Here; I'll try to inject some life with a PBPA (so much for my goal of NOT doing that)
This may be a ~little~ out of date:
LynchHimNotMe (rep. Zombie Monkey pregame)
As soon as he started posting, LynchHimNotMe has given off a very strong "follow the pack" vibe to me. His initial FOS on ZEEnon was basically a copy/paste of what I said about the same comment. His defence of the FoS seems logical enough, but then he chops down on ZEEnon and doesn't look like he's going to let go. His defense of Sironigus is really, really suspicious to me. The "follow the pack" vibe continues in [url="
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 57#1491657]Post 67[/url]; the "don't look at this as a scumtell" only strengthens the vibe. I'm not sure how I feel about the unvote from L-1; caution because of concern or the desire to feign concern? Also, I don't think there's much for ZEEnon to "explain," except maybe the switching of his possitions on the FoS. Really comes off as follow-the-pack and sound-pro-town. My day 1 scumpick team is LHNM and Sironigous.
zindionne
His first post is quite a bit after some real discussion had started. I'm not sure if he didn't read or what but his incredibly baseless vote on ZEEnon seems bizzare in context.
image
Right off the bat; I will say that image's 'random' vote and initial defence of that vote were, and are, suspect. The vote itself doesn't carry much weight, but the fact that he initially tried to defend the randomness of his vote smacks, to me, of overdefensiveness. I also really approve of going after lurkers.
He did, however, conduct himself in a logical manner after that, and it's my gut feeling that he's being genuine.
DIonized
His first vote, on image, seemed a little opportunistic (I understand that the same could be said of my vote on image). I like that he took his vote off image at L-1. FoS's everyone on page 3, in not so many words. But, he helps put pressure on Sir (kinda), which is good (kinda).
IronTurkey
Lynch all FOS-ers is an odd policy to stick to, in general, but I don't hate it on page 2 at all.
Sironigous (rep. BLEEPBLOOP/astrosquibb pregame)
Like I intimated before; his quick jump on the leading wagon, with no explanation, is scummy. I've done the same thing myself in at least half the games I've been in so far here, but you know, some of those times I was scum.
Xtoxm
Has been extremely brief with us. I'd like to hear more from him.
As an IC, I'd like to give you all some advice (it applies more to some than to others); lay off the personal attacks and insults. They are, at best, simply anti-town and, at worst, make the game not fun to play. They also wont make you any friends (at least not the kind you should want to have).
