Catch-up post(Note things as I see them)(Pages 1-10):
Post 30 - zwet: why are you pointing out that it's a joke post?
Post 31 - DGB: Not taking into account that it could be just personality in general? You seem real quick to name people town.
Post 32 - zwet: This looks like you're just trying to get on DGB's good side after her list post.
Post 34 - zwet: that's your entire defense? That's no defense.
Post 37 - UROE: semi-random? looks like a pretty good reason for a vote to me. No need to call it semi-random.
Post 39 - zwet: answer his question. Plus, "joke posts" are one of the best places to find scum.
Post 41 - DGB: Oh, what a surprise, DGB calling bussing this early. Was UROE bussing zwet with his early vote?
Post 43 - copter: really? you're listening to DGB on a bussing claim?
Post 55 - copter: actually, "getting out of the random stage" is exactly what we want to be doing. How is his attack crap? Looks pretty good to me.
Post 63 - Kevy: how is it trying to appear town as opposed to, you know, being town?
Post 74 - Kevy: This reads to me as "I think Tar is town but should be lynched because he is playing badly." Am I missing something? Plus, this game is very different from IRC. Optimal play is definitely not the same in both cases.
Post 75 - Kevy: First off, the "others did it, so I shouldn't be scummy/voted for it" fallacy. Then misrepping Tar's vote.
Post 81 - Tar: Maybe I should just replace out if there's going to be this much swearing at people. These are the games I hate.
Post 88 - Xtoxm: Why's this?
Post 89 - zwet: nothing to say on that whole exchange?
Post 92 - zwet: ok, nothing to say on that whole thing.
Post 96 - zwet: Wording of a question can be a scumtell. And what the heck are you talking about with the next two? vote hopping? maybe, but it's not really scummy on it's own. It depends on how it's done.
Post 102 - Phate: why? It's not a small IRC game, this game is huge, it won't work out so well
Post 104 - zwet: *headdesk* why are you trusting phate so readily
Post 121 - kscope: I have no idea what you are going for here.
Post 126 - zwet: ... where did he partially support it? He clearly stated that he thinks we don't need a massclaim.
Post 128 - UROE: How is listening to zwet convenient? rolebased, eh? and claiming that only a certain group will know what you're doing? This post doesn't feel right to me.
Post 142 - Vir:
FoS
. I don't particularly care if there's a jester. We lynch scummy people. Jester speculation is scummy and only serves to distract the town.
Post 148 - copter: What is with all the bussing accusations recently?
Post 161 - tubby: I2 that really all you have to say? An inane comment that adds nothing to the game?
Post 172 - kevy: "jokes" can be a great way to find scum.
Post 181 - copter: You don't have a backing for this. Of course he's going to want your reasoning.
Post 195 - armlx: This doesn't seem like armlx for some reason. You're too quiet, unless I've missed a boatload of posts you've made.
Post 200 - Phate: This isn't IRC mafia. This is an IRC setup, played on a forum. Huge difference. We can't use the same strategy.
Post 202 - zwet: ..............
Post 209 - Kevy: LOL @ "town should have a pretty good idea of what role a lynchee is if we're going to lynch them". What makes you say that, exactly? Because I have no idea how you could think that. Not everyone plays like Tar.
Post 219 - Tanarin: Looks like a strawman to me. I don't see him state anywhere that it's for opposing a massclaim.
Post 238 - tajo: Why
should
he claim?
Post 239 - phate: so what happend with suth?
my thoughts so far:
Tar-Kevy quabble: Tar is playing really aggressive and I think it's throwing Kevy off his game. Kevy's post 75 especially seemed pretty bad to me.
rofl seems town in that argument, although very, what's the best way of putting this? "rough".
I don't like that the IRC'ers are trying to turn this into an IRC game when it really isn't. IRC doesn't have this much talking, we can totally play a day game as well, the way it usually is in the forum, as opposed to the way it is in IRC.
zwet is really saying nothing, but saying it scummily. I wouldn't mind him being lynched.
That's it for right now, expect the rest later.
