MoS?

I don't think suggesting it would count as a tell though - I've not read through the whole thing, 'cos I'm lazy, but I imagine it would be pretty risky for scum too.

How is it risky?

Emp - If using the MOS idea doesn't change the town's chances of winning, why are we looking at how long it took zwet to disagree with it? Surely neither scum nor town would have a motive to agree (Or otherwise) with it?

Well, that's assuming he knew it would make no difference..

Three players hat me and want me lynched everygame I'm in.

i've nevah play'd in a game wit u b4 dawg... wich 3 playaz alwayz want u lynch'd?

One is obviously zwet, the other two are not in this game. I assume they are in the other game I'm in with emp.

i am becuming suspicious of tdc yo
he still haznt rly givin an opinion on ne1 & haz only done theery talk. dat seems scummy to me yo

Who has given an opinion on anyone?

[molestargazer]

Well, that's assuming he knew it would make no difference..

At the time that Emp posted that, you yourself had posted that it would make no difference several posts earlier - and that analysis had been posted a few before that.
Despite my vote on Empking being random, I'm quite happy with it right now, on the little we have to go off on everyone.

How is it risky?

No matter which way the scum play it, they still have a chance of losing a member / the godfather.

[TDC]

But the chance is there without it, too.

Or are you saying the chance is higher, because then you should actually be in favour of using the plan.

[molestargazer]

No, I'm saying they're the same. I think it's not a tell to either push for or denounce the plan if the odds are equal.

[TDC]

I agree, but how can it be a risky move then?

[molestargazer]

There's always risk for the scum that one of them is going to be lynched. I don't mean it's more risky - but the chance is still there.

[Empking]

Three players hat me and want me lynched everygame I'm in.

i've nevah play'd in a game wit u b4 dawg... wich 3 playaz alwayz want u lynch'd?

I'd rather not say.

Mole; Do you honestly think that waiting forever to get a read on what town wants and then agreeing with the town isn't a scum tell?

[Killah Nine]

i am becuming suspicious of tdc yo
he still haznt rly givin an opinion on ne1 & haz only done theery talk. dat seems scummy to me yo

Who has given an opinion on anyone?

dat prolly came out wrong

i mean peeps seem to be questinin each otha to try to figure each otha out n u keep askin q's about da mos plan

havin sed that i reread the thred and zwet is guilty of dis too so itz not jus u

[molestargazer]

Mole; Do you honestly think that waiting forever to get a read on what town wants and then agreeing with the town isn't a scum tell?

I certainly see where you're coming from. However, I can't shake the feeling that

in this case

of MoS, it's fairly irrelevant, since even if he had disagreed, it wouldn't have been a scumtell in my eyes.

[Empking]

Mole; Do you honestly think that waiting forever to get a read on what town wants and then agreeing with the town isn't a scum tell?

I certainly see where you're coming from. However, I can't shake the feeling that

in this case

of MoS, it's fairly irrelevant, since even if he had disagreed, it wouldn't have been a scumtell in my eyes.

But from Zwet's eyes it might've been "better safe than sorry"

[molestargazer]

It might.
I suppose he'd better post and explain. It might be interesting.

[zwetschenwasser]

TDC, what are your thoughts on mole's parroting?

[Empking]

It might.
I suppose he'd better post and explain. It might be interesting.

Plus there's the fact that he posted and didn't explain.

[TDC]

Whom do you think is he parroting?

[molestargazer]

TDC, what are your thoughts on mole's parroting?

?

[zwetschenwasser]

It might.
I suppose he'd better post and explain. It might be interesting.

Parroting Empking.

[molestargazer]

Uh.. no. Was just posting what I thought at the time.
Certainly wasn't intended to copy anyone.

[zwetschenwasser]

Well, hey! You did.

[Killah Nine]

i think i undahstand wut zwet is talking bout yo

i do find it weird that molestargazer was defendin zwet 4 a bit here:

Mole; Do you honestly think that waiting forever to get a read on what town wants and then agreeing with the town isn't a scum tell?

I certainly see where you're coming from. However, I can't shake the feeling that

in this case

of MoS, it's fairly irrelevant, since even if he had disagreed, it wouldn't have been a scumtell in my eyes.

but then wehn empking ask'd him anotha question he flipp'd his opinion about da whole issue n said that zwet's response wud be interestin here:

It might.
I suppose he'd better post and explain. It might be interesting.

y's mole changin his opinion bout da whole thing rite away yo?

[Empking]

Zwet; Answer the question.

[molestargazer]

zwet's response wud be interestin here:

Precisely. I was arguing that it was not a scumtell - I never said that zwet's response wouldn't be interesting. It certainly is giving us information right now, such as the fact that Zwet's seemingly avoiding answering.

[TDC]

I find mole's claim that Emp's suggestion "would be risky for scum" (i.e. an argument for Emp being town) and subsequent back-pedal to

There's always risk for the scum that one of them is going to be lynched. I don't mean it's more risky - but the chance is still there.

more interesting than the zwet thing.
That is, if mole was scum, I'd be more inclined to think about Emp as his partner than zwet.

[molestargazer]

I find mole's claim that Emp's suggestion "would be risky for scum" (i.e. an argument for Emp being town) and subsequent back-pedal to

There's always risk for the scum that one of them is going to be lynched. I don't mean it's more risky - but the chance is still there.

more interesting than the zwet thing.

I don't see how that's a back-pedal.
Risky = There is risk involved.
If scum chose it, there would be risk.

[TDC]

In the same spirit I could claim that using the letter "s" is risky.
Because you know, if you use it, you can get lynched.

[zwetschenwasser]

I endorse the above post.