Newbie 745 - Town wins!

[Gabe]

Well spinach I'm calling you out on a claim and if you convince me your town then I will be more willing to remove my vote on you

I'm curious: when did Spinach claim anything?

[Mufasa]

Well spinach I'm calling you out on a claim and if you convince me your town then I will be more willing to remove my vote on you

I'm curious: when did Spinach claim anything?

no I am asking for a claim, because I don't feel he has provided enough iinformation to prove he is town and not scum

[Family:Kostic]

I've read you just fine. You missed the point. It's very poor reasoning.

Careless voting? Poor reasoning? I think you have just displayed them in your last 2 posts more than I have..

So you admit that

your vote

is based on WIOFMY logic, yet you

cast it

anyways even after we mislynched D1, knowing that it's going to put us in a difficult spot on D3. I don't like how careless you're being with your vote.

I never even voted, therefore your vote is partially based on something I didn't even do. The rest of the reasoning you provided for your vote was also poor IMO. If voting to try to make an inactive player more active is poor reasoning, especially as it was the first day when ppl still had Random votes, then I would like you to tell me what good reasoning could be at that stage...

It seems that you just don't want to admit wrong.. Unless you can also show that I did vote Spinach today....?

[farside22]

I'm going to start looking to see if anyone needs to be prodded.

[Bladewing Vorox]

OK well, seams like an active bunch of people, Well here are my thoughts Spinach hasn't said anything, neko is away, Bladewing no clue, and Gabe really donno either. Been a bit inactive lately.

Spinach is currently in L-1 and hasnt said anything to save himself, in my opinion. Inactive? Hmm, I'm just not sure as of right now.

Sorry for my activity, I hadn't the time to post. I had a lot of things to do. I'll try to post tomorrow.

[farside22]

Vote count:

Spinch 3 votes: (neko2086, Bladewing Vorox, Mufasa)
Family: Kostic 1 vote: (hohum)

Not voting:

Gabe
Spinach
Family:Kostic


With 7 players it takes 4 to lynch

Prodding:
Bladewing Vorox

[Bladewing Vorox]

I responded before you prodded me. As I've said, I wasn't able to post before because I was busy.

Sorry I prodded as I posted.

[Spinach]

Well spinach I'm calling you out on a claim and if you convince me your town then I will be more willing to remove my vote on you

I'm curious: when did Spinach claim anything?

no I am asking for a claim, because I don't feel he has provided enough iinformation to prove he is town and not scum

You think that a few bolded words and a role makes a person town-sided? <_<.
But it is the only thing I can do, I mean, just bold a few words.

Claim: Townie/Villager.

Are you pleased now?

[neko2086]

unvote

first of all, not because I believe the claim, but because I don't know if I trust F:K when there's a L-1 sitting here.

Spinach's claim is really interesting, especially seeing as how there are no villagers in this game...

I actually probably wouldn't mind lynching spinach, but this is moving too fast.

[Spinach]

Heh-Heh, when I learned the game, they were called villagers, so it's remains of that slipping in. :P

[Mufasa]

unvote

first of all, not because I believe the claim, but because I don't know if I trust F:K when there's a L-1 sitting here.

Spinach's claim is really interesting, especially seeing as how there are no villagers in this game...

I actually probably wouldn't mind lynching spinach, but this is moving too fast.

Moving too fast? He's been on L-1 for 5 days now, ya moving real fast there. Plus I still don't find Fk suspicious

[Family:Kostic]

unvote

first of all, not because I believe the claim, but because I don't know if I trust F:K when there's a L-1 sitting here.

Maybe you should investigate that further to satisfy yourself then. I have nothing to hide and it would be good for others can see that also.

[neko2086]

Mod: requesting replacement

. Shouldn't be a surprise by now.

Sorry everyone. I really just don't see myself having time for this anymore, even when I get back home.

It's been fun.

[Bladewing Vorox]

Mod: requesting replacement

. Shouldn't be a surprise by now.

Sorry everyone. I really just don't see myself having time for this anymore, even when I get back home.

It's been fun.

Ah, too bad you're leaving. I hope the one who'll replace you will be as good player as you were.

By the way, I'm going to

unvote

. I only voted against Spinach to get him to talk. It doesn't mean that I'm believing him. If I have reasons to vote for him again, I'll do it.

[farside22]

Mod: requesting replacement

. Shouldn't be a surprise by now.

Sorry everyone. I really just don't see myself having time for this anymore, even when I get back home.

It's been fun.

Looking for replacement now.

[Gabe]

Well spinach I'm calling you out on a claim and if you convince me your town then I will be more willing to remove my vote on you

I'm curious: when did Spinach claim anything?

no I am asking for a claim, because I don't feel he has provided enough iinformation to prove he is town and not scum

You think that a few bolded words and a role makes a person town-sided? <_<.
But it is the only thing I can do, I mean, just bold a few words.

Claim: Townie/Villager.

Are you pleased now?

Mufasa: having somebody claim "I'm a townie!" isn't worth anything. If a player has a power role or is in the mafia, they try to keep it a secret. So this claim by Spinach isnt worth anything - he could still be in the mafia or be a doctor/police officer.

[farside22]

Kison replaces Neko. Lets give him a warm welcome!

[Gabe]

Welcome, Kison! Read up, and tell us what you think so far.

[Family:Kostic]

Hope you slide right in Kison, this has hardly been a normal game.. Lol

[Spinach]

Welcome Kison! Hopefully you will bring a little life to the game, as it has been slacking a bit lately. :-)

[Bladewing Vorox]

Hope you slide right in Kison, this has hardly been a normal game.. Lol

I agree with you.
By the way, welcome Kison !

[Kison]

I have to leave right now, but I wanted both to post that and inform you all that I am 95% through my read of the game. I don't have time to make a nice, long juicy post, but I will say I believe Bladewing Vorox's claim, mainly because of the timing and lack of inhibition - scum, especially a new player, would be more hesitant to claim doc because of the fear of counterclaiming.

I'll be back to post more in ~ two hours.

[Gabe]

You're gonna fit right in.

[Kison]

The way I see it, the fact that you (

Spinach

) were friendly with Bronco, and possibly knowing he was not Mafia, gives you every reason to Lynch him during the night...

Obviously, it is only WIFOM theory and should be taken with a pinch of salt as it holds no real evidence to you being or not being Scum.. Nevertheless I think you would be the type who would lynch a friend rather than an enemy in this situation..

Why do you think Spinach is the type who would kill his friend during the night? What makes you think he is not the type who would leave his friend alive? This looks to me like you are pushing his wagon without being on it, and for a rather weak reason.

I believe Spinach is scum, he was very quite day one, and he made the first jump on day 2. Spinach seemed to make himself look like Bronco's friend day one (from previous rounds) to make it seam to us to be impossible for Seamus to be Scum this time around.
Thererfore my vote is for

vote: Spinach

This is also very sketch, particularly because of the sudden conviction at the convenient time after which two votes were already placed on Spinach. Not to mention, the logic you use to justify your vote is practically nonexistent - even if, theoretically, Spinach was trying to make Seamus out to be an unlikely scum candidate, what makes you believe he is more likely to do this as scum rather than as town?

In fact,

Vote: Mufasa

, for that vote and for the day one cop drawing post. I may move this, because I'm still reading. I'm not particularly fond of Spinach's play, either, but that vote definitely makes me uneasy.

[Kison]

Unvote

Vote: Mufasa

Neko was already voting, and new votes don't count unless I unvote. Sorry.