Newbie 744 -- Game Over!

[Yaw]

Vote Count:

AshKetchummm (3): Dennis1993, Raivann, alexhans
alexhans (1): Boltrig
Kmd4390 (1): ZazieR
ZazieR (1): Kmd4390
Raivann (1): AshKetchummm

Not Voting: CntRational, syndromeofadown

5 to lynch.

[CntRational]

I want to get this going somewhere, so...

Vote:AshKetchummm

[ZazieR]

I so disagree with the above post.
First of all is the reason for putting Ash at L-1. It's just to get this game going, while there are lots of other ways to get this game going. Besides, CntR, what did you expect as response to this action?
Second, is that he didn't suspect Mizz at all, yet he's willing to put Ash at L-1. So far, I haven't seen any suspicions stated, except for the lurkers as lurkers make the game less fun, according to him. And even then, he misses them. So I'd like to hear who you suspect the most right now CntR.

Include that he didn't give arguments why he wanted to vote Mizz (see post 78), not responding to Mizz her posts and ignoring a question:

And I'd also like to know what according to you the difference is between your posts so far and those of Mizz.

So right now, I'll be happy with a

Unvote, Vote CntRational

Also

Mod

, what's the status of Boltrig? Could alexhans also be prodded as I saw that he was being replaced in a different game?

[Yaw]

blueshadow replaces Dennis1993.

Boltrig's on his 48 hours to post, as per the rules. Once those are up, if I haven't heard from him, I'll be replacing.

I'll get to alexhans when I do an overall lurker check a bit later.

[blueshadow]

Greeting, I just replaced Dennis1993.

Anyway, from what I've gathered I

vote Raivann

.

[Kmd4390]

CnT needs to explain that vote. One more vote on Ash is a lynch. Were you aware of this when you voted? Are you comfortable with it? Do you even suspect Ash.

Unvote, Vote CnT

blueshadow should explain his vote too, but I don't suspect him for the unexplained vote as it doesn't place Raiv at L-1 like CnT's vote on Ash.

[syndromeofadown]

wow, I haven't posted in a while. sorry guys

Greeting, I just replaced Dennis1993.

Anyway, from what I've gathered I

vote Raivann

.

Hi, welcome! What

have

you gathered? Care to explain your vote?

[AshKetchummm]

Well, I can't say I didn't "place a vote to get things going." because I did that on Raivann, but at least I gave my reasoning. After not really contributing much, and then just coming out of the blue with a vote to put me at L-1 is fishy.

I'll give you a chance to rebuttal with a valid reason before I put my vote on you.

I still think raviann isn't out of the water yet, until he comes up with a valid reason why he has been on the mizz/me bandwagon, and felt certain, but when confronted he says that it may be weak assumption.

Something better then.

"weak scumhunting"

So until then, my vote stays on Raivann, until I hear from Cnt again.

[blueshadow]

My reason is exactly the same as Ash's in #137.

And Raiv just disappeared without ansering the question in #139.

Maybe I'll change my mind after seeing how CntR responses to ZazieR's confrontation.

[Yaw]

alexhans and Raivann have been prodded (no posts for 5 days).

Looking for a replacement for Boltrig.

[Raivann]

Welcome blue
had problems logging on, anyways,

I still think raviann isn't out of the water yet, until he comes up with a valid reason why he has been on the mizz/me bandwagon, and felt certain, but when confronted he says that it may be weak assumption.

Something better then.

"weak scumhunting"

Actually I'm gonna get off this wagon
You two were my top 2 suspects and CntR wasn't posting much so i was trying to get him talking.

unvote

besides misquoting me and knowing what i'm thinking, Ash's play has been alot better than Mizz's, which is why my vote was cast in the first place.

My reason is exactly the same as Ash's in #137

Ash's reasons in #137 are weak sauce
FoS:blueshadow

Vote: CntR

putting ash at L-1 , especially with his reason to get things going, was scummy.

[blueshadow]

Ash's reasons in #137 are weak sauce

Maybe I was just trying to make you talking, who knows.

UNVOTE

since I've already saw your reply.

had problems logging on

Not a good reason.

So... FoS: Raivann

Now I

vote CntR

since he wanted to get this going that badly. Someone's just got to go first.

[Raivann]

Unvote

Don't want CntR hammered before he can reply

[Raivann]

Now I vote CntR since he wanted to get this going that badly. Someone's just got to go first.

Talk about itching for a quick lynch!

Blueshadow would you have hammered if CntR was at L-1 before you voted?

[blueshadow]

Talk about itching for a quick lynch!

Blueshadow would you have hammered if CntR was at L-1 before you voted?

I'm just talking about the truth.

Are you trying to scare me?

[Kmd4390]

blueshadow, the major point against CnT is that he put Ash at L-1 without much reasoning. You just did the same thing with your CnT vote.

