Mini 709 - Musical Mafia - (Game Over!)

[RestFermata]

How can you call that chainsaw defense when I've been saying I wanted to look at you after corporate since yesterday? And you're still doing that "If X is town, Y is scum" thing that you say is scummy, by the way.

Vote Count:
Gamma - (0)
Knight of Cydonia - (0)
magisterrain - (0)
My Milked Eek - (0)
RestFermata - (0)
Trumpet of Doom - (4) Gamma, Knight of Cydonia, Wall-E, WhereIsTony
Wall-E - (0)
WhereIsTony - (2) Rest Fermata, Trumpet of Doom

With 8 alive, 5 votes will end the day.

[WhereIsTony]

i was not talking about you. I was talking about ToD.
claiming miller

[RestFermata]

Oh, the other chainsaw defense. I thought you were talking about the Tarhalindur version.

Anyway, I can understand why a bari sax might be a miller, but I can tell that ToD knows enough about music to make that up convincingly.

FoS

, just for that, but I sure as hell don't want to hammer until we've talked about this more.

[Gamma]

Because ToD is scum

[Knight of Cydonia]

I wouldn't discount the possibility of a miller, but every other game I've played here with a miller, that miller has claimed D1 to avoid problems like this.

[WhereIsTony]

I have also never seen a "implied miller"

[Gamma]

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saxophone

The saxophone (commonly referred to simply as sax) is a conical-bored transposing musical instrument considered a member of the woodwind family.

Saxophones are usually made of brass

and are played with a single-reed mouthpiece similar to the clarinet. The saxophone was invented by Adolphe Sax in 1841, and patented in 1846 in two groups of seven instruments each. Each series consisted of instruments of various sizes in alternating transposition. The series pitched in B♭ and E♭, designed for military bands, has proved extremely popular and most saxophones encountered today are from this series. A few saxophones remain from the less popular orchestral series pitched in C and F.

[RestFermata]

Yes, they're made of brass but they are not a "brass instrument". They are a member of the woodwind family, which you just said. That's why I can understand it being a miller, especially if the "cop" role is flavored to something like "PM me the name of a player and I will tell you what material his/her instrument is made of". However, I'm wary of claimed millers in general, especially "implied" millers, because that seems like playing both sides. Especially since ToD is a musician, so he would know that bari sax would be a good instrument for miller.

[WhereIsTony]

Well if nothing else we are getting a musical education.

[Wall-E]

Yes, they're made of brass but they are not a "brass instrument". They are a member of the woodwind family, which you just said. That's why I can understand it being a miller, especially if the "cop" role is flavored to something like "PM me the name of a player and I will tell you what material his/her instrument is made of". However, I'm wary of claimed millers in general, especially "implied" millers, because that seems like playing both sides. Especially since ToD is a musician, so he would know that bari sax would be a good instrument for miller.

Are you mental?

A saxophone is clearly brass.

Vote: RestFermata

[Wall-E]

I will also gladly HAMMER Trumpet of Doom, given the opportunity.

[RestFermata]

No. Are you really arguing with me? I am in my university's jazz band. When the director says, "BRASS, play this package," it means "trombones and trumpets, not saxophones." Saxophones are woodwinds. It says so in the passage Gamma quoted.

I'm not saying ToD is surely not scum, but if ToD is scum, he is LYING about being a saxophone because a saxophone is a woodwind instrument, even though it is made of brass. Look it up.

[Gamma]

ToD could also be a traitor.

just sayin'.

[RestFermata]

Gamma, I was actually thinking the same exact thing during class today.

[WhereIsTony]

traitor is not a possibility i had considered.

but it makes his pressing on netlava seem odd.

[Wall-E]

Unvote

[RestFermata]

Wait...did i really say "play this package"? I meant "passage." I was in a big hurry. Haha.

[My Milked Eek]

However, if, as the daystart flavour implies, Gamma is also unkillable, that leads me to think Serial Killer.

Blame my foreigness, but how?

I have reasons.

Oh really?
A = B. come on, spill your beans, or so I've heard them say on the tube.

Now, the lack of a Gamma kill could be any number of things, and I'm not going to rule any of them out. But in light of Tony's change of tune about the RB'er, I'm inclined to believe it was a mafia RB.

I'm with RF on this matter. ToD being alive does not imply ToD being some kind of un-Nk-able scum/sk/voodoo man.


Replying to rest tomorrow.

[RestFermata]

Why did you unvote, Wall-E? Can you stop being cryptic for 5 seconds?

[WhereIsTony]

I still don't see where I have changed my tune.

[Wall-E]

I have reasons.

Oh really?
A = B. come on, spill your beans, or so I've heard them say on the tube.

Not telling without a good reason.

[Wall-E]

Why did you unvote, Wall-E? Can you stop being cryptic for 5 seconds?

Is a saxophone made of brass, the metal?

[Wall-E]

That didn't make sense.

Let me restate myself:

Yes, I'm being cryptic about something. No, it has nothing to do with your unvote. I unvoted you because a saxophone is not classified as a wind instrument. I retract my earlier post.

[Wall-E]

Rather, it IS classified as a woodwind, probably because of the wooden reed.

[Wall-E]

Five posts in a row zinga zinga woot woot