[Raivann]

I believe blue would have hammered CntR if he could have, before CntR could even post. I don't like his reasoning for lynch either saying "someone's gotta go first" and I believe that blue is deserving of my vote

Are you trying to scare me?

Vote : blueshadow

boo!

[syndromeofadown]

Do you know what time it is? It's CRAZY THEORY TIME!!! with your host, syndromeofadown!

Just in case you wondered why I would not vote for him if he had 2 votes is that: Assuming that the first 2 voters aren't mafia and I place my vote on him, would leave him with Lynch-2, at which the scum could come and voterush him, leading to a waste of a day 1 lynch.

Cntr is afraid of l-2, stating that he doesn't want mafia to "vote rush" a townie, then later agrees with kmd that "it wouldn't be a waste. If scum let us find them that easy, we'd win no problem.", contradicting his vote rush logic. I'll get back to this later, but first, the other piece of the puzzle. I want bring something else to your attention. Someone's been on cntr's case more than anyone else in the entire game.

And I'd like to know from CntR, why he only mentioned Dennis, while Mizz also hadn't posted after she had voted.

I'd like to know what you (Mizz) think of CntR and Alex not voting in their first post of the day.

One player who did catch my attention is CntR. You might remember that he called Dennis out as he didn't post after his vote. Afterwards, he also saw that Mizz hadn't posted after her vote. But when she does post, he only states that he would vote her after waiting on a post (after those 3) as she pinged his scumdar. But he never stated why, and he didn't respond to her last post before she asked to be replaced. There's one other player that caught my interest with his response, but will get into him later.

However, CntR, who votes Mizz for lurking, but didn't mention Bolt at all, while he was worse, deserves some attention as well.

But CntR, how come you were saying that you'd vote Mizz (which was based upon lurking), but not Boltrig or Dennis? And I'd also like to know what according to you the difference is between your posts so far and those of Mizz.

Then comes,

I want to get this going somewhere, so...

Vote:AshKetchummm

This is what really pinged my scumdar. Remember when he didn't vote me in fear of l-2 and scum-rushing? Now he goes and puts someone at l-1 for no reason at all! And what makes this extra scummy is this:

I see that you[cntrational] were cautious as town in Newbie 709, so I won't hold it against you.

Does that look like a cautious townie move to any of you guys? Which brings up the question: Why would cntr do this if it was already established that he acts cautious as town? Would any (cnt) rational person really think that putting someone at l-1 just to "get the game going" would help himself or the town at all?

Then, of course, zazier was first to pounce on him and finally vote him (of course, why wouldn't she have voted him earlier considering how scummy she apparently thought he was)...

Which brings me to my final point. ZazieR was trying her best to get the town to vote cntr by constantly putting pressure on him. (And notice how cntr does little to defend himself?) And when nobody was following her, cntr votes ash to make himself look extra scummy so now zazier has an "excuse" to vote him.

So the crazy theory of the day is:

this is all a brilliantly set up bussing/distancing ruse, and ZazieR and CntRational are mafia partners.

[Yaw]

yellowbunny replaces Boltrig.

[yellowbunny]

Hi guys...just wanted to drop a line and say that I am here to replace Boltrig. I need to read all 7 pages so I will do so & post my impressions asap.

[AshKetchummm]

well, he hasn't responded and is probely hoping that some kind of distraction will come up...

I think this is the hammer vote, and you are most likely going to condemn me for it, but I think it's in the best interest of the town to get rid of someone who acts scummy, and places votes without any real reason sooo....

Unvote: Vote CntRational

[syndromeofadown]

It's not the hammer. it's l-1

[yellowbunny]

Whoa...okay, it seems to me that some people are jumping really quick on bandwagons w/o any concrete reasons...specifically Blueshadow and Ash.

Now I vote CntR since he wanted to get this going that badly. Someone's just got to go first.

I think this is the hammer vote, and you are most likely going to condemn me for it, but I think it's in the best interest of the town to get rid of someone who acts scummy, and places votes without any real reason sooo....


Unvote: Vote CntRational

Based on your posts, it seems like neither of you two are all that sure that CntRational is scum. Explain to me how a "Oh hell, lets just lynch someone already!" is very pro-town???

[blueshadow]

blueshadow, the major point against CnT is that he put Ash at L-1 without much reasoning. You just did the same thing with your CnT vote.

I know.

And yes, I did the exactly the same thing.

[blueshadow]

I believe blue would have hammered CntR if he could have, before CntR could even post. I don't like his reasoning for lynch either saying "someone's gotta go first" and I believe that blue is deserving of my vote

What can I say? A good job maybe ....

Based on your posts, it seems like neither of you two are all that sure that CntRational is scum. Explain to me how a "Oh hell, lets just lynch someone already!" is very pro-town???

Welcome, yellowbunny.

No its not even pro-town. Just like I said before, "someone's gotta go first